UK case law
Claudette Maria Clarke v Ofsted
[2026] UKFTT HESC 1466 · Care Standards · 2026
The verbatim text of this UK judgment. Sourced directly from The National Archives Find Case Law. Not an AI summary, not a paraphrase — every word below is the original ruling, under Crown copyright and the Open Government Licence v3.0.
Full judgment
Application
1. On 7 th August 2025 the Appellant applied to register on the Early Years Register and both the CCR and VCR parts of the Childcare Register. Following a registration visit on 6 th November 2025, the Respondents served a Notice of Decision to Refuse Registration dated 13 th January 2026. The Appellant served an appeal on 12 th April 2026, the Tribunal issuing that appeal on 15 th April 2026. Attendance
2. Mrs Clarke attended for the hearing of her appeal. She was not legally represented. Her husband Carlton Clarke also came to the hearing but did not give evidence. The only oral evidence for the Appellant was given by Mrs Clarke herself.
3. The Respondents were represented by Counsel Mr Matthew Howarth. He called to give evidence Ann Austen, an Early Years Regulatory Inspector, and Emma McCabe, an Early Years Senior Officer. Late Evidence
4. No late evidence was filed, but the Appellant sent a Skeleton Argument to the Tribunal on 12 th October 2026. The panel did not receive it until the beginning of the hearing but took time to read it before the hearing commenced. Reporting Restrictions
5. At the outset of the hearing the Tribunal made an order under rule 14(1)(b) of the Tribunal Rules 2008 that that for the duration of the hearing there should be no publication of any matter a) likely to lead members of the public to identify any children or family members of children mentioned in the proceedings, or b) relating to the physical health of the Appellant. Recording of the Proceedings
6. Through the online CVP platform Care Standards hearings are routinely audio-recorded and members of the public thereby enabled to attend remotely. The system worked on the first day of the hearing. But due to a nationwide CVP outage it did not work at all on the second day. We explained the situation to Mr Howarth and Mrs Clarke; we saw no purpose in adjourning; with the agreement of the parties we did not do so. Background
7. Mrs Clarke lives in Houghton Regis, Bedfordshire. Her business - under the name of Happy Dayz Childminding - has taken place on the ground floor of her home address. She began working with children in 2001. She was first registered on the Early Years Register and the CCR and VCR parts of the Childcare Register on 26 th March 2008. Chronology a) 8 th October 2008. Inspection. Outcome: Satisfactory. b) 20 th March 2013: Inspection. Outcome: Good. c) 9 th December 2016: Inspection. Outcome: Inadequate. One strength was noted in that the Appellant had developed partnerships with other settings and schools and would share information with them on children’s learning. But the following issues were noted on the Childminder Report: • Failing to notify Ofsted of two assistants employed by her, with the result that the full procedure for assessing their suitability had not been completed. • Failing to implement appropriate or consistent behaviour management strategies. • Failing to ensure that the assistants knew what to do in case of an emergency; a particular concern, as Mrs Clarke was at times leaving them in sole charge of the children. • Weak supervision of the assistants. • Failing to assess and track children’s development so as to prioritise support. • Failing to challenge children in their learning. A Welfare Requirements Notice was issued requiring the Appellant to take specified remedial actions by 30 th December 2016. d) 15 th December 2016: An unannounced regulatory visit occurred after concerns raised by an older child. Outcome: It was noted that a first-aid certificate had lapsed and that the Appellant did not have certified up-to-date knowledge in the event of an emergency. This constituted an additional breach of the Early Years Foundations Stage [EYFS] requirements. e) 3 rd January 2017: An unannounced monitoring visit was made. Outcome: Mrs Clarke had satisfactorily addressed the concerns noted on both 9 th December 2016 and 15 th December 2016. f) 8 th June 2017: Inspection. Outcome: Good. g) 22 nd September 2021. An unannounced regulatory visit was made after an ex-employee of the Appellant raised concerns with Ofsted. Outcome: a Welfare Requirements Notice was issued, to be complied with by 11 th October 2021, the Appellant being notified that if it was not then she could be prosecuted and fined in relation to the following breaches of safeguarding and welfare requirements: • Two adults were caring for the children present; the Appellant was in her office on a telephone call; one of the adults was in the process of having their suitability checked by Ofsted; but neither had had their suitability checks fully completed and so should not have been allowed unsupervised contact with children. • Two young children were asleep in highchairs, which are not suitable for sleeping; they were not supervised as the adults were in an adjacent room; the Appellant had not provided appropriate facilities to meet the children’s sleeping needs. • Six children were sleeping in the back room, with three in travel cots, one on a sofa and two in highchairs; there were four more children playing in the front room; the Appellant told the inspector that she was aware of the shortage of free space for the children when they were all awake and playing; the Appellant had failed to take account of the necessary space requirements for small children. • The only available activity for children to play with consisted of wooden bricks scattered on the floor; the children had little