UK case law
Eyebright Ltd v The Pensions Regulator
[2026] UKFTT GRC 1338 · First-tier Tribunal (General Regulatory Chamber) – Pensions · 2026
The verbatim text of this UK judgment. Sourced directly from The National Archives Find Case Law. Not an AI summary, not a paraphrase — every word below is the original ruling, under Crown copyright and the Open Government Licence v3.0.
Full judgment
Decision: The appeal is Dismissed and the matter is remitted to the Respondent. No further directions are required. REASONS FOR DECISION Introduction:
1. This appeal concerns a Fixed Penalty Notice ("FPN") issued by The Pension Regulator(“TPR”) pursuant to section 40 of the Pensions Act 2008 in the sum of £400 on 17 April 2026. The penalty was imposed following the Appellant's alleged failure to comply with a Compliance Notice (“CN”) dated 18 February 2026 requiring the submission of a re-declaration of compliance in respect of automatic enrolment obligations.
2. The appeal has been listed for determination on the papers following the parties' consent and the Registrar's direction dated 31 July 2026.
3. There is little dispute regarding the existence of the underlying statutory duty or that the relevant re-declaration had not been submitted by the original deadline of 2 February 2026 or the extended deadline of 31 March 2026. The central dispute concerns whether the Appellant can successfully challenge the validity and effect of the CN upon which the FPN depends.
4. In broad terms, TPR relies upon statutory presumptions of service and receipt. The Appellant maintains that it never received the CN and that a substantial proportion of the warning communications relied upon by TPR were sent to an email address that had allegedly been defunct for approximately eight years. The principal dispute concerns service and receipt of the CN and the legal consequences flowing from that issue.
5. More specifically, the appeal raises the question whether the Appellant has displaced the statutory presumptions upon which TPR relies and, if it has not, whether any separate reasonable excuse nevertheless exists. Chronology:
6. The Appellant is an employer for the purposes of the automatic enrolment provisions of the Pensions Act 2008 .
7. The Appellant previously operated under the name Business Advisory Support Limited before changing its name to Eyebright Limited in September 2017.
8. The Appellant successfully completed its first declaration of compliance in December 2016, its first re-declaration in August 2019 and its second re-declaration in October 2022.
9. TPR's case is that the Appellant's third re-declaration of compliance ("Re-Doc3") was due by 2 February 2026 and was not submitted by that date.
10. During 2025 TPR sent two reminder letters addressed to Business Advisory Support Ltd at 11 Woodside Crescent, Glasgow and a series of reminder emails to [email protected].
11. The Appellant did not submit the re-declaration by 2 February 2026.
12. On 18 February 2026 TPR issued the CN requiring compliance by 31 March 2026. The CN was addressed to Eyebright Limited at 50 High Craighall Road, Glasgow G4 9UD, which TPR contends was the registered office address.
13. TPR also sent further reminder emails on 3 March, 21 March and 30 March 2026 referring to the CN and the extended deadline.
14. The Appellant did not submit the re-declaration by 31 March 2026.
15. On 17 April 2026 TPR issued the FPN in the prescribed sum of £400. The FPN was sent to the same registered address.
16. On 4 May 2026 the Appellant sought an internal review, asserting that it had never received the CN and therefore had been unaware of the requirement to act.
17. On 8 May 2026 TPR confirmed the FPN on review, stating that both the CN and FPN had been properly served at the registered office address.
18. The Appellant lodged a Tribunal appeal on 8 May 2026. Its grounds maintained that the CN had never been received and challenged TPR's reliance upon service at the registered office as proof of receipt.
19. In its response dated 22 May 2026 TPR relied upon statutory presumptions of service and receipt and invited the Tribunal to dismiss the appeal.
20. On 27 May 2026 the Appellant raised a further matter, namely that the email address [email protected] had allegedly not been used by or on behalf of the company for approximately eight years.
21. By directions dated 4 June 2026, Judge Muzaffer granted permission for the Appellant to amend its grounds to advance that additional point.
