UK case law
AC & AA Limited v The Pensions Regulator
[2026] UKFTT GRC 1316 · First-tier Tribunal (General Regulatory Chamber) – Pensions · 2026
The verbatim text of this UK judgment. Sourced directly from The National Archives Find Case Law. Not an AI summary, not a paraphrase — every word below is the original ruling, under Crown copyright and the Open Government Licence v3.0.
Full judgment
Background
1. AC & AA Limited ('the Employer') challenges a Fixed Penalty Notice ('FPN') issued by the Respondent ('the Regulator') on 14 October 2025 under Notice number 177258959580 and an Escalating Penalty Notice ('EPN') dated 13 November 2025 under Notice No. 205957102309.
2. The penalties were imposed following the Employer's failure to comply with an Unpaid Contributions Notice ('UCN') issued on 19 August 2025 requiring payment of outstanding pension contributions and the provision of evidence of compliance by 29 September 2025.
3. Following the Employer's out-of-time request on 30 December 2025 for a review of the FPN and EPN, on 5 January 2026 the Regulator confirmed both notices after a review on its own initiative.
4. On 29 January 2026, the Employer appealed to the Tribunal, seeking an oral hearing and giving contact details of its sole director, Arslan Riaz Chaudhry.
5. The evening before the appointed date of the oral hearing on 14 September 2026, Mr Chaudhry emailed the Tribunal to apologise that, due to his ongoing health issues, he was not in a fit state to attend. He added he is not a lawyer, could not afford to instruct a lawyer to represent him and that he had already explained the reasons for the delay in appealing.
6. Mr Chaudhry asked the Tribunal to take the circumstances and reasons set out in his appeal letter into consideration and show leniency and understanding.
7. The Regulator's representative attended the oral hearing at the appointed time, and consented to the Tribunal deciding the matter on the papers. Given the contents of the Mr Chaudhry's email and the absence of any request for adjournment of the hearing, the Regulator's representative agreed with the Tribunal's interpretation of that email as consent on the Employer's behalf to the matter being decided on the papers.
8. Given both parties' consent, the Tribunal decided the matter was suitable for determination on the papers in accordance with Rule 32 of The Tribunal Procedure (First-tier Tribunal) (General Regulatory Chamber) Rules 2009.
9. The papers comprise a bundle of 177 pages of evidence and submissions by both parties together with a 12-page response by the Regulator dated 11 March 2026. The Appeal and Response
10. The Employer's appeal grounds are, in summary: (a) The Employer did not receive the UCN, FPN or EPN. The first communication it recalls receiving in relation to the penalties was an email from the Regulator dated 30 December 2025. (b) The Employer believes that earlier notices may have been sent to a previous or incorrect working address. (c) There was no deliberate or malicious intention to avoid compliance with pension obligations. (d) Delays in payment resulted from a combination of cash-flow difficulties, direct debit and account issues, staffing changes and administrative problems experienced by the Employer and/or its accountants. (e) The outstanding contributions were ultimately paid. (f) The total penalty of £5,400 is disproportionate and imposes a significant financial burden upon a small business.
11. In a subsequent reply, the Employer repeated that it had not received the enforcement notices, questioned whether there was proof of actual delivery and relied upon the difficulties experienced by its business during the relevant period.
12. In its response dated 11 March 2026, the Regulator opposed the appeal on the basis that the above grounds do not amount to a reasonable excuse for failing to comply with the UCN.
