UK case law

Laurencekirk Medical Practice v The Pensions Regulator

[2026] UKFTT GRC 1368 · First-tier Tribunal (General Regulatory Chamber) – Pensions · 2026

Get your free legal insight →Email to a colleague
Get your free legal insight on this case →

The verbatim text of this UK judgment. Sourced directly from The National Archives Find Case Law. Not an AI summary, not a paraphrase — every word below is the original ruling, under Crown copyright and the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Full judgment

1. This is a reference by Laurencekirk Medical Practice against a Fixed Penalty Notice issued by the Pensions Regulator under section 40 of the Pensions Act 2008 .

2. The Respondent applied for the proceedings to be struck out under rule 8(2)(a) of the Tribunal Procedure (First-tier Tribunal) (General Regulatory Chamber) Rules 2009. The Respondent submits that the Tribunal has no jurisdiction because the Fixed Penalty Notice was not reviewed under section 43 of the Pensions Act 2008 and no valid application for a review was made within the prescribed period.

3. The Appellant opposes the application. It submits that there is a genuine factual dispute concerning receipt of the relevant notices, its awareness of them, and its practical opportunity to use the statutory review procedure. It argues that those matters should not be determined summarily and asks the Tribunal either to refuse the application or to direct that the matter proceed to a hearing.

4. The Tribunal has considered the Respondent’s application, the accompanying documents, the Appellant’s response and the material submitted with the reference. It has also considered the decisions relied upon by the Respondent. Statutory Framework

5. Under section 40 of the Pensions Act 2008 , the Respondent may issue a fixed penalty notice in the circumstances specified by that provision.

6. Section 43(1) provides that the Respondent may review a fixed penalty notice: a) on the written application of the person to whom the notice was issued; or b) if the Respondent otherwise considers it appropriate.

7. The prescribed period for making a written application for a review is 28 days from the date on which the notice is issued.

8. Section 44 provides for a reference to be made to the Tribunal in respect of the issue of, or the amount payable under, a penalty notice. Section 44(2) provides that a reference may be made only if: a) the Respondent has completed a review of the notice under section 43 ; or b) the person to whom the notice was issued has made an application for review under section 43(1) (a) and the Respondent has determined not to carry out such a review.

9. The statutory review process is therefore a necessary jurisdictional gateway. The Tribunal has no general or freestanding jurisdiction to consider the fairness, proportionality or merits of a penalty notice where the conditions in section 44(2) have not been met.

10. Rule 8(2) of the The Tribunal Procedure (First-tier Tribunal) (General Regulatory Chamber) Rules 2009 provides: “The Tribunal must strike out the whole or a part of the proceedings if the Tribunal (a) does not have jurisdiction in relation to the proceedings or that part of them; and (b) does not exercise its power under rule 5(3)(k)(i) to transfer the proceedings or that part of them to another court or tribunal.”

11. There is no other court or tribunal to which these proceedings could appropriately be transferred. Accordingly, if the Tribunal does not have jurisdiction, strike out is mandatory. Background

12. The Appellant accepts that its re-declaration of compliance was not completed by the deadline of 31 December 2025.

13. The Respondent subsequently issued a Compliance Notice. The Appellant’s position is that the Compliance Notice did not come to the attention of those responsible for regulatory compliance within the Practice before the relevant deadline.

14. A Fixed Penalty Notice was issued by the Respondent on 23 March 2026. The notice explained the procedure for applying for a review and stated that any application for review, together with the supporting documents, had to be submitted within 28 days of the notice being issued.

15. On 24 March 2026, the Appellant completed the outstanding re-declaration of compliance. The Appellant says that it did so immediately upon becoming aware of the matter.

16. The Appellant did not apply for a review of the Fixed Penalty Notice within the prescribed 28-day period. Its review request was made on 24 April 2026.

17. The Respondent declined to undertake a review because the application had been made outside the prescribed period. It also declined to carry out a review on its own initiative under section 43(1) (b).

18. The Appellant subsequently made this reference to the Tribunal. The Respondent’s application to strike out

19. The Respondent submits that the Tribunal does not have jurisdiction because neither of the conditions in section 44(2) has been met.

20. No review was completed under section 43 . The Respondent submits that the late review request was not an application made under section 43(1) (a) because it was not made within the prescribed period. Its decision not to act on that late request was therefore not a determination falling within section 44(2)(b).

21. The Respondent relies upon the fact that the relevant notices were sent to the Practice’s proper address. It says that the address used was the Practice’s principal office, appeared on the Practice’s website and was the address provided when the re-declaration was completed.

22. The Respondent submits that the Appellant has not produced evidence capable of rebutting the statutory presumption of receipt. In particular, the Appellant has not clearly asserted that the Fixed Penalty Notice was never delivered to the Practice address or that it was delivered only after the review period had expired.

23. The Respondent distinguishes between receipt of a notice by the Appellant and the notice subsequently coming to the attention of the particular person responsible for regulatory compliance. It submits that a failure in the internal handling or distribution of post does not prevent a notice from having been received by an organisational recipient. The Appellant’s Response

24. The Appellant accepts that the Tribunal’s jurisdiction is governed by sections 43 and 44 of the Pensions Act 2008 . It submits, however, that the proceedings should not be struck out without consideration of the exceptional factual circumstances.