22. On 31 July 2026 the Registrar noted that both parties had consented to determination without a hearing and directed that the matter proceed by way of paper hearing. Issues Joined Between the Parties:
23. The parties are largely agreed on the factual proposition that the third re-declaration was not completed by the statutory deadline and had not been completed by 31 March 2026.The principal issues appear to be: a) Was the CN dated 18 February 2026 duly served upon the Appellant in accordance with the applicable statutory provisions? b) If the statutory presumptions of service arise, has the Appellant adduced sufficient evidence to rebut them by establishing that the CN was not received? c) What significance, if any, should be attached to the reminder letters and reminder emails relied upon by TPR? In particular, what weight should be given to the Appellant's assertion that the email address [email protected] had been defunct for approximately eight years? d) If service is established, has the Appellant demonstrated a reasonable excuse for non-compliance with the CN? e) What is the appropriate action for the Tribunal to direct pursuant to its jurisdiction under the Pensions Acts? Relevant Legislative Framework:
24. The Pensions Act 2008 : Sections 35 and 40 provide the statutory basis for Compliance Notices and Fixed Penalty Notices. The Tribunal's jurisdiction is not appellate in the traditional sense but requires it to determine what action is appropriate on the evidence before it. Employers' Duties (Registration and Compliance) Regulations 2010 The Regulations prescribe employers' duties relating to declarations and re-declarations of compliance and create presumptions relating to service of notices relied upon by TPR. Pensions Act 2004 / Interpretation Act 1978 TPR relies upon statutory presumptions that notices correctly addressed and issued are deemed served and received. Relevant Authorities:
25. In London Borough of Southwark v Akhtar - The Upper Tribunal held that a mere assertion of non-receipt is generally insufficient to rebut a statutory presumption of service. The case emphasises that more is required than a simple denial.
26. In Keith's Rubbish Clearance Ltd v TPR - Judge Hunter described a "bare paper assertion" of non-delivery as insufficient to overcome the statutory presumptions.
27. In Davide Cupertino v TPR - Judge Swaney found that a responsible employer is expected to understand its statutory duties and that non-receipt of reminders does not necessarily constitute a reasonable excuse. The Appellant's Case:
28. The Appellant's case is straightforward. It maintains that the CN was never received. It therefore contends that it had no knowledge that a CN existed, no awareness of the requirement to comply by 31 March 2026 and consequently no opportunity to avoid the penalty that followed.
29. The Appellant further submits that TPR's account of repeated warning communications is materially undermined by the revelation that ten reminder emails were sent to an email address which had allegedly not been used for approximately eight years. The Appellant argues that this is evidence that TPR's communication records were materially inaccurate.
30. The Appellant says that, in those circumstances, it is unjust to rely upon presumptions of receipt when there is evidence suggesting that significant components of TPR's contact information were outdated. The Respondent's Case:
31. TPR submits that all statutory conditions for issue of the CN and FPN were met.
32. TPR relies upon the registered office address recorded at Companies House and contends that both the CN and FPN were properly addressed and issued.
33. TPR submits that the Appellant advances no more than a bare assertion of non-receipt and that the authorities consistently hold such assertions to be insufficient.
34. TPR further argues that a responsible employer remains under an independent statutory obligation to understand and fulfil automatic enrolment duties irrespective of reminder communications. Discussion:
35. The Tribunal's first task is to be determine whether the statutory presumptions arise. On the evidence available in the bundle, there appears to be no dispute that 50 High Craighall Road was the Appellant's registered office at the material time. TPR therefore appears able to invoke the relevant presumptions.
36. Once those presumptions arise, the authorities relied upon by TPR demonstrate a consistently high threshold for rebuttal. Both authorities in Akhtar and Keith's Rubbish Clearance emphasise that simple denials of receipt are generally insufficient.
37. The question therefore becomes whether the Appellant has produced evidence going beyond a bare denial.
38. The strongest point available to the Appellant is not the assertion of non-receipt itself but the evidence concerning [email protected]. Judge Muzaffer considered that point sufficiently significant to justify amendment of the grounds of appeal.
39. However, the difficulty for the Appellant is that the disputed email address concerns reminders rather than the CN itself. The CN relied upon by TPR was sent by post to the registered office. Consequently, even if the Tribunal accepts that the reminder emails were sent to an obsolete address, that fact does not necessarily undermine service of the CN.
40. In substance, evidence that reminder emails went astray does not automatically establish that a later statutory notice sent by post to the registered office also failed to arrive.
41. The absence of additional material evidence demonstrating wider failures in the receipt of correspondence at the registered office, the authorities relied upon by TPR presents a substantial obstacle to the appeal.
42. If the Tribunal were able to conclude that the CN was served and deemed received, the Appellant faces a further difficulty on reasonable excuse.
43. The authorities relied upon by TPR adopt a relatively strict approach. In the cases of Keith's Rubbish Clearance and Davide Cupertino, the Tribunal emphasised that employers bear responsibility for understanding and complying with statutory obligations.