13. The Regulator states that: (a) On 4 August 2025, it received a report from the Employer's pension provider ('NEST') about unpaid pension contributions for the period 1 February 2025 to 30 June 2025. (b) On 19 August 2025, the Regulator issued a UCN requiring the Employer to calculate, pay and provide evidence of payment of the outstanding contributions by 29 September 2025. (c) The Employer failed to comply with the UCN within the specified period. (d) The Regulator therefore issued the FPN on 14 October 2025, and subsequently the EPN on 13 November 2025. (e) All notices and letters from the Regulator were issued to the Employer's registered office at 14 Highfield Road, Tunbridge Wells TN4 9BB, which was also the address recorded for the Employer at Companies House, supplied in the Employer's re-declaration of compliance and used by the Employer in its Notice of Appeal. (f) The Employer has produced no evidence capable of rebutting the statutory presumptions of service. (g) Information obtained by the Regulator from NEST demonstrates that contribution schedules were repeatedly submitted late and that several payment attempts failed before being successfully re-submitted months later. (h) NEST was unable to identify any correspondence from the Employer reporting the alleged direct debit difficulties. (i) Based on the evidence provided, the reasons advanced by the Employer do not amount to a reasonable excuse for failing to comply with the UCN. Findings of fact, consideration and decision The facts
14. Based on all the evidence, the Tribunal finds the following facts proved on the balance of probabilities: (a) The Employer is a private limited company incorporated under the name AC & AA Limited and is the employer for the purposes of the Pensions Act 2008 (' the Act '). (b) Since 2019, the Employer has been making pension contributions to NEST. (c) Since April 2022, the Employer's registered office has been 14 Highfield Road, Tunbridge Wells, TN4 9BB. (d) On 4 August 2025, NEST reported to the Regulator that pension contributions for the period 1 February 2025 to 30 June 2025 remained unpaid. The Employer had almost 30 employees and the contributions due were £552.46 by the Employer and £736.47 by employees. (e) On 5 August 2025, the Regulator emailed the Employer warning that enforcement action could be taken if payment of pension contributions remained outstanding. (f) On 19 August 2025, as the contributions remained unpaid, the Regulator issued the UCN. (g) On 8 September 2025, the Regulator sent the Employer a reminder email about the unpaid pension contributions. (h) The following day, contributions relating to February, April and May 2025 were paid. (i) On 22 September 2025, contributions relating to June 2025 were paid but those relating to March 2025 (comprising £90.63 by the Employer and £120.82 by the employees) remained outstanding until 22 December 2025. (j) At the UCN deadline of 29 September 2025, the Employer had not fully complied with the requirements of the notice because the March 2025 contributions of just over £210 remained unpaid. (k) On 14 October 2025, the Regulator issued the FPN imposing a penalty of £400. The notice required payment and full compliance with the UCN by 11 November 2025. (l) The Employer did not achieve full compliance by 11 November 2025. (m) On 13 November 2025, the Regulator issued the EPN requiring full compliance by 10 December 2025 and providing for an escalating penalty of £500 per day thereafter. (n) The Employer remained non-compliant on 10 December 2025, so the escalating penalty began to accrue on 11 December 2025. (o) The Regulator subsequently calculated the accrued escalating penalty at £5,000 reflecting ten days' accrual at £500 per day between 11 and 20 December 2025. (p) On 22 December 2025, the March 2025 contribution was paid meaning all contributions within the scope of the UCN had been paid by that date. (q) On 30 December 2025 the Employer requested a review of the penalties. This request was made outside the statutory 28-day period but, on 5 January 2026, the Regulator nevertheless conducted a review on its own initiative and confirmed both the FPN and the EPN. (r) On 6 January 2026, the Regulator issued a letter before action seeking payment by 5 February 2026 of the FPN and EPN aggregate penalties of £5,400. (s) On 29 January 2026, the Employer lodged its Notice of Appeal with the Tribunal. (t) During the appeal process, NEST informed the Regulator that it held no record of correspondence from the Employer about alleged direct debit difficulties. It further reported that a failed collection had occurred because a direct debit mandate was not held. Consideration
15. The Employer does not challenge that the UCN, FPN and EPN were issued and sent by the Regulator: it simply denies that any of them was received.
16. There is no suggestion or evidence of any previous problems with post addressed to the Employer's registered office.
17. The Employer suggests a possible explanation for non-delivery and/or non-receipt of the Regulator's notices and correspondence is that they were sent to a previous or incorrect working address. However, each of the Regulator's notices and letters is clearly addressed to the Employer's registered office address at 14 Highfield Road, Tunbridge Wells, TN4 9BB.
18. The Tribunal considers the Employer's simple denial of receipt is insufficient to overturn the statutory presumptions that a notice correctly addressed to a company's registered office is both delivered and received at that address. As Judge O'Connor said at paragraph 22 of his decision in J.M Kamau v The Pensions Regulator [2025] UKFTT 484 (GRC) , where notices have been sent by the Regulator 'to the proper address...even though they did not reach the hands of [the director], the appellant has not rebutted the presumption that the notices were, as a matter of law, received.'
19. Moreover, the Employer has not explained why it did not receive emails from the Regulator dated 5 August 2025 (advising that NEST had reported unpaid contributions from February to June 2025) and dated 8 September 2025 (advising of the approaching UCN deadline of 29 September 2025) which would at least have alerted the Employer to the outstanding contributions. Both these emails were sent to the Employer's current email address, since used by the Employer to communicate with the Tribunal.
20. Despite the Employer claiming that it did not receive any notices, letters or emails from the Regulator before the debt-chasing email of 30 December 2025, the Tribunal accepts that the Employer did in fact pay four of the five months' unpaid contributions before the UCN deadline of 29 September 2025.
21. Had the fifth remaining unpaid contribution payments (for the month of March 2025) also been paid by that date, no penalties would have been imposed. However, that final missing contribution was not paid until 22 December 2025.
22. The Tribunal finds that, as the UCN was not fully complied with by the deadline, the Regulator was entitled to issue the FPN on 14 October 2025.
23. The Tribunal likewise finds that the Employer's failure to comply with the FPN, by the clearly stated deadline of 11 November 2025, entitled the Regulator to issue the EPN on 13 November 2025.
24. The Employer has claimed that cash-flow difficulties, direct debit and account issues, staffing changes and administrative problems (of its own or its accountants) caused its inadvertent failure to pay the contributions on time rather than any deliberate intention to evade its statutory obligations. However, no further details nor any documentary evidence of these difficulties have been provided to the Tribunal.
25. The Tribunal observes that even if an employer engages third party professionals to assist with its statutory obligations relating to employee pensions, it remains the employer's responsibility to fulfil its obligations on time and in full .
26. Further, the Tribunal's position is that eventual compliance does not excuse earlier non-compliance: the deterrent effect of penalty notices would be much diminished if notices were revoked once compliance was eventually achieved. In this case, the Employer had been non-compliant - as regards payment of the March 2025 contribution - for nearly six months.
27. Moreover, even in the absence of notices or reminders from the Regulator, the Employer should have been aware of its statutory responsibility to make monthly pensions contributions and should have realised that its previous attempts to pay had failed. Decision
28. In the Tribunal's judgment, the Employer has given no reasonable excuse for failing to pay the March 2025 pensions contributions on time, or at least within the extended deadlines granted by the various notices from the Regulator.
29. The Employer has not explained why - despite various administrative and financial problems of its own and its accountants - it was able to pay four of the five months' outstanding contributions within the deadline of the UCN, but not the fifth. That failure may have been an administrative slip or other oversight - but the fact remains that the Regulator was entitled to serve the FPN, imposing a penalty of £400 as full compliance was not achieved by 11 November 2025.
30. The amount of the penalty is fixed by law so the Tribunal cannot reduce it below £400.
31. As regards the EPN, the Tribunal notes that the daily rate of the penalty is prescribed according to the number of employees - £500 being the rate for an employer with 3-49 employees.
32. The Tribunal regards the Regulator's ability to impose an EPN as an important enforcement tool when an employer remains non-compliant - and has failed to communicate with the Regulator - despite the issue and service of a UCN, FPN, reminder letters sent to the employer's registered office and emails sent to a current email address.
33. However, in this case, while it is disappointing that neither the Employer nor its accountants contacted the Regulator to explain alleged difficulties with calculating or paying pensions contributions, in fact the Employer had largely complied with the UCN by the deadline. Moreover, there is no suggestion of any pattern of previous non-compliance by the Employer.
34. This, coupled with full compliance by payment of the outstanding contributions amounting to little over £210 within two weeks of the escalating penalty beginning to accrue, leads the Tribunal to conclude that slightly extending the compliance period of the EPN would provide a fair and reasonable further opportunity for compliance.
35. The Tribunal accordingly varies the EPN to state a compliance date of 19 December 2025 (instead of 10 December 2025) with the consequence that the accrued escalating penalty is reduced from £5,000 to £1,000. The Tribunal considers this a fair and proportionate penalty in all the circumstances of this case while respecting and maintaining the statutory importance of an escalating penalty notice when all other enforcement tools have failed to secure full compliance.
36. If paying the aggregate FPN and EPN penalties of £1,400 would cause the Employer hardship, it can approach the Regulator to discuss possible payment terms.
37. The Tribunal confirms the FPN and varies the EPN as stated above.
38. The matter is remitted to the Regulator. No directions are necessary beyond reduction of the EPN penalty from £5,000 to £1,000. Signed: Judge A. Marks CBE Sitting as a First-tier Tribunal Judge Date: 14 September 2026