UK case law
Luxurico Ltd v The Commissioners for HMRC
[2026] UKFTT TC 1252 · First-tier Tribunal (Tax Chamber) · 2026
The verbatim text of this UK judgment. Sourced directly from The National Archives Find Case Law. Not an AI summary, not a paraphrase — every word below is the original ruling, under Crown copyright and the Open Government Licence v3.0.
Full judgment
introduction
1. This is an appeal by Luxurico Limited ("Luxurico") against refusal to allow recovery of input VAT of £477,508.60 incurred on the importation and acquisition of a Hypercar motor vehicle (“the Index Vehicle”) in November 2020. The appeal originally concerned a number of VAT assessments issued by the Respondents (“HMRC”) and issues covering various accounting periods between September 2019 and March 2022. By the date of the hearing, however, all matters other than the Index Vehicle input tax issue had either been conceded, resolved or were no longer pursued. It was common ground that the Index Vehicle issue was therefore the sole remaining matter requiring determination.
2. Luxurico carries on a luxury vehicle hire business under the trading name Platinum Executive Travel. Its case is that the Index Vehicle was acquired as a flagship hire vehicle and that the input tax incurred on its acquisition falls within the exception contained in Article 7(2E) and (2F) of the Value Added Tax (Input Tax) Order 1992 ("the Input Tax Order"). HMRC contend that the Appellant has failed to establish that the relevant condition was satisfied and that the statutory input tax block therefore applies.
3. There is no dispute that the Index Vehicle is a motor car for the purposes of Article 7 of the Input Tax Order, that Luxurico is a taxable person, or that the ordinary conditions for input tax deduction would otherwise be satisfied. The dispute is confined to whether, at the time of acquisition and importation in November 2020, Luxurico objectively intended primarily to use the vehicle for a relevant purpose within Article 7(2E) and (2F).
4. The hearing lasted one day. The Tribunal heard oral evidence from Mr Saleem Iqbal, Mr Aleem Iqbal and Mr Christopher Tyler. HMRC relied on the witness statement of Mr Andrew Kirkby. The Tribunal was referred to a hearing bundle (1,853 pages), an authorities bundle (202 pages), and was also provided with detailed skeleton arguments and oral submissions from both parties.
5. In reaching this decision, we have considered all of the evidence and submissions before us, whether or not they are referred to expressly. The fact that a particular piece of evidence or submission is not specifically mentioned should not be taken as indicating that it has been overlooked.
6. For the reasons set out below, we conclude that, at the time of acquisition and importation in November 2020, Luxurico objectively intended primarily to use the Index Vehicle for self-drive hire and/or hire with a driver within the meaning of Article 7(2E) and 7(2F) of the Input Tax Order. The appeal is therefore allowed. Legal framework The statutory provisions
7. Luxurico's entitlement to deduct the VAT incurred on the acquisition and importation of the Index Vehicle falls to be determined by Article 7 of the Value Added Tax (Input Tax) Order 1992 ("the Input Tax Order"). Article 7(1) provides that input tax incurred on the acquisition or importation of a motor car is ordinarily excluded from recovery. The parties agree that the Index Vehicle is a motor car for the purposes of Article 7 and that, absent a statutory exception, the input VAT incurred on its acquisition would be blocked.
8. The relevant exception is contained in Article 7(2E). As material, the input tax block does not apply where, at the time of acquisition or importation, the taxable person intends to use the vehicle: "(a) exclusively for the purposes of a business carried on by him; or (b) primarily for a relevant purpose."
9. Luxurico relies on Article 7(2E)(b). Article 7(2F) provides that a "relevant purpose" includes: "(a) providing the vehicle on hire with a driver for the purpose of carrying passengers; or (b) providing the vehicle for self-drive hire."
10. There is no dispute that self-drive hire and hire with a driver are relevant purposes within the meaning of Article 7(2F). Nor is there any dispute that the appeal falls to be determined under Article 7(2E)(b) rather than Article 7(2E)(a). The applicable legal principles
11. Although the parties referred us to a number of authorities, there was very little disagreement as to the applicable legal principles.