44. The Appellant does not appear to argue that the underlying obligation was unknowable or that compliance was impossible. Rather, its case is that it was not made aware of the need to comply because communications were not received.
45. If the Tribunal rejects the non-receipt argument, it is difficult to identify a separate reasonable-excuse case capable of succeeding.
46. Conversely, if the Tribunal accepts that the Appellant genuinely did not receive the CN, the analysis changes. In that scenario the failure to comply may arguably stem not from disregard of statutory obligations but from lack of notice of the enforcement step that triggered liability for the fixed penalty. The Tribunal would then consider whether the statutory presumptions should nevertheless prevail.
47. The appeal is unusually narrow. There is no substantial challenge to the underlying statutory scheme, no challenge to the amount of the penalty, and no dispute that the relevant re-declaration remained outstanding beyond the statutory deadline.
48. In essence the appeal stands or falls upon a single question: Has the Appellant produced evidence capable of elevating its case beyond a bare assertion of non-receipt and thereby rebutting the statutory presumptions upon which TPR relies? Findings of Fact:
49. The Appellant is an employer subject to the automatic enrolment regime under the Pensions Act 2008 .
50. The company was incorporated under the name Business Advisory Support Limited and changed its name to Eyebright Limited in September 2017.
51. The Appellant successfully completed a declaration of compliance in 2016 and subsequent re-declarations in 2019 and 2022.
52. The Appellant was required to submit a further re-declaration of compliance by 2 February 2026.
53. Prior to that deadline, the Respondent sent reminder correspondence by both post and email. The email communications were sent to [email protected].
54. No re-declaration was submitted by 2 February 2026.
55. On 18 February 2026 the Respondent issued a CN addressed to the Appellant at 50 High Craighall Road, Glasgow G4 9UD.
56. The parties do not appear to dispute that this was the Appellant's registered office address at the material time. The bundle contains Companies House documentation consistent with that position.
57. The CN required the Appellant to complete the re-declaration by 31 March 2026.
58. No re-declaration was submitted by 31 March 2026.
59. On 17 April 2026 the Respondent issued the FPN.
60. On 4 May 2026 the Appellant, aware of the FPN sought a review of the FPN. The central basis of that review request was that the CN had not been received.
61. On 8 May 2026 the Respondent completed its review and confirmed the FPN.
62. The Appellant subsequently appealed to this Tribunal.
63. Following service of the Respondent's response, the Appellant asserted that [email protected] had not been used by or on behalf of the company for approximately eight years. Permission to advance that additional point was granted by Judge Muzaffer. Service of the Compliance Notice:
64. The Appellant's principal argument is that it never received the Compliance Notice.
65. There is no positive dispute before the Tribunal regarding the address used by the Respondent for service of the CN. The evidence before the Tribunal indicates that the notice was addressed to the Appellant's registered office.
66. The Respondent’s position is that the Appellant was given ample notice of its statutory obligations and that all relevant correspondence was sent to addresses properly associated with the company. Prior to the deadline for the third Re-Declaration of Compliance, the Respondent issued reminder correspondence concerning the Appellant’s automatic enrolment duties. More significantly, when no response was received by the statutory deadline of 2 February 2026, the Respondent issued a CN on 18 February 2026 to the Appellant’s registered office address, namely 50 High Craighall Road, Glasgow G4 9UD, being the address recorded for the company and later confirmed by Companies House records. The CN clearly identified the outstanding obligation, extended the compliance deadline to 31 March 2026, warned in unequivocal terms that failure to comply could result in a £400 Fixed Penalty Notice, provided details of how compliance could be achieved, and explained the Appellant’s review rights.
67. The Respondent relies upon the statutory presumptions applicable to service and receipt of notices.
68. The Tribunal accepts that those presumptions arise on the facts of this case.
69. The question therefore becomes whether the Appellant has produced evidence sufficient to rebut those presumptions.
70. The authorities relied upon by the Respondent are not binding in every respect upon the Tribunal's determination of the facts of this appeal. However, they are consistent in identifying the evidential burden faced by a party seeking to rebut a statutory presumption of service.
71. In London Borough of Southwark v Akhtar, the Upper Tribunal held that a mere assertion of non-receipt does not ordinarily rebut a statutory presumption of service.
72. Similarly, in Keith's Rubbish Clearance Ltd v The Pensions Regulator; Judge Hunter held that a " bare paper assertion " of non-delivery fell substantially short of what was required to displace the statutory presumption.
73. The Tribunal has carefully considered whether the Appellant's case goes beyond such an assertion.
74. The Appellant has consistently maintained that the CN did not come to its attention. The Tribunal does not regard that assertion as lacking sincerity. However, sincerity and evidential sufficiency are distinct matters.
