UK case law
BMC Building and Landscapes Limited v The Pensions Regulator
[2026] UKFTT GRC 1321 · First-tier Tribunal (General Regulatory Chamber) – Pensions · 2026
The verbatim text of this UK judgment. Sourced directly from The National Archives Find Case Law. Not an AI summary, not a paraphrase — every word below is the original ruling, under Crown copyright and the Open Government Licence v3.0.
Full judgment
1. This is a reference against a fixed penalty notice (“FPN”) issued under section 40 of the Pensions Act 2008 (“ the Act ”) by the Pensions Regulator (“the Regulator”). The Regulator has invited the Tribunal to strike out the reference under Rule 8(2)(a). This is on the basis that the Tribunal does not have jurisdiction because no review has been undertaken by the Regulator.
2. Under Rule 8(2) of the Tribunal Procedure (First-tier Tribunal) (General Regulatory Chamber) Rules 2009, the Tribunal “must strike out the whole or a part of the proceedings if the Tribunal - (a) does not have jurisdiction in relation to the proceedings or that part of them; and (b) does not exercise its power under rule 5(3)(k)(i) (transfer to another court or tribunal) in relation to the proceedings or that part of them”
3. Under section 43(1) of the Pensions Act 2008 , the Regulator may review a fixed penalty and escalating penalty notice, “ (a) on the written application of the person to whom the notice was issued, or (b) if the Regulator otherwise considers it appropriate”. The prescribed period for a written application for a review under section 43(1) (a) is 28 days from the date of the notice.
4. Under section 44 of the Pensions Act 2008 , a person can make a reference to the Tribunal in respect of the issue or amount of a penalty notice. The conditions are that the Regulator has completed a review under section 43 , or “the person to whom the notice was issued has made an application for the review of the notice under ( section 43(1) (a) and the Regulator has determined not to carry out such a review” section 44(2) (b).
5. I have considered the background information provided by both parties.
6. The Regulator issued the Appellant with a Compliance Notice on 25 December 2025 and an FPN on 25 March 2026. The Appellant requested a review of the FPN on 28 April 2026. The Respondent declined to conduct a review because it had been received outside the 28-day time frame for doing so and declined to conduct a review on its own initiative.
7. The Appellant made a reference by way of form GRC1 which was dated 2 May 2025. Its grounds for appeal gave the following reasons why the decision was wrong: “We would like to respectfully explain that there was no deliberate attempt to avoid registration or fail to comply with any requirement. At the time, we were genuinely unsure whether the directors needed to be enrolled and did not fully understand the process for doing so. This was a misunderstanding rather than an intentional breach As soon as the issue was brought to our attention, we took it seriously and sought to clarify what was required. We recognise the importance of complying with all obligations and regret that this matter arose due to our lack of understanding We respectfully ask that you take into account the following: There was no intention to breach the rules. We were unclear on whether enrolment was required for both directors. We were unsure how to complete the enrolment process correctly. We are willing to take immediate steps to rectify the situation and ensure full compliance going forward. Given the circumstances, we kindly request that the fines be reconsidered and, if possible, reduced or withdrawn. We hope you will take a fair and sympathetic view, bearing in mind that this was an honest misunderstanding and not a deliberate failure to comply.”
8. The Appellant subsequently completed a Pensions: Right to Appeal form which was lodged with the Tribunal on 30 June 2026. This stated that the Appellant had not received the FPN and gave the following explanation: “I did not receive the original Penalty Notice and was therefore unaware that a penalty had been issued or that there was a 28-day period in which I could request a review. Had I received the notice, I would have acted immediately to resolve the matter and follow the correct process. At the time of the alleged breach, the company had recently appointed two new directors. As new directors, we were still familiarising ourselves with our legal responsibilities and relied on professional advice from our accountant. We were advised that there was no requirement to enrol into a workplace pension scheme at that stage. We acted in good faith based on that advice and had no intention of ignoring our statutory obligations. As soon as we became aware of the issue, we took immediate steps to understand our responsibilities and ensure the company complied with all requirements. There has never been any deliberate attempt to avoid our obligations or disregard the law. The company is a new business, and the penalty has a significant financial impact. We have always sought to act responsibly and honestly. The circumstances arose from a genuine misunderstanding, reliance on professional advice, and the fact that we did not receive the original Penalty Notice. In these circumstances, I respectfully ask the Tribunal to allow my appeal to proceed despite any procedural issues, so that the merits of the case can be properly considered. I believe it would be unjust to prevent the appeal where there was no deliberate non-compliance, no intention to avoid our responsibilities, and prompt action was taken once we became aware of the matter.”