12. First, entitlement to deduct input tax falls to be determined when the input tax is incurred. The question is therefore whether the relevant statutory conditions were satisfied at the time of acquisition and importation of the vehicle. That principle is reflected in the reasoning in Commissioners of Customs and Excise v Elm Milk Ltd [2006] EWCA Civ 164 and was not disputed before us.
13. Secondly, the statutory focus under Article 7 is upon intended use rather than actual use. The legislation requires the Tribunal to determine the purpose for which the vehicle was intended to be used when acquired. It does not require the Tribunal to undertake a retrospective assessment of how the vehicle was ultimately used over the whole period of ownership.
14. Thirdly, intention is assessed objectively. In Teleos plc v Commissioners of Customs and Excise ( Case C-409/04 ), the Court of Justice stressed that VAT consequences should ordinarily be determined by reference to objective characteristics rather than an investigation into a trader's subjective wishes. Similar observations appear throughout the VAT authorities. In Sub One Ltd v HMRC [2014] EWCA Civ 773 , the Court of Appeal emphasised that domestic legislation should, so far as possible, be interpreted consistently with the EU law principle that VAT liabilities are to be assessed by objective criteria. Likewise, in Royal Opera House Covent Garden Foundation v HMRC [2021] EWCA Civ 910 , the Court confirmed that a taxpayer's purpose is to be objectively ascertained from the facts and circumstances rather than by an enquiry into subjective motive.
15. Fourthly, while subsequent events may be relevant, they are relevant only as evidence from which the original intention may be inferred. Subsequent conduct may confirm, contradict or illuminate an intention said to have existed when the input tax was incurred. It does not itself determine entitlement.
16. Fifthly, the statutory scheme distinguishes between the determination of entitlement at acquisition and later changes in use. Luxurico relied on Article 5 of the VAT (Cars) Order 1992 as demonstrating that the legislation contemplates circumstances in which actual use may diverge from originally intended use. We agree that the existence of provisions dealing with later use supports the proposition that entitlement under Article 7 is determined by reference to the intention existing at acquisition and is not revisited simply because subsequent events unfold differently from what was expected.
17. Finally, Article 7(2E)(b) requires that the intended use be "primarily" for a relevant purpose. The legislation does not require exclusive use. Nor does it require Luxurico to establish that every anticipated use of the Index Vehicle was connected with hire activity. The question is whether, viewed objectively and at the time of acquisition, the most important, dominant or principal intended use of the vehicle was self-drive hire and/or hire with a driver. The burden of proof
18. It is common ground that the burden of proof rests upon Luxurico. Accordingly, the question for determination is whether Luxurico has established, on the balance of probabilities, that at the time of acquisition and importation in November 2020 it objectively intended primarily to use the Index Vehicle for self-drive hire and/or hire with a driver within the meaning of Article 7(2E) and 7(2F) of the Input Tax Order. position of the parties
19. HMRC's case
20. HMRC submit that Luxurico has failed to establish that, at the time the Index Vehicle was acquired and imported in November 2020, it intended primarily to use the vehicle for self-drive hire or hire with a driver within the meaning of Article 7(2E) and 7(2F) of the Input Tax Order. They accept that Luxurico operated a luxury vehicle hire business, that the Index Vehicle was marketed as available for hire and that hire insurance was arranged shortly after acquisition. However, HMRC contend that those matters do not of themselves demonstrate that commercial hire was the vehicle's primary intended use.
21. HMRC place particular reliance on the absence of contemporaneous mileage logs between November 2020 and March 2022, inconsistencies within the mileage records that were eventually produced, and the accumulation of significant mileage during a period when there was limited documentary evidence of completed hires. They further submit that there is little contemporaneous evidence of genuine hire activity during 2020 and 2021. They note that most of the hire invoices relied upon by Luxurico are dated from March 2022 onwards and contend that there is limited evidence of actual booking records, hire agreements or other contemporaneous documentation demonstrating commercial exploitation of the vehicle during the earlier period.
22. HMRC also rely on what they describe as gaps in the insurance evidence. Whilst accepting that the Index Vehicle was initially insured for self-drive hire, HMRC submit that there is limited evidence of equivalent cover during later periods and that this is inconsistent with Luxurico's contention that the vehicle was primarily intended for hire.
23. They further rely on social media content and YouTube videos featuring the Index Vehicle and submit that references to the vehicle as a "dream car", together with evidence of its use in connection with trips and motoring events, suggest a significant personal element which is inconsistent with Luxurico's case that the vehicle was acquired primarily as a commercial asset.
24. More generally, HMRC submit that the objective evidence of the vehicle's actual use after acquisition does not support the primary hire intention asserted by Luxurico. Although accepting that subsequent events are not themselves the statutory test, they argue that those events provide an important indication of the true purpose for which the vehicle was acquired.
25. Accordingly, HMRC submit that Luxurico has not discharged the burden of proof and that the input tax block contained in Article 7 applies. Luxurico's case
26. Luxurico submits that HMRC's analysis is directed towards the wrong question. Its case is that Article 7 requires the Tribunal to determine Luxurico's objective intention at the time of acquisition and importation in November 2020, rather than undertaking a retrospective assessment of how the vehicle was ultimately used. Luxurico relies first upon the nature of the business and submit that it operated an established luxury vehicle hire business, and that the acquisition of the Index Vehicle was entirely consistent with that business model. The vehicle was acquired as a flagship hire vehicle intended to distinguish the business within a specialist and high-value market.
27. Luxurico further relies upon the objective evidence available at the time of acquisition. It points to the fact that commercial interest had already been generated before the vehicle arrived, that bookings had been secured in advance, that hire insurance was arranged from the outset and that the vehicle was advertised and marketed as available for hire. Luxurico accepts that there was limited evidence of completed hires during 2020 and 2021 but submits that this was the result of exceptional circumstances rather than any absence of commercial intention. It relies in particular upon the impact of Covid-19 restrictions, a succession of serious issues affecting the vehicle from shortly after delivery and the accident in June 2021 which rendered the vehicle unavailable for an extended period. Luxurico contends that those matters provide a coherent explanation for the vehicle's restricted commercial use and for the cancellation of anticipated hires.
28. As regards the mileage evidence, Luxurico accepts that the records are incomplete but submits that the deficiencies identified by HMRC do not establish private use, nor do they undermine the more substantial objective indicators of commercial intention present at acquisition. Luxurico argues that much of the vehicle's movement was connected with transportation, testing, marketing activity and repeated journeys associated with inspection and repair.
29. Luxurico likewise disputes HMRC's reliance on social media and YouTube content. It submits that online promotion formed an important part of the business's marketing strategy and that the Index Vehicle featured prominently because it was the flagship vehicle within the fleet. Luxurico argues that evidence of enthusiasm for the vehicle is not inconsistent with a commercial hire purpose and does not demonstrate that personal enjoyment was the dominant intended use.
30. Finally, Luxurico relies upon evidence that insurers, lawyers and representatives who investigated claims arising from the Index Vehicle on the basis that the Index Vehicle was being operated as part of a commercial hire business. Whilst not relying on confidential settlement terms, Luxurico submits that those investigations provide independent support for its case.
31. Luxurico therefore submits that, viewed objectively and in the round, the evidence demonstrates that the primary intended use of the Index Vehicle at the time of acquisition was self-drive hire and/or hire with a driver. It contends that the relevant condition contained in Article 7(2E) and 7(2F) was satisfied and that the appeal should be allowed. the evidence Witness Evidence
32. Saleem Iqbal
33. Mr Saleem Iqbal adopted his witness statement and gave oral evidence. He described himself as being responsible for the day-to-day operation of the Appellant's business. His evidence concerned the acquisition of the Index Vehicle, its intended role within the business and the events that followed its arrival in the United Kingdom.
34. Mr Iqbal explained that the Appellant operated a luxury vehicle hire business and that the decision to acquire the Index Vehicle formed part of a strategy to expand into the hypercar market. He stated that, at the time of acquisition, no other business in the United Kingdom was offering the Index Vehicle for hire and that the Appellant intended to be the first provider to make such a vehicle commercially available. According to his evidence, the Index Vehicle was intended to act as a flagship vehicle within the Appellant's fleet and to distinguish the business from its competitors.
35. Mr Iqbal stated that commercial interest in the vehicle existed before it arrived in the United Kingdom. He referred in particular to a booking and explained that arrangements had been made in anticipation of the vehicle's arrival. His evidence was that the vehicle attracted significant publicity and interest from potential customers from the outset.
36. Mr Iqbal gave evidence concerning the chronology following delivery of the vehicle. He stated that shortly after arrival the vehicle was wrapped in preparation for a booking and that issues relating to the vehicle then emerged. According to his evidence, which detailed the circumstances, these issues resulted in repeated journeys to London and, ultimately, outside the UK.
37. Mr Iqbal also described the accident occurring in June 2021. His evidence was that the vehicle had been supplied to a customer under a hire arrangement when it was involved in a rear-end collision. He explained that replacement parts were difficult to obtain because of the limited production of the vehicle and that, as a result, the Index Vehicle remained unavailable for a lengthy period. According to his evidence, the vehicle remained off the road until early 2022.
38. During cross-examination, HMRC questioned Mr Iqbal regarding the absence of mileage logs before March 2022. He accepted that no mileage records had been produced for the period immediately following acquisition. He denied, however, that the absence of such records demonstrated private use of the vehicle and maintained that the vehicle was not used for personal purposes. HMRC also questioned him regarding the increase in mileage between acquisition and March 2022. Mr Iqbal attributed that mileage to testing, transportation, repairs and the operation of the vehicle within the business.
39. Mr Iqbal was further questioned regarding insurance arrangements and accepted that he was not personally responsible for all insurance matters. His evidence was that insurance was arranged at the outset and that periods during which the vehicle was not continuously insured coincided with periods when it was unavailable because of accident damage or other issues.
40. HMRC also suggested that the vehicle had been used for private purposes. Mr Iqbal rejected that suggestion and maintained that the vehicle was intended to be used as part of the Appellant's commercial hire business.
41. Aleem Iqbal
42. Mr Aleem Iqbal adopted his witness statement and gave oral evidence. His evidence chiefly concerned the Appellant's marketing activities, social media presence and the role of the Index Vehicle within the business.
43. Mr Iqbal explained that he played a significant role in promoting the Appellant's business through social media. He described social media as a core commercial tool through which the business reached customers and generated enquiries. According to his evidence, visibility through online content was particularly important in the luxury and prestige vehicle market.
44. Mr Iqbal stated that the Index Vehicle was intended to operate as a flagship hire vehicle and that substantial interest in hiring the vehicle had been generated before it arrived in the United Kingdom. He referred to the booking received from the digital online agency and stated that the vehicle had been booked shortly after delivery. He also stated that the Index Vehicle was marketed and held out as available for hire from the outset.
45. HMRC cross-examined Mr Iqbal extensively regarding YouTube videos published through his "Lord Aleem" channel. He accepted that videos existed in which the Index Vehicle was described as a "dream car" and that enthusiasm for the vehicle was expressed. However, he maintained that references to the vehicle in social media content were linked to the promotion of the Appellant's business and that he discussed the company's activities throughout much of that content.
46. Mr Iqbal was also questioned about the transportation of the vehicle to Dubai in December 2022 and his participation in motoring-related events. HMRC suggested that those activities were at least partly motivated by personal enjoyment. Mr Iqbal disagreed. His evidence was that the vehicle was taken to Dubai because potential customers were located there and that the use of the vehicle was connected with promoting the business and its services.