interest in the bricks and were wandering around aimlessly; the Appellant had not provided suitable activity and resources to meet the needs of the children in her care. h) 11 th October 2021. Appellant’s Response to the Welfare Requirements Notice of 22 nd September 2021. In respect of the four points above the Appellant responded as follows: • The children are not now being left alone with the assistants at any time. • They are no longer letting children sleep in highchairs; all children now have a cot to sleep in, or mats. • She has included another room on the ground floor where the children can sleep and be monitored. This means that there will be enough space for all children when they are awake. • The two play spaces seen on the visit have since been totally overhauled and the rooms are now set up with designated areas for play with access to age-appropriate toys. A long workbench has been set up where the children can play with toys of their choosing, and playdough and drawing/writing materials are set out. i) 13 th October 2021. Inspection. Outcome: Requires Improvement. Some positives were noted; for example, it was stated that ‘ The childminder provides a safe and welcoming environment’ . It was noted too that the safeguarding arrangements were effective. But in respect of the Early Years Foundation Stage the areas for required improvement by 30 th November 2021 and noted in the Childminder Report included: • Ensuring that assessment information is used to create a curriculum tailored to the needs of each child. It was noted that activities did not always engage children; they would lose interest, behave poorly, run off and disrupt other children’s play. • Providing assistants with effective induction and supervision. • Ensuring that assistants have the knowledge and understanding of how children learn and developing their skills and interactions with them; ‘At times, assistants are unclear of what they want children to learn.’ j) 27 th September 2022. Inspection. Outcome: Inadequate. Some improvements since the last inspection were noted. But the following deficiencies in relation to the Early Years Foundation Stage and safeguarding were recorded: • Since the last inspection insufficient progress had been made to raise the quality of learning experiences for the children. The Appellant had not provided an adequate curriculum. The quality of teaching was poor in that the Appellant and her assistants continued to demonstrate a limited knowledge of what they wanted the children to learn, and frequently missed opportunities to extend their knowledge and understanding. • Staffing arrangements were ineffective; for example, the Appellant and her assistants were consistently overstretched when supporting distressed children. • The Appellant’s supervision and support of her assistants remained weak. She was not effectively encouraging assistants to develop their understanding of the curriculum and to improve their interactions with the children. • The Appellant was not ensuring that her assistants appropriately managed and that they supported the children’s feelings and behaviours. ‘On two occasions during the inspection, assistants were heard making inappropriate comments about the children in her care who were crying. This demonstrates extremely poor practice, and compromises children’s emotional well-being.’ • The Appellant had not ensured that all required records were retained and available for inspection. For example, she could not find her paediatric first-aid certificate, and the inspector was told that previously-completed accident report forms had been lost. A number of remedial steps were directed to be implemented by October of 2022. k) 22 nd March 2023. Inspection. Outcome: Inadequate. The inspector concluded that ‘The childminder has failed to address the actions raised at the previous inspection and no improvements have been made.’ Specific concerns raised about the Early Years Foundation Stage and safeguarding included the following: • The Appellant had taken on new assistants since the previous inspection. But she had failed to notify Ofsted about them and was already including them in her staff-to-child ratios. Because Ofsted had not been able to carry out the suitable checks, the children’s safety was not assured. Moreover, in working with three assistants for short periods of the day, the Appellant was at times working outside the terms of her registration. • Staffing arrangements remained ineffective. Because the Appellant and her assistants were busy meeting the general needs of a high number of children, the time available for meaningful interactions with children was minimised and the Appellant did not have time to support newer assistants. Furthermore the Appellant had not prioritised professional development for herself or her established assistant since the previous inspection. As a result, practice had not improved. • A number of children were frequently wandering around with little purpose to their play. There was at times minimal interaction with adults and the Appellant and her assistants were doing little to try to re-engage the children. • Although the Appellant knew the children she cared for, she was not using that knowledge to provide them with learning opportunities tailored to a particular child and their targets. For example, children of various ages were all playing together with playdough. Some were quickly losing interest. • Required documents were not available during the inspection. The Appellant was unable to demonstrate that she held a relevant and current paediatric first-aid qualification. She told the inspector that she had not yet provided new assistants with written guidance as to their roles and responsibilities, something which she accepted was part of her usual