UK case law
M and N Beauty Limited v The Commissioners for HMRC
[2026] UKFTT TC 1411 · First-tier Tribunal (Tax Chamber) · 2026
The verbatim text of this UK judgment. Sourced directly from The National Archives Find Case Law. Not an AI summary, not a paraphrase — every word below is the original ruling, under Crown copyright and the Open Government Licence v3.0.
Full judgment
Introduction
1. This appeal concerns a civil evasion penalty imposed by the Respondents on the Appellant pursuant to s.8 Finance Act 1994 and s.25 Finance Act 2003 .
2. The penalty arose following the seizure by Border Force officers of 506,400 cigarettes concealed within boxes loaded in a maritime container at Tilbury Docks on 23 November 2022. The container was consigned to the Appellant. The cigarettes had not been declared for customs or excise purposes. The Respondents contend that the Appellant was knowingly concerned in a deliberate attempt to evade excise duty, customs duty and import VAT.
3. The Respondents assessed a combined civil evasion penalty of £181,201. Following an internal review, the assessment was upheld. The Appellant appealed to the Tribunal.
4. The central issue for the Tribunal is whether the Respondents have established, on the balance of probabilities, that the Appellant engaged in dishonest conduct for the purpose of evading duty.
5. We have concluded that they have, and that it did. Therefore, for the reasons set out below, we have decided to dismiss this appeal and confirm the penalty in the amount assessed by the Respondents. Procedural History
6. On 23 November 2022 officers of Border Force examined container ACLU9681666 at Tilbury. During that examination they discovered 506,400 cigarettes concealed amongst goods declared as hair products and food products.
7. A Notice of Seizure was subsequently issued in respect of the cigarettes. The Appellant did not appeal the seizure in the Magistrates’ Court.
8. On 3 December 2022, the Appellant submitted a request seeking restoration of the seized goods.
9. By a decision dated 20 January 2023, restoration was refused. No appeal was made against this refusal.
10. HMRC subsequently commenced enquiries into the circumstances of the importation and, following correspondence with the Appellant, they imposed a civil evasion penalty assessed in the amount of £181,201.
11. The Appellant sought an internal HMRC review of that assessment. By a review conclusion letter dated 25 January 2024, the Respondents upheld the penalty decision.
12. The present appeal was then notified to the Tribunal.
13. At various stages during the appeal the Appellant was professionally represented. Initially the Appellant was represented by Lawmans Solicitors Ltd. Subsequently, representation passed to Buzzacott LLP. By the time of the hearing, however, the Appellant was no longer professionally represented, and it appeared only by its Director, Mr Moses Okeoma. Preliminary issue – Late Evidence
14. Shortly before the hearing, the Respondents applied for permission to rely upon four documents which had not formed part of the original hearing bundle. Those documents comprised: (1) import declaration data relating to the shipment; (2) correspondence describing three previous tobacco seizures connected with the Appellant; (3) correspondence dated June 2025 from the Appellant's former representatives, Buzzacott; and (4) