UK case law

Apple Inc & Ors v Powermat Technologies Ltd

[2026] EWHC PAT 2458 · High Court (Patents Court) · 2026

Get your free legal insight →Email to a colleague
Get your free legal insight on this case →

The verbatim text of this UK judgment. Sourced directly from The National Archives Find Case Law. Not an AI summary, not a paraphrase — every word below is the original ruling, under Crown copyright and the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Full judgment

MR. JUSTICE MEADE:

1. I am dealing with Powermat’s application for specific disclosure from Apple concerning the Via LA licence. The current position as to what is sought is set out in Mayer Brown's letter of 16th September.

2. Request 1 in a modified form is agreed. That relates to communications about the licence, in other words documents known to both sides to the negotiations. Mr. Eustace has put down a marker that the date limitation might be revisited by Powermat in the context of Mr. Lim’s fourth statement. I note the marker, although I do not understand it and I do not intend to adjust the disclosure that is given now or in the future because of any frustration or disappointment I might feel with the way that Apple's evidence was put forward. That would not be appropriate, but in any event I do not need to rule on that today.

3. Request 2 is: “All other documents relating to the Via LA Licence, in particular internal memoranda and communications relating to (but not limited to) negotiation of Attachment 3A up to the date of the final signature of the Via LA licence ”.

4. The Via LA licence, it cannot be disputed, is of absolutely central importance to Apple's case and to the proceedings as a whole. Powermat has a pleading that, I paraphrase, the Via LA licence to Apple is a bespoke agreement which is – and I pass no judgment on whether it is correct or not, I am simply paraphrasing Powermat’s allegation – which is synthetic and strategic and intended to reach a non-RAND result for use as a comparable in these proceedings. That may or may not be so, but it is clearly pleaded in paragraph 101 of Via's pleading (in particular), and I am satisfied that it is adequately supported, first of all to take forward to trial and, secondly, to support requests for an appropriate degree of documentation.

5. I do not accept that a substitute for it is the negotiating documents which are agreed in relation to point 1 of Mayer Brown’s letter. It is a different and additional point. Although in general in FRAND cases the UK courts have set their face against internal documents of this kind being disclosed, it has been done to a limited degree on a few occasions. This is an exceptional one, I think, because of the centrality of the Via LA situation itself and because of the surrounding circumstances of the question of whether the Apple licence was bespoke or not.

6. On the other hand, the wording of the request: “All other documents relating to the Via LA licence” is obviously too broad and a better attempt could have been made to stipulate something meaningful. Reference has been made to various documents disclosed in litigation concerning Qualcomm and an attempt could have been made to describe those.

7. I am going to order that Apple is to go away and swiftly – I will hear submissions on the timing – and come up with its own proposal, as would have happened if there had been a fuller disclosure hearing, about internal documents which will reveal its strategy and intention in entering into the Via LA Apple licence agreement in the nature of (and this is just for guidance and not my formal order) the approval memo and at least surrounding presentations which will explain the strategy and objectives. I appreciate that these documents will be sensitive and confidential, but I accept Mr. Eustace’s submission that it is not a reason not to order their disclosure. If they are privileged, then they will not be inspected in due course, and I agree with Mr. Eustace on that front as well.

8. In summary, I agree that a proportionate amount of disclosure going to this issue and going beyond negotiations is appropriate, but what is sought is too broad and it is for Apple to come up with a workable proposal in short order. (For continuation of proceedings: please see separate transcript)

9. I am going to say June for the close of evidence, by which I do not include the joint experts’ statement. I imagine there is the risk of some slippage anyway, but whether or not that is the case, there are obviously possibilities for there to be procedural disputes following either round of evidence (in chief or in reply). Bitter experience tells me that trying do that during August and September can work very poorly and even if the parties have arranged their affairs so that everybody is available in August and September, there is the matter of the court’s availability.

10. I reject the submission that this action is expedited. The claim form was in March 2026 and we are talking about the second round of reply evidence in July 2027. There is a lot of money at stake, but I do not get the impression that this is at the moment of the absolutely highest complexity of these FRAND cases and I think it ought to be feasible to bring the evidence to the stage of reply by June.

11. The joint expert statement is a very big job. That can be done subsequently to June and time can be allowed for that. But that ought not to be a document which brings to the surface disputes that have not already crystallised. That is my decision on that.

12. In relation to the timing of the next CMC I will go for the later date because I can see that there could be consequences arising from my judgment if not in relation to the interim payment but in relation to disclosure. But I think there is probably going to be tidying up to do on the interim payment anyway and I am unsure when I will give my judgment. I will do it as quickly as I can obviously but I think the extra time in hand could be important. (For continuation of proceedings: please see separate transcript) - - - - - - - - - - - -

Apple Inc & Ors v Powermat Technologies Ltd [2026] EWHC PAT 2458 — UK case law · My AI Judge