induction process. • Due to poor deployment of adults, instances of one child being unkind to another were sometimes not noticed. The Appellant was not addressing children’s poor behaviour when other children told her what had happened. Remedial steps were required to be taken by April and May of 2023. l) Undated: Appellant’s Response to Inspection Report of 22 nd March 2023. The Appellant stated: ‘I totally dispute that no improvements have been made since the last inspection’ and went on to give more detail. At the conclusion of her response the Appellant said that ‘Not addressing children’s poor behaviours when told what has happened is true in relation to what the Inspector saw but I know that the child involved always says this when they want what the other person has. Which was why it was not addressed at the time this is something we are working on with this child.’ m) 11 th April 2023. Welfare Requirements Monitoring visit. Outcome: Appellant was not complying with requirements. The Appellant was warned that if without reasonable excuse she did not take the actions specified by 18 th May 2023 she would be liable to prosecution and if convicted a fine: ‘We will check to make sure you comply with this notice’. The deficiencies noted included the following: • A continual failure by the Appellant to provide effective support, coaching and training for her assistants. Since the last inspection she had not completed her own induction process with newer assistants. Consequently they were not provided with clear guidance as to what was expected of them . ‘You confirmed that you are aware newer assistants do not know about the seven areas of learning and you employed them as they ‘appear to be good with children’.’ This was an action raised on 13.10.21, 27.9.22 and 22.3.23. This demonstrated that the Appellant lacked the capacity to make the required improvements. • Staff deployment remained poor. Children’s care and education needs were not being met. The Appellant’s more established assistant was continuing to complete routine tasks such as food preparation and was leaving the care of children to newer assistants who did not understand their roles and responsibilities. • The Appellant’s procedures for ensuring that only suitable adults worked with children were ineffective. She had submitted applications for two assistants. But Ofsted had not yet deemed them suitable. Despite having been shown the appropriate Ofsted guidance on the last inspection, the Appellant was continuing to use these assistants within her staffing ratios. Moreover, during the visit, one of the assistants was observed taking a child to the toilet unsupervised . ‘It is particularly concerning that you continue to place children at risk from adults whose suitability has not been confirmed. This shows your inability to meet and sustain the prescribed requirements for registration.’ n) May 2023: Ofsted began the process of Issuing a Notice of Intention to cancel the Appellant’s registration o) 10 th May 2023: During that process the Appellant instructed Ofsted that she wanted to resign her registration. p) 17 th May 2023: The Appellant resigned her registration. ***** q) 7 th August 2025: Appellant submitted a fresh application to register as a childminder on the Early Years Register and on both the CCR & VCR parts of the Childcare Register. r) 6 th November 2025: Ofsted registration visit conducted by Ann Austen. Ann Austen’s written evidence as to that important visit is contained within her first witness statement and appears specifically at pages C85 – C90 and C305-C328 of the hearing bundle. Recorded concerns arising during that visit centred around the Appellant’s perceived lack of a secure knowledge of the learning and development requirements. The EYFS requires learning in 7 areas. These areas are divided into 3 prime areas and 4 specific areas of learning: • The 3 prime areas consist of: ◦ Communication and language ◦ Physical development ◦ Personal, social and emotional development • The 4 specific areas of learning consist of: ◦ Literacy ◦ Mathematics ◦ Understanding the world ◦ Expressive arts and design Ann Austen’s particular concerns during the visit were as follows: • When she asked the Appellant to identify the 7 areas of learning within the EYFS, there was a period of silence before the Appellant replied, ‘The prime areas’ . She did not elaborate further. • The Appellant was unable to recall and discuss any of the 4 specific areas of learning. • Ann Austen asked the Appellant how she would support children’s development across the prime areas of learning, and in particular to give an example within the area of personal, social and emotional development. The Appellant asked her what this meant. Ann Austen re-worded the question, asking the Appellant how she would support a child’s independence and social skills. The Appellant was only able to respond by referring to children learning to eat properly and to sit around the table. When Ann Austen asked the Appellant how she would support a child to manage their emotions, the Appellant said that she would encourage children to share and take turns with other children. Ann Austen states that she would have expected the Appellant to elaborate and give broader examples. Ann Austen recorded a concern that during her previous registration the Appellant had in December of 2016 and September of 2022 breached the requirement to support children to manage their feelings and emotions. Overall Ann Austen recorded that the Appellant consistently hesitated in her responses, and demonstrated a lack of confidence and a very basic understanding of child development. • Ann Austen asked the Appellant to discuss her intended curriculum. Ann Austen had to re-word the question. Eventually, following