25. The Appellant says that it was not deliberately non-compliant and that the Compliance Notice did not come to the attention of those responsible for regulatory compliance within the Practice before the relevant deadline.

26. It says that it first became aware of the matter on 24 March 2026 and immediately completed the re-declaration. It submits that this conduct is inconsistent with any suggestion that it intended to disregard its obligations or correspondence from the Respondent.

27. The Appellant also says that it was unaware that it was required to submit a separate review request. It states that it became aware of that procedural requirement only after receiving further correspondence dated 22 April 2026 and that it then acted promptly.

28. The Appellant accepts that there are statutory presumptions concerning service and receipt, but submits that they are rebuttable. It does not allege bad faith on the part of the Respondent and does not dispute that the Respondent intended to send correspondence to the Practice address.

29. It submits that the relevant correspondence did not come to the attention of those responsible for regulatory compliance. It also refers to uncertainty as to whether previous correspondence may have been addressed to former partners.

30. The Appellant argues that its subsequent conduct supports its account. It completed the re-declaration immediately, attempted to engage with the Respondent and sought a review once it became aware of the review process.

31. It submits that the factual circumstances surrounding notice, awareness and its ability to exercise its review rights should be examined at a hearing rather than determined summarily. The Issues

32. The principal issue is whether the Tribunal has jurisdiction under section 44 of the Pensions Act 2008 . In determining that issue, the Tribunal must consider: a) whether the Respondent completed a review under section 43 ; b) whether the Appellant made an application for review under section 43(1) (a); c) whether there is a genuine and material factual dispute concerning receipt of the Fixed Penalty Notice that requires oral evidence; and d) whether the Appellant’s case concerning lack of awareness is capable of affecting the Tribunal’s jurisdiction. Statutory Review Conditions

33. It is common ground that the Respondent did not complete a review of the Fixed Penalty Notice. The condition in section 44(2) (a) is therefore not met.

34. The Appellant made its review request on 24 April 2026. That request was made outside the prescribed period of 28 days from the date of the Fixed Penalty Notice.

35. The statutory scheme distinguishes between an application made under section 43(1) (a) and a request made after the prescribed period has expired. The Respondent has no statutory power to extend the prescribed period for an application under section 43(1) (a).

36. The Respondent retained a separate power under section 43(1) (b) to conduct a review if it otherwise considered it appropriate. It declined to exercise that power. A request that the Respondent exercise its discretionary power under section 43(1) (b) is not the same as a valid application made under section 43(1) (a).

37. The Respondent’s refusal to undertake a review following an out-of-time request does not satisfy section 44(2) (b). For that provision to apply, there must first have been an application under section 43(1) (a), which necessarily means an application made within the prescribed period.

38. The Tribunal cannot extend the statutory review period, treat an out-of-time request as having been made in time, or confer jurisdiction upon itself because the circumstances appear deserving of consideration. Receipt and awareness

39. The Tribunal has carefully considered the Appellant’s submission that there is a factual dispute requiring a hearing. In doing so, it is important to distinguish between: a) receipt of the Compliance Notice; b) receipt of the Fixed Penalty Notice; c) the Fixed Penalty Notice coming to the personal attention of the individual responsible for regulatory compliance; and d) that individual appreciating the need to make a separate review application within 28 days.

40. The Appellant’s evidence and submissions are principally directed to the Compliance Notice. Its case is that the Compliance Notice did not come to the attention of those responsible for compliance until 24 March 2026.

41. The Tribunal accepts, for the purpose of determining the application, that the relevant individual within the Practice may not have become personally aware of the Compliance Notice before that date. It also accepts that the Appellant completed the re-declaration promptly after the matter came to that individual’s attention.

42. Those circumstances may show that the Appellant did not deliberately disregard its automatic enrolment obligations. They do not, however, establish that the Fixed Penalty Notice was not received by the Appellant or that a review application was made within the prescribed period.

43. The legally material notice for present purposes is the Fixed Penalty Notice issued on 23 March 2026. It was that notice which gave rise to the right to apply for a review and which explained the procedure and time limit for doing so.

44. The Appellant has not clearly asserted that the Fixed Penalty Notice was never delivered to its address. Nor has it asserted that the Fixed Penalty Notice was delivered only after the 28-day review period had expired.

45. The Appellant has not identified the date on which the Fixed Penalty Notice was first delivered to or received at the Practice. It has not produced an envelope, post log, date stamp or other contemporaneous document indicating that it was delivered late, misdirected or returned to the Respondent.

46. The Appellant has not provided evidence from a person responsible for receiving and distributing post explaining that the Fixed Penalty Notice was not received at the Practice. Nor has it explained the Practice’s arrangements for handling official correspondence.

47. Instead, the Appellant’s case is that the relevant correspondence did not come to the attention of “those responsible for regulatory compliance”. That is not the same as saying that the correspondence was not received by the Practice.