47. HMRC further suggested that the vehicle was intended to be available for Mr Iqbal's personal use. He rejected that proposition and maintained that the vehicle was acquired and operated as part of the Appellant's luxury hire fleet.
48. In response to questions concerning the period between acquisition and the June 2021 accident, Mr Iqbal stated that the vehicle experienced repeated issues and spent substantial periods off the road undergoing repairs. According to his evidence, this largely explained the limited number of completed hires during that period.
49. Christopher Tyler
50. Mr Christopher Tyler adopted his witness statement and gave oral evidence concerning investigations previously carried out in respect of the Index Vehicle.
51. Mr Tyler explained that he had been involved in matters affecting the Index Vehicle, including the June 2021 accident. He stated that, in the course of those matters, insurers, lawyers and others investigated the nature of the Appellant's business and the basis on which losses were said to arise.
52. He gave evidence that those investigations considered whether the vehicle was genuinely being operated as a hire vehicle and whether losses arising from the vehicle's unavailability reflected lost commercial opportunities. According to his evidence, those investigations proceeded on the basis that the Index Vehicle was part of a vehicle-hire business and that it was being operated as a hire vehicle.
53. Mr Tyler accepted that settlement agreements existed and explained that they were subject to confidentiality provisions. He did not disclose the confidential terms of those agreements. However, his evidence was that the investigations carried out included consideration of whether the Index Vehicle was being operated commercially and whether losses resulting from issues and accident damage reflected lost hire income.
54. During cross-examination, Mr Tyler reiterated that the significance of his evidence was not the outcome of any settlement but the fact that independent third parties investigated and treated the Index Vehicle as a vehicle being operated within a commercial hire business.
55. HMRC Evidence
56. HMRC relied principally upon the witness statement of Mr Andrew Kirkby, together with the documentary evidence gathered during the course of HMRC's enquiry. HMRC did not challenge the existence of the Appellant's luxury hire business or the fact that the Index Vehicle had been advertised for hire. Instead, HMRC's evidence focused upon matters said to be inconsistent with the Appellant's assertion that hire represented the vehicle's primary intended use.
57. HMRC relied upon the absence of contemporaneous mileage records, discrepancies in mileage figures, the limited evidence of completed hires during 2020 and 2021, gaps in the insurance evidence and material drawn from social media and YouTube content. HMRC also relied upon the limited documentary evidence of actual hire activity before March 2022.
58. As reflected both in Mr Kirkby's witness statement and in the submissions made on behalf of HMRC, the Respondents' position was not that there was no intention to hire the vehicle. Rather, HMRC contended that the evidence did not establish that commercial hire represented the primary intended use of the vehicle at the time of acquisition.
59. Documentary Evidence
60. The Tribunal was referred to extensive documentary material contained in the hearing bundle. We do not propose to summarise every document, but certain categories of evidence were of particular importance. The documentary evidence included an insurance certificate issued shortly after acquisition showing that the Index Vehicle was insured for self-drive hire from November 2020. The Appellant relied upon that document as an objective indicator of intention existing at the time of acquisition. The bundle also contained website material and marketing content presenting the Index Vehicle as a vehicle available for hire. The Appellant relied upon that material as evidence that the vehicle was held out to the market for commercial use from the outset.
61. Of particular relevance were witness statements and documentary records relating to prospective hirers. Those documents recorded intended bookings that could not proceed because the vehicle became unavailable as a result of issues or accident damage. HMRC questioned the weight to be attached to those statements because the individuals concerned were not called as witnesses. The Appellant relied upon them as evidence of genuine commercial demand for the vehicle.
62. The Tribunal was further referred to workshop records and repair invoices documenting the history of issues affecting the vehicle. The evidence also included material relating to the June 2021 accident and the resulting repairs, and demonstrated that intended hires were cancelled and that the vehicle remained unavailable for a substantial period following the collision.
63. Finally, the bundle contained mileage records, hire invoices and documents relied upon by HMRC as evidence of alleged private use. The parties disagreed sharply as to the significance of those materials. We consider the proper weight to be attached to them below. findings of fact
64. We have considered all of the oral and documentary evidence, including the witness statements, the evidence given under cross-examination, the contemporaneous documents and the parties' submissions.
65. We recognise that aspects of Luxurico's records are incomplete, particularly in relation to mileage logs and contemporaneous documentation relating to the Index Vehicle’s use. We have taken those matters into account. However, the existence of shortcomings in the evidence does not absolve the Tribunal from reaching findings on the evidence as a whole.
66. Having considered all of the evidence, we make the following findings. Luxurico's business (1) At all material times, Luxurico carried on a genuine luxury vehicle hire business under the trading name Platinum Executive Travel. (2) The acquisition and operation of prestige and high-value vehicles formed a central part of that business. (3) The acquisition of the Index Vehicle was consistent with Luxurico's business model and commercial activities. (4) The Index Vehicle was acquired as a flagship vehicle intended to enhance Luxurico's position within the luxury and hypercar hire market. The circumstances of acquisition (5) Before the Index Vehicle arrived in the United Kingdom, Luxurico had already generated interest from prospective customers and had secured or anticipated bookings involving the vehicle. (6) We are satisfied that there was genuine commercial demand for the vehicle at the time it was acquired. (7) Shortly after acquisition, the Index Vehicle was insured for self-drive hire and was marketed as available for hire through Luxurico's existing business channels. (8) We find that both the insurance arrangements and the marketing of the vehicle were consistent with its intended operation as a hire vehicle. Issues with the Index Vehicle and its availability (9) The Index Vehicle suffered significant issues shortly after delivery. (10) Those issues required repeated inspections, repairs and transportation to specialist facilities. (11) The issues were not isolated incidents. They persisted over an extended period and materially affected the availability of the vehicle. (12) As a result, the Index Vehicle was unavailable for hire on numerous occasions during 2020 and 2021. The June 2021 accident (13) In June 2021 the Index Vehicle was involved in a significant accident whilst being used by a customer. (14) The damage caused by that accident required extensive repairs. (15) Owing to the specialist nature of the vehicle and the difficulty in obtaining replacement parts, the vehicle remained unavailable for a substantial period thereafter. (16) We find that anticipated bookings were lost or cancelled because of the accident and the resulting repair process. Covid-19 restrictions (17) During the period immediately following acquisition, Luxurico operated within a market that was materially affected by Covid-19 restrictions. (18) Those restrictions affected weddings, events and related activities which formed an important part of Luxurico's customer base. (19) We find that Covid-19 restrictions contributed to the reduction in commercial opportunities available during the relevant period. Mileage records (20) Luxurico did not maintain complete mileage records for the period between acquisition of the vehicle and March 2022. (21) The mileage evidence produced contains inconsistencies and is not a complete record of the vehicle's movements during that period. (22) We therefore accept HMRC's criticism that the mileage evidence is unsatisfactory. (23) However, we do not find that the mileage evidence demonstrates that the vehicle was acquired primarily for private purposes. Social media and alleged private use (24) The Index Vehicle featured prominently in social media content and YouTube videos involving Mr Aleem Iqbal. (25) Some of that content reflects enthusiasm for the vehicle and includes references to it as a desirable or aspirational car. (26) However, we also find that social media formed an important part of Luxurico's marketing strategy and customer engagement. (27) We do not find that the social media evidence establishes that personal use or enjoyment was the primary reason for acquiring the vehicle. Independent third-party investigations (28) Insurers, lawyers and representatives of the manufacturer investigated matters arising from the vehicle's issues and the June 2021 accident. (29) In doing so, they considered the basis upon which Luxurico claimed to have suffered loss of income arising from the vehicle's unavailability. (30) Without relying upon confidential settlement terms, we find that those investigations proceeded on the basis that the Index Vehicle was being operated as part of a commercial hire business. discussion The issue before the Tribunal
67. The issue before the Tribunal is a narrow one. The parties are agreed that the Index Vehicle was a qualifying motor car for the purposes of Article 7 of the Value Added Tax (Input Tax) Order 1992 and that self-drive hire and hire with a driver are relevant purposes within Article 7(2F). They are also agreed that entitlement to recover the input tax falls to be determined by reference to Luxurico's objective intention at the time the input tax was incurred. The dispute is therefore not one of legal principle but of application. The question we must determine is whether, viewed objectively and on the balance of probabilities, Luxurico intended primarily to use the vehicle for a relevant hiring purpose at the time of its acquisition and importation in November 2020.
68. HMRC contend that Luxurico has failed to establish the requisite intention. They point to the limited evidence of completed hires during 2020 and 2021, the absence of contemporaneous mileage records, inconsistencies within the mileage evidence eventually produced, gaps in insurance arrangements and aspects of the social media and other evidence said to be indicative of personal enjoyment. Luxurico submits that the objective evidence available at the point of acquisition points overwhelmingly towards a commercial hire purpose and that the vehicle's subsequent history was materially affected by Covid-19 restrictions, persistent issues and the June 2021 accident. The Tribunal's task is therefore to evaluate the evidence as a whole against the statutory test.
69. It is important at the outset to remain focused on the distinction between the statutory question and the evidence relied upon by the parties to address it. The question is not whether the vehicle was ultimately hired extensively, nor whether its subsequent use perfectly reflected the intentions that existed when it was acquired. Rather, the question is whether the dominant and objectively ascertainable intended primary use of the vehicle at the time input tax was incurred was commercial hire within the meaning of Article 7(2E) and 7(2F). Objective indicators of intention at acquisition
70. In our judgment, the most significant evidence in this appeal consists of the objective indicators present at or around the time of acquisition. When those matters are considered collectively, they point strongly towards a commercial hire purpose.
71. Luxurico was already operating an established luxury vehicle hire business. The acquisition of prestigious and high-value vehicles formed part of its ordinary commercial activity. The Index Vehicle was not acquired by a private individual but through a business whose principal activity involved the commercial hiring of luxury vehicles. We accept the evidence that the Index Vehicle was intended to serve as a flagship vehicle within that fleet, differentiating Luxurico within a competitive luxury and hypercar hire market. Whilst HMRC are correct to submit that the nature of the business does not by itself answer the statutory question, it forms an important part of the objective context within which intention must be assessed.
72. We also attach significant weight to the evidence of commercial interest in the vehicle before it became operational in the United Kingdom. Although HMRC criticised aspects of the evidence relating to advance bookings and prospective hires, we are satisfied that the vehicle was generating commercial interest before it arrived and before it became available to customers. That is an objective circumstance consistent with acquisition for commercial exploitation and considerably more difficult to reconcile with a contention that the vehicle was acquired primarily for private enjoyment.
73. The contemporaneous insurance and marketing evidence points in the same direction. Shortly after acquisition, the vehicle was insured for self-drive hire and was actively marketed through the same channels used by Luxurico to promote the remainder of its fleet. Neither factor is determinative in isolation, but both are objective commercial acts undertaken contemporaneously with acquisition. They demonstrate that practical steps were taken to place the vehicle into commercial service and to make it available to customers. The vehicle was not held privately or kept outside the business and it was presented to the market as part of Luxurico's hire offering.
74. HMRC rely upon gaps and changes in later insurance arrangements. We do not consider those matters materially diminish the significance of the contemporaneous insurance evidence. The statutory question concerns intention at acquisition. Further, those later arrangements must be viewed against the evidence of recurring issues and the subsequent accident, both of which materially affected the vehicle's availability. In those circumstances, interruptions in insurance cover are not inconsistent with the explanation advanced by Luxurico. Subsequent use and HMRC's evidential criticisms
75. HMRC place considerable reliance upon the limited evidence of completed hires and deficiencies in the mileage records. We accept that both criticisms are justified to an extent. The absence of comprehensive mileage logs is unsatisfactory and there are inconsistencies in aspects of the mileage evidence eventually produced. Likewise, the documentary evidence of completed hires during 2020 and 2021 is considerably less extensive than might ordinarily be expected in the case of a vehicle acquired for commercial hiring.