75. The bundle contains no witness evidence explaining postal arrangements at the registered office, no evidence of any systemic postal difficulties and no evidence from any person responsible for receipt and handling of correspondence at the relevant premises.
76. Nor has the Appellant produced evidence demonstrating circumstances from which the Tribunal could infer that correspondence sent to the registered office was unlikely to reach those acting on behalf of the company.
77. Having considered the material before it as a whole, the Tribunal is not satisfied that evidence sufficient to rebut the relevant statutory presumptions has been produced.
78. The Tribunal therefore finds that the Compliance Notice was validly served. The Allegedly Obsolete Email Address:
79. The Tribunal has separately considered the Appellant's submission concerning [email protected].
80. This point was considered sufficiently arguable to justify amendment of the grounds of appeal. The Tribunal has therefore given it careful consideration.
81. The difficulty for the Appellant is that the assertion is unsupported by any documentary or witness evidence.
82. The bundle contains the assertion itself but no technical evidence, business records or witness statement explaining the status of the address or the circumstances in which it allegedly ceased to be used.
83. More fundamentally, the reminder emails sent to that address are not the CN upon which the FPN depends. They may assist in explaining why reminders failed to come to the attention of the Appellant. They do not, however, directly address the separate question of service of the CN itself.
84. The Tribunal therefore accepts that the point is relevant background but does not regard it, either alone or together with the remaining evidence, as sufficient to rebut the statutory presumptions applicable to the CN. Reasonable Excuse:
85. The Tribunal has separately considered the issue of reasonable excuse.
86. The Appellant's reasonable-excuse argument is closely linked to its contention that it did not receive the CN.
87. The Tribunal accepts that, in principle, genuine non-receipt of a CN may in some circumstances be capable of contributing to a reasonable-excuse case.
88. However, the Tribunal has found that the Appellant has not rebutted the presumption that the CN was served at all.
89. The authorities relied upon by the Respondent also provide guidance as to the responsibilities of employers operating within the statutory scheme.
90. In Davide Cupertino v The Pensions Regulator, Judge Swaney observed that responsible employers are expected to remain aware of their statutory duties and that non-receipt of reminder communications will not necessarily amount to a reasonable excuse.
91. The facts of this appeal include the Appellant's history of previous compliance with the statutory regime. The Appellant completed relevant declarations and re-declarations in 2016, 2019 and 2022.
92. Those previous interactions demonstrate familiarity with the existence of the regulatory requirements.
93. The Tribunal therefore does not regard this as a case involving an employer wholly unaware of the statutory regime.
94. Having considered all of the circumstances relied upon by the Appellant, the Tribunal is not satisfied that a reasonable excuse has been established. Appropriate Action:
95. The Tribunal's task is to determine what action should appropriately be taken.
96. The Tribunal has found that: a) the Compliance Notice was validly served; b) the Appellant has not rebutted the statutory presumptions relied upon by the Respondent; c) the Appellant has not established a reasonable excuse for non-compliance.
97. In those circumstances the Tribunal is satisfied that confirmation of the Fixed Penalty Notice was the appropriate action for the Respondent to take. Conclusion:
98. The Tribunal has reached these conclusions on the evidence presently before it. Nothing in this decision should be taken as suggesting that genuine failures of service could never amount to a reasonable excuse; the determination in this case turns upon the Tribunal's assessment of the particular evidence filed.
99. The Respondent contends that the CN was properly addressed and served at the company’s registered office. The Appellant offers no explanation as to why a statutory notice sent to its own registered address was allegedly not received, nor any evidence capable of displacing the presumption that correspondence posted to that address would come to the attention of the company. On the Respondent’s case, a bare assertion of non-receipt is insufficient. The Tribunal is therefore invited to conclude that the CN was validly served, that the Appellant had both notice of its obligations and a further opportunity to comply, and that the subsequent FPN was issued in consequence of the Appellant’s failure to take the required action within the extended period allowed.
100. The Tribunal finds that the statutory presumptions apply. The Tribunal finds that the Appellant has failed to adduce evidence sufficient to rebut those presumptions. The Tribunal is not satisfied that a reasonable excuse has been established. The Tribunal determines that confirmation of the Fixed Penalty Notice issued on 17 April 2026 was the appropriate action for the Respondent to take. For the reasons set out above, the appeal is dismissed. The matter is remitted to the Respondent. No further directions are required. Brian Kennedy KC 22 September 2026.