prompting, the Appellant stated that she would encourage children to count their pieces of fruit at snack time. Ann Austen did not regard this as constituting a curriculum at all. • Ann Austen asked the Appellant how she would support children’s communication and language development. Again Ann Austen had to re-word the question. She asked the Appellant how, for example, she would support a baby’s language development. The Appellant said that she would share picture books and read stories. She could not elaborate further. In her first witness statement Ann Austen says that she would have expected the Appellant to comment, for example, on responding to babies’ sounds and visual expressions, as well as singing songs and sharing rhymes with them. • The Appellant told Ann Austen that she found it difficult to understand the terminology used in the EYFS and by Ofsted inspectors. Ann Austen felt however that the Appellant had in this respect insufficiently prepared for the registration meeting. Ann Austen concluded that despite the prompting and rephrasing of questions throughout the visit, the Appellant could not confidently explain how she would meet the most basic learning needs of the children in her care. According to the Appellant she was left with the impression that she had ‘passed’ the registration visit, although she accepted that that was not the word actually used. But the evidence of Ann Austen is that she told the Appellant she could not make a registration decision that day but would have to consider the situation further. It is evident that, particularly given the history, Ann Austen wished to discuss the case with her senior colleague Emma McCabe, an Early Years Senior Officer. Following that discussion and the involvement of another senior officer, it was decided that the Appellant’s application to register would be refused. s) 25 th November 2025: Ofsted’s Notice of Intention to Refuse Registration. Reasons for the refusal were given. Ofsted was not satisfied that the Appellant had demonstrated that she was able to meet - and continue to meet - all the prescribed requirements for registration. Ofsted relied upon the Appellant’s lack of appropriate knowledge at the registration visit of 6 th November 2025 and her poor inspection history when previously registered. t) 11 th December 2025: Appellant wrote to Ofsted objecting to refusal of registration. u) 15 th December 2025: Because the Appellant provided no detail in her objection letter, Ofsted wrote to her asking for further detail. v) 5 th January 2026: Appellant wrote to Ofsted objecting to the Notice of Intention to Refuse Registration. That letter states, firstly, that she disagreed that she had lacked confidence and had required prompting at the registration visit and, secondly, that Ann Austen had told her on the day of the visit that she was satisfied that she had passed on both EYFS and welfare but that Ann Austen would need to discuss the Appellant’s physical health [an area not now relied upon] with her manager before she could confirm it. w) 13 th January 2026: Ofsted issued Notice of Decision to Refuse Registration. x) 12 th April 2026: Appellant filed Appeal Against Refusal of Registration. Under paragraph G – The Result the Applicant is Seeking – the Appellant stated: ‘I no longer want to re-start childminding but I do not want to be barred from working with children in the future. I have looked after children for the past 23 years in one way or another. I do not know what I will do going forward but do not think it fair that after 7/8 visits from Ofsted inspectors over 15 years for 3-4 hours per time and no child ever being hurt or endangered in my care that they should stop me being around children.’ y) 14 th May 2026: Ofsted filed Response to Appeal Legal Framework
8. We bear in mind that the Appellant is not legally represented. But we have had the opportunity to read her comments on the Scott Schedule and her own Skeleton Argument, and we note that there is no disagreement between the Appellant and the Respondents as to the legal framework. In paragraph 12 of her Skeleton Argument the Appellant explicitly agrees with the Respondent that sections 35 , 54 & 62 of the Childcare Act 2006 require us to determine whether the prescribed requirements are satisfied and likely to continue to be satisfied. We set out the legal framework below: a) Early Years . Section 35(3) Childcare Act 2006 : Requires Chief Inspector to grant an early-years childminder application only where the applicant is not disqualified and it appears that the prescribed requirements are satisfied and are likely to continue to be satisfied. Where section 35(3) does not require grant, section 35(4) requires refusal. The prescribed requirements for an early-years childminder require that the applicant is suitable and will secure that the proposed childminding will meet the EYFS learning and development, and welfare, requirements. Appearing at pages C94-143 of the hearing bundle are the mandatory EYFS learning-and development requirements and safeguarding-and-welfare requirements. They are dated 14 th July 2025 and effective from 1 st September 2025. In relation to learning and development the 3 prime areas and 4 specific areas referred to in paragraph 7 r) above appear on page C101 of the hearing bundle. The safeguarding-and-welfare requirements are specified on page C109 and thereafter in the bundle. b) General Childcare Register . Sections 54(3)-(4) & 62(3)-(4) of the 2006 impose similar grant/refuse tests for Parts A & B of the General Childcare Register. The applicant’s suitability is also a prescribed requirement here. c) Evidence Relied Upon by Respondents in Relation to a) & b) above . In paragraph 31 of its Skeleton Argument the Respondent states: ‘The statutory basis for refusal is not identical across all three registers. For the Early Years Register, Ofsted relies in particular on the Appellant’s failure to demonstrate that she will secure compliance with the EYFS learning-and-development requirements. For Parts A and B of the General Childcare Register, Ofsted relies more broadly on the Appellant’s suitability, including the repeated failure to implement and sustain safe and effective childcare practice.’ d) Powers of Tribunal; Burden of Proof; Evidence : We accept the analysis of Mr Howarth as set out in paragraphs 9-11, and 33-35, of the Skeleton Argument: The Tribunal’s jurisdiction is statutory and limited. Under section 74(4) of the Childcare Act 2006 , on an appeal against refusal of registration the Tribunal must either: (a) confirm the refusal; or (b) direct that the refusal shall not have effect. The Tribunal therefore determines whether the refusal of registration should stand. It does not exercise a free-standing supervisory, advisory or declaratory jurisdiction beyond the powers conferred by section 74 ….. The Tribunal determines the appeal on the evidence available at the hearing and may consider material arising after the decision. The ultimate burden rests on the Appellant, as the person seeking registration, to demonstrate on the balance of probabilities that the prescribed requirements are met and are likely to continue to be met. In Jones v Commission for Social Care Inspection , the Court of Appeal held that an applicant must demonstrate fitness to the regulator and, on appeal, to the Tribunal. Ofsted’s policy states the same distinction between an applicant and an existing registrant. This is a forward-looking test. Experience, completed training, policies and historic improvement are relevant, but they do not displace the need to demonstrate present practical understanding and likely continuing compliance. The Tribunal is not required to wait for actual injury or developmental harm before refusing registration. Respective Cases of the Appellant & Respondent
9. Appellant . We have noted in paragraph 7 x) above the Appellant’s comment in her Appeal that she no longer wanted to re-start childminding. But in paragraph 6-11 of her Skeleton Argument she states that this is not the case and that she continues to seek registration as a childminder. In paragraphs 1-5 of her Skeleton Argument she accepts that concerns were identified during her previous registration and she does not seek to minimise them. But she contends that the Tribunal’s task is not to determine whether concerns existed in the past, but whether she is currently suitable for registration and whether the prescribed requirements are likely to continue to be met. In her Skeleton Argument she contends that: • The fact that in January of 2017 she had addressed concerns and in June of 2017 the inspection rated the outcome as good demonstrates that she is capable of implementing improvements and achieving compliance with EYFS requirements. • In respect of the registration visit of November 2025, the Appellant did not always use EYFS terminology. But the Tribunal should distinguish between recalling terminology in interview and applying child development knowledge in practice. Her identified evidence of good childcare practice provides a more reliable indicator of understanding than isolated answers given at a single registration interview. • In respect of the alleged lack of EYFS knowledge and the seven areas of learning, the curriculum documentation does expressly identify all 7 areas of learning and development, and shows evidence of planning across each of those areas. The Appellant relies upon practical evidence of support for children, together with curriculum documentation and planning for various activities. • The Appellant also relies upon the evidence in the hearing bundle of Sarah Woodward, Early Years Specialist SEND practitioner, as demonstrating modelling of strategies, provision of resources, collaboration in SEND planning and a positive response by the child in question. • Whilst recognising that their evidence is not a substitute for inspection evidence, the Appellant also relies on the positive comments made by parents in relation to communication, development, confidence, independence, learning opportunities, positive relationships with staff and progress towards developmental milestones. • Whilst fully acknowledging mistakes identified in visits during the previous registration period, the Tribunal must determine current suitability. The documentary evidence filed by the Appellant as to curriculum, assessment, induction, supervision and professional development shows that she has now fully addressed and rectified these mistakes. This demonstrates insight into previous concerns and a commitment to improvement. • The Respondent is placing too much emphasis on historic shortcomings and the interview of 6 th November 2025, and is giving insufficient weight to the evidence of improvement. In her closing submissions the Appellant additionally told us that: • Because she has not now childminded for some 3 ½ years her recollection of a lot of what she knew has been lost, as the evidence has shown. • But, childminding at home, you have written guidance to which you can refer; you have it all in front of you; she would have it in front of her when planning activities. • She has a lengthy career in childminding and her history shows that she is capable of improvement. She has taken stock following each identification of failings. • In relation to unvetted staff, she was relying on the Ofsted 14-day notification period. She uses that period to decide whether an assistant really wants to work with children. She did take up their references. Assistants were not being counted in staffing ratios.
10. Respondent . In his closing submissions Mr Howarth addressed us on what he submitted were the 9 key points: • Historic and continuing lack of knowledge about EYFS requirements. • Lack of context for documents submitted by the Appellant for her appeal. Mr Howarth submitted that they did not show how procedures will be implemented in the future. • Lack of preparation by the Appellant for her registration visit of 6 th November 2025. • The fact that, although in some cases the burden of proof shifts to the regulator, it here rests with the Appellant. • The Appellant’s failure to keep her learning and development skills and knowledge up-to-date. • The repeated historical breaches. Mr Howarth contended that the Appellant was asking us to give disproportionate weight to the improvements noted in 2017. • The use of unvetted assistants. Although of course this was not – indeed could not have been - noted at the registration visit of 6 th November 2025, the Appellant’s answers during the hearing showed a continuing lack of insight into the potential risk posed to children by unvetted adults. • Leaving assistants unsupervised. • The fact that the concerns raised in November of 2025 mirror issues found at inspections during the previous registration period. Tribunal’s Approach as to Fact-Finding
11. We have considered this with care. One possibility is to progress through Mr Howarth’s closing submissions. Another is to work our way through the Scott Schedule, which approaches the issues as follows: a) Paragraph 1: ‘Umbrella’ allegation that the Respondent had to refuse the registration application because the Appellant failed to satisfy the prescribed requirements or show that they are able to meet and continue to meet them. b) Paragraph 2 a) to e): Allegation that the necessity for prompting at the registration visit of 6 th November 2025 shows that the Appellant failed to demonstrate the learning and development requirements of the EYFS. c) Paragraph 3: Allegation that the Appellant has failed to demonstrate that she has addressed and will prevent any re-occurrence of the failures identified during her previous registration. d) Paragraph 4: Allegation that the learning and development deficits identified on historic visits have not been demonstrably addressed and resolved.
12. Whilst we have borne the above in mind, we have decided instead to approach our task by examining each of the following areas in turn: a) The history between 2001 and 2023. b) The registration visit of 6 th November 2025. c) The evidence given at the hearing of 19 th /20 th October 2026. Although this is in our view the most helpful way to analyse the evidence, we do bear in mind that that we have to decide in the round whether on the balance of probabilities the Appellant has proved that the prescribed requirements are satisfied and are likely to continue to be satisfied. As will become apparent, we find that areas a), b) and c) both individually and taken together are directly relevant to that test. Tribunal’s Findings
13. History between 2001 and 2023 . We make the following findings: a) The Appellant is undoubtedly an experienced and caring childminder. In respect of all the years that she has cared for children, it was never suggested to us that any of them have ever come to any physical harm. We have read the emails of support from a number of parents included in the bundle. We do not doubt that she is well-regarded by large numbers of them. b) We further note that the Appellant began working with children as long ago as 2001. She was first registered as a childminder - on the Early Years Register, the Compulsory Childcare Register and the Voluntary Childcare Register – in 2008. We have noted above that the outcomes of the 2008 and 2013 inspection were satisfactory and good, respectively. We are unaware of any criticisms made until 2016. c) We have set out above the failings recorded at the Ofsted inspection of 9 th December 2016. We observe that, realistically, the Appellant during the course of the hearing has by and large accepted most of the historical record of failings between 2016 and 2023. Her case is that she has recognised and acted upon them. We find that the failings of 9 th December 2016 are all very significant and that the failures, firstly, to notify Ofsted of the assistants and, secondly, to ensure that they were not left unsupervised with children are particularly serious. The result of those failures was that children were left with adults who not only were unvetted but could potentially have abused them. We are unaware of any challenge by the Appellant to the findings of 9 th December 2016. d) At an unannounced regulatory visit just a few days later on 15 th December 2016, it was additionally found that a first aid certificate had lapsed and that the Appellant did not have certified up-to-date knowledge in the event of an emergency. Again, we regard that breach as serious, for reasons we hardly need to specify. e) We do give the Appellant full credit for the positive outcome visit and inspection of 3 rd January 2017 and 8 th June 2017 respectively. The issue for us, however, is whether the improvements were sustained. We find that they were not, as will become evident from our findings below. f) We have detailed above the failings noted on the inspection visit of 22 nd September 2021. Leaving aside the significant learning and development deficits and the issue of children sleeping in highchairs, we are very concerned that on that date the Appellant – whilst she was elsewhere - had left two unvetted and unsupervised assistants with children. That is we find a repetition of the failing noted in December of 2016 and shows that the Appellant had failed to rectify a practice which created a very significant risk