76. However, the significance of those matters must be viewed in light of the issue we are required to determine. They relate principally to the vehicle's subsequent use rather than the intention which existed when the input tax was incurred. Had the issue before us been the precise use of the vehicle throughout a particular period, these deficiencies would have assumed greater importance. The present issue is different.
77. The absence of comprehensive mileage records does not establish that the vehicle was acquired for private use. At most, it limits the Tribunal's ability to reconstruct every journey undertaken by the vehicle. Equally, whilst limited hire activity may in some circumstances support an inference that a purported hiring purpose was not genuine, the force of that submission depends upon whether there is a credible explanation for the position. In our judgment, there is. The evidence demonstrates that the vehicle suffered persistent and significant problems shortly after delivery, requiring repeated specialist involvement and repeated journeys associated with testing, transportation and repair. In addition, the vehicle operated in a market heavily connected with weddings, events and related activities during a period affected by Covid-19 restrictions. The June 2021 accident then rendered the vehicle unavailable for a prolonged period and resulted in anticipated bookings not proceeding. None of those matters was seriously challenged by HMRC.
78. Considered individually, each of those factors would have affected the vehicle's availability. Considered together, they provide a coherent and persuasive explanation for why the level of completed hire activity fell materially below what might otherwise have been expected. Their significance is not that they independently establish intention at acquisition, but that they substantially weaken the inferences HMRC seek to draw from the subsequent hiring history. Personal enjoyment and the social media evidence
79. HMRC also rely upon social media material, YouTube content and aspects of the Dubai evidence as supporting an inference of personal use. We accept that some of the material demonstrates enthusiasm for the vehicle and that those associated with Luxurico derived enjoyment from its ownership. References describing the vehicle as a "dream car" are capable of supporting that conclusion. However, that is not the statutory question before us. The existence of personal enjoyment is not inconsistent with a commercial hire intention. The relevant question is whether personal use or enjoyment represented the dominant intended use of the vehicle at the time it was acquired.
80. We do not consider that the social media evidence establishes that proposition. We accept the evidence that social media formed a significant part of Luxurico's marketing strategy and that the Index Vehicle featured prominently because it was intended to be the flagship vehicle within the fleet. The material relied upon by HMRC is therefore capable of supporting more than one interpretation. In those circumstances, we do not regard it as sufficient to outweigh the objective indicators pointing towards commercial hire.
81. Similar observations apply to the Dubai evidence. Even if there was an element of personal enjoyment associated with those events, that does not establish that the dominant intention in November 2020 was private use. We therefore attach only limited weight to this aspect of HMRC's case. Overall assessment
82. Having assessed the evidence objectively and as a whole, we conclude that the dominant and most important intended use of the Index Vehicle at the time of acquisition and importation was commercial hire through Luxurico's luxury vehicle hire business. The condition in Article 7(2E) is therefore satisfied. It follows that the vehicle was intended primarily for self-drive hire and/or hire with a driver within Article 7(2F), with the result that the input tax restriction in Article 7(1) does not apply.
83. We are satisfied that Luxurico has discharged the burden of proving that, at the time of acquisition and importation in November 2020, it intended primarily to use the Index Vehicle for a relevant purpose within Article 7(2E) and 7(2F). conclusion
84. The appeal is therefore allowed. Right to apply for permission to appeal
85. This document contains full findings of fact and reasons for the decision. Any party dissatisfied with this decision has a right to apply for permission to appeal against it pursuant to Rule 39 of the Tribunal Procedure (First-tier Tribunal) (Tax Chamber) Rules 2009. The application must be received by this Tribunal not later than 56 days after this decision is sent to that party. The parties are referred to “Guidance to accompany a Decision from the First-tier Tribunal (Tax Chamber)” which accompanies and forms part of this decision notice. Release date: 27 August 2026