48. The Appellant is an organisational recipient. Receipt by the Appellant does not depend upon the notice personally reaching the particular partner, manager or employee responsible for compliance. A notice may be received by an organisation even if a failure in its internal arrangements means that it does not promptly reach the individual who ought to deal with it.

49. The reasoning in J.M. Kamau Ltd v The Pensions Regulator [2025] UKFTT 425 (GRC) supports that distinction. Delivery to the proper address is not rendered ineffective merely because the notice does not subsequently reach the hands of the particular individual responsible for handling it.

50. The Appellant’s uncertainty as to whether some correspondence may have been addressed to former partners does not materially alter the position. The notices were sent to the Practice’s accepted address. The Appellant has not identified which named partners had left, when they left, or how the inclusion of their names would have prevented delivery to the Practice.

51. There is no evidence that post addressed in that manner would not ordinarily have been delivered to or accepted at the Practice. There is also no evidence that the addressing of the Fixed Penalty Notice caused it to be returned, withheld or delivered elsewhere.

52. The Tribunal therefore finds that the Appellant has not raised a genuine factual dispute concerning receipt of the Fixed Penalty Notice that is capable of affecting jurisdiction. The identified issue concerns internal awareness and the subsequent handling of correspondence, rather than delivery to the Appellant’s address. Lack of awareness of the review procedure

53. The Appellant says that it did not understand that it was required to make a separate application for review and became aware of that requirement only after receiving further correspondence dated 22 April 2026.

54. The Tribunal accepts that this may have been the Appellant’s genuine understanding. It does not, however, provide a legal basis for treating the late review request as an application made within the prescribed period.

55. The Fixed Penalty Notice explained the right to seek a review and the relevant 28-day time limit. The fact that the information was not appreciated or acted upon by the appropriate individual within the Practice cannot extend the statutory period or create jurisdiction where the conditions in section 44(2) are not met.

56. The Tribunal also accepts that the Appellant acted promptly once the need to make a review request was understood. That conduct may demonstrate good faith, but prompt action following the expiry of the statutory period cannot retrospectively validate an out-of-time request. Is an oral hearing necessary?

57. The Tribunal has considered whether the matter should proceed to an oral hearing so that evidence concerning receipt may be tested. The question is whether the appellant has identified a genuine and material factual dispute capable of affecting the Tribunal’s jurisdiction.

58. A hearing might be required where an appellant clearly asserts, with some evidential foundation, that the penalty notice was never delivered, was delivered to an incorrect address, or was first delivered after the statutory review period had expired.

59. That is not the Appellant’s case as presently advanced. The Appellant does not dispute that the Respondent intended to serve the correspondence at the Practice address. It does not clearly deny that the Fixed Penalty Notice was delivered there. Its case is that the relevant documents did not come to the attention of the person responsible for compliance and that the review requirement was not understood in time.

60. The Tribunal accepts the Appellant’s factual case at its highest for the purpose of determining this application. Even if the relevant person did not become aware of the correspondence or understand the review procedure until after the deadline had passed, that would not establish that the statutory conditions in section 44(2) had been met.

61. In my view, an oral hearing would therefore serve no material purpose. The resolution of any dispute about when the relevant individual first became personally aware of the notice would not alter the jurisdictional outcome. Tribunal’s acceptance of the Notice of Appeal

62. The Appellant relies upon the fact that the Tribunal accepted the Notice of Appeal for filing and subsequently invited the Appellant’ submissions on the strike-out application.

63. Administrative acceptance of a reference does not amount to a judicial determination that the Tribunal has jurisdiction. Jurisdiction may be examined at any stage of the proceedings.

64. The Tribunal’s decision to invite the Appellant’s response ensured that the Appellant had a fair opportunity to address the Respondent’s application before a decision was made. It does not imply that the Tribunal had reached a preliminary view that a hearing was required or that there was a properly arguable basis for jurisdiction. Conclusion

65. The Respondent did not complete a review of the Fixed Penalty Notice under section 43 of the Pensions Act 2008 .

66. The Appellant did not make an application for review within the prescribed 28-day period. Its request of 24 April 2026 was made after that period had expired and was not an application under section 43(1) (a) for the purposes of section 44(2) (b).

67. The Respondent declined to exercise its separate power to conduct a review on its own initiative under section 43(1) (b). That decision does not create a right of reference under section 44 .

68. The Tribunal accepts that the Appellant may have acted promptly once the matter came to the attention of the relevant individual within the Practice. It also accepts that the Appellant may not have deliberately disregarded its statutory obligations. Those matters cannot confer jurisdiction upon the Tribunal.

69. The Appellant has not clearly denied that the Fixed Penalty Notice was delivered to the Practice’s proper address. Its case concerns when the notice came to the attention of the person responsible for compliance and when the review requirement was understood. Those matters do not establish non-receipt by the Appellant and do not require determination at an oral hearing.

70. Neither of the conditions in section 44(2) of the Pensions Act 2008 is satisfied. The Tribunal therefore has no jurisdiction to determine the reference.

71. There is no appropriate court or tribunal to which the proceedings may be transferred. Rule 8(2)(a) accordingly requires the Tribunal to strike out the proceedings. Signed: Judge Mornington Date: 2 October 2026