to the children in her care. We find that the Appellant’s response of 11 th October indicates an acceptance that children had indeed been left alone with unvetted assistants and that they had also been allowed to sleep in highchairs. g) We have also set out above the failings noted at the inspection of 13 th October 2021. That inspection noted problems with the induction and supervision of assistants. Whilst the circumstances may not have been precisely the same, we find that the inspection confirmed a continuing problem involving the supervision of assistants. h) Leaving to one side for a moment the learning and development issues, the inspection of 27 th September 2022 records a continuing issue of supervision of assistants who, on this occasion, were showing a lack of compassion for distressed children. There was the repetition of a lack of an available first-aid certificate which was evident in December of 2016. Additionally on this occasion, accident report forms had been lost. i) The remedial steps required following the September 2022 were not complied with. At the inspection of 22 nd March 2023, quite extraordinarily in our view - and leaving aside the learning and development in issues - the Appellant was still allowing unvetted - and inadequately inducted and supervised - assistants to work with children; issues between the children were not being noticed; the Appellant was unable to demonstrate that she held a relevant and current paediatric first-aid qualification. We find, again, that this demonstrates an inability on the Appellant’s part to rectify past failings. We are not reassured by the Appellant’s Response to the inspection report of 22 nd March 2023. j) Finally we turn to the last inspection within this time period, that of 11 th April 2023. Yet again the Appellant was using unvetted and inadequately inducted/supervised assistants, one of whom took a child to the lavatory unsupervised. k) We find that the history of visits and inspections between 2016 and 2023 makes it abundantly clear, not only that learning and development requirements were being repeatedly ignored, but that the Appellant’s failure to recognise the risks posed by unvetted and unsupervised assistants showed a striking disregard for the safety of children in her care. It is clear to us that, in a number of areas, the Appellant had demonstrated a continuing inability to implement and sustain the improvements repeatedly and properly required by Ofsted.
14. Registration visit of 6th November 2025 . This visit could not adequately address welfare and safety concerns because, the Appellant being unregistered, no children were actually present. We have considered carefully the allegation of failures in relation to learning and development. We find that that allegation is made out and that the failures closely mirror the failures between 2016 and 2023. We make findings as follows: a) The Appellant told Mr Howarth in cross-examination that she did identify to Ann Austen the 4 specific EYFS learning areas set out in paragraph 7 r) above; she said that that she did not know why Ann Austen had said that she did not. But generally she sought to explain her inability to specify all 7 areas by characterising it as having difficulties with EYFS terminology. However she had ample time to familiarise herself with that terminology which, in our view, is hardly difficult to understand. The EYFS framework is written in plain English, specifically for childminders. We remind ourselves that the visit of 6 th November 2025 did not come out of the blue. It was the Appellant who had chose to make a fresh registration application and she would have known that such a visit would take place. Ann Austen contacted the Appellant on 21st October 2025 to discuss the application and to confirm if the Appellant was ready for a registration visit. At that telephone call, the registration visit date of 6th November 2025 was set. But the Appellant appears to have done very little indeed to prepare for it. The EYFS terminology was clearly going to be used by an inspector at any registration visit. Yet the Appellant had clearly done or nothing to prepare for it. We see no reason why Ann Austen’s evidence should be unreliable when she tells us that the Appellant was unable to identify by name even one of the 7 areas of learning, and find that inability to be extraordinary. We do not understand how in the circumstances she could possibly have felt able to persuade Ann Austen that her knowledge of the learning and development requirements was adequate. b) But Ann Austen did not rely on the terminology alone. Seeing that the Appellant was at a loss, Ann Austen provided a variety of prompts. As is evident from the record of the registration visit set out above, the Appellant was still unable to provide sufficient examples in relation to any of the 7 relevant areas. This makes clear to us that the Appellant’s preparation for the registration visit was wholly inadequate. We agree that the Appellant consistently hesitated in her responses, and demonstrated a lack of confidence and a very basic understanding of child development. This makes clear to us that the Appellant’s lamentable lack of preparation not only made evident her embarrassing lack of knowledge but also an inability or unwillingness to learn from her mistakes of the past and ensure that they did not recur in the future. We have to say that, if she lacked the motivation to prepare for a pre-arranged registration visit, she would hardly be likely to improve her learning and development skills once any registration was in place. c) Whether or not Ann Austen told the Appellant or not that, in effect, she had ‘passed’ the registration visit cannot alter our findings as to what happened on that visit.
15. Evidence given at the hearing of 19th/20th October 2026 . We recognise of course just how stressful a hearing must be for a legally unrepresented Appellant and we make what allowance we can for this. But we have already found that, despite having from May of 2023 until November of 2025 to prepare for it, the Appellant displayed a concerning lack of knowledge as to learning and development requirements at the registration visit. Given the outcome of that registration visit, we would have expected the Appellant to use the intervening period of almost a year to prepare for this appeal hearing. But we find that she did not adequately do so and that she displayed a continuing lack of insight into both the learning and development requirements and the safety and welfare of children who would be in her care. Our findings are as follows: a) Learning & Development . In her evidence she told us that, although she may not have elaborated and could have given more examples at the registration visit, the answers she gave were correct and demonstrated that she satisfied the learning and development requirements. For the reasons we have given above we find that her answers were wholly inadequate and her inability even at the hearing to recognise this shows that she lacks insight. At one point during her evidence she told us that it had been acceptable to give short answers ‘as I knew what I was talking about’. She also told us that she thought the visit went well and that ‘I got nothing wrong’ . During cross-examination by Mr Howarth the Appellant accepted that the requirements were mandatory. She accepted that the documents she relied upon as supporting her appeal had not been presented to Ann Austen at the registration visit of November 2025. She accepted too that an inability to specify the 7 EYFS learning and development areas would be concerning. In cross-examination Mr Howarth asked the Appellant about the 7 EYFS areas. We find that, as clearly had been the case during the registration visit, her answers were short and inadequate. When asked about ‘Communication & Language’, she referred to talking to children and developing language skills. When Mr Howarth prompted her with some other considerations, she replied that that was written in the book; some of it she had covered, some not. When asked about ‘Physical Development’ she paused before referring initially to fine motor skills. Other factors were, again, mentioned only after prompting. When asked about ‘Personal, Social and Emotional Development’, she initially referred only to ‘looking after a child’s well-being’ . During cross-examination the Appellant frankly accepted that she had required prompting and that she was still unable to identify the 7 EYFS areas which are in the book, and that the book was a mandatory requirement. In response to our own questioning she told us that she had not done any specific EYFS training since November of 2025. We find that the deficits in relation to the 7 EYFS areas were as evident at this hearing as they had been at the registration visit of November 2025. b) Safety & Welfare . In relation to allowing assistants to work with children, the Appellant accepted that they were unvetted. However she told us that either she had notified Ofsted, or that assistants were in the process of being vetted, or that she was within the time limit for notification. But we find that all this is irrelevant. If an assistant has not been vetted by Ofsted, then they should not have been working unsupervised with children at all. We have to say that the Appellant during her evidence appeared wholly unable to take this point on board. In cross-examination she accepted that in April of 2023, a month after the previous inspection, she was still using unvetted assistants. She told Mr Howarth that, although unvetted, assistants were not left unsupervised. But in response to our own questioning she told us that they would sometimes be in one room whilst she was in another. We find that, at the hearing, the Appellant showed the same lack of insight into risk as was evident at the historical visits between 2016 and 2023. Conclusion
16. Taking into accounts the history between 2016 and 2023, the registration visit of November 2025 and the Appellant’s own evidence at this hearing, we find that the Appellant has not discharged the burden of proof upon her of demonstrating that the requirements for registration are satisfied and are likely to continue to be satisfied. We find that she has failed to establish her suitability for registration.
17. Indeed we would have come to the same conclusions had the burden of proof been on the Respondent. Decision
18. Pursuant to section 74(4) of the Childcare Act 2006 the Tribunal confirms the refusal of the Respondent to register the Appellant on the Early Years Register and Parts A & B of the General Childcare Register.
19. It follows that this appeal is dismissed. Tribunal Judge Francis Chamberlain Specialist Member Rachael Smith Specialist Member Martyn Green Date Issued: 23 October 2026