9. The Regulator applied by way of form GRC5 dated 10 August 2026 for the reference to be struck out under rule 8(2)(a) as the Tribunal lacks jurisdiction. I directed on 13 August 2026 that the Appellant should respond to the application by 28 August 2026, but the Appellant did not respond. I am nevertheless satisfied that that the Appellant has had an opportunity to comment on the proposed striking-out under Rule 8(4).
10. The Regulator relies on the presumptions of service set out in section 303(6) (a) of the Pensions Act 2004 and Regulation 15(4) of the Regulations for the service of the FPN. It has provided evidence to show that the last known address of the Appellant was the registered office recorded at Companies House, which was the address to which the notices were sent.
11. I considered the Upper Tribunal authority in Philip Freeman Mobile Welders Ltd v The Pensions Regulator [2022] UKUT 62 (AAC) . This confirms that the presumption of service is not irrebuttable, and the rebuttable presumption of service applies to the question of whether a notice has been received for the purposes of the time limits for a review. Where there is a dispute about receipt of notices which may affect the relevant time limits, the evidence should be considered by the Tribunal.
12. The Appellant says that it did not receive the FPN. The Appellant said it would have acted sooner had it received the FPN.
13. In relation to the question of whether the Appellant received the FPN, the Appellant has not provided any evidence of circumstances that might have prevented delivery, simply asserting that it did not receive it.
14. The Regulator argues that the Appellant’s bare assertion of non-receipt is not sufficient to overturn the presumption of service, as was the finding of the Upper Tribunal in the case of London Borough of Southwark v Akhtar 2017 UKUT 150, where the Upper Tribunal stated at paragraph 82 that mere assertion of non-receipt was insufficient to rebut the presumptions of service provided by s.7 of IA78. This principle has been adopted by the First Tier Tribunal (General Regulatory Chamber), one case example being Keith’s Rubbish Clearance Limited v The Pensions Regulator (PEN 2020 0203) (judgment dated 8 April 2021) (‘Keith’s Rubbish Clearance’). In Keith’s Rubbish Clearance, Judge Hunter found that “ the Regulator is entitled to rely on the strong statutory presumptions...The Employer has made a bare “paper” assertion of non-delivery. That falls far short of the proof necessary to overturn the presumption ” (paragraph 32).
15. Having reviewed all the evidence before the Tribunal, I find that the Appellant has not put forward any case that would potentially rebut the presumption of service because, at the time the FPN was issued, it was issued to the Appellant’s registered office. This means there is no evidence about receipt of the notice in this case that needs to be tested at a hearing before the First-Tier Tribunal.
16. The Regulator also says that the Tribunal does not have jurisdiction because the conditions in section 44(2) of the Pensions Act 2008 are not met. The Regulator refers to the decision in Mosaic Community Centre Limited v Pensions Regulator (PEN/2015/0004) as showing that the Tribunal only has jurisdiction when a review under section 43 has been undertaken by the Regulator. The Regulator says there was no review in this case. There was also no refusal to carry out a review within the meaning of section 44(2) because the Appellant had not requested a review in the prescribed 28-day period which is set down in Regulation 15(1) of the Employers’ Duties (Registration and Compliance) Regulations 2010. The Regulator therefore says that the necessary conditions in section 44 to permit a reference to the Tribunal are not met.
17. It is clear from the information provided by both parties that no request for a review of the FPN was made within the 28-day time limit. The Regulator refused to conduct any review for this reason. This means that the conditions of Section 44 of the Pensions Act are not met.
18. The Tribunal does not have jurisdiction to consider this reference and so it is struck out under Rule 8(2)(a).
19. I remit the appeal to the Pensions Regulator and no further action is required. Signed: Judge Harris Date: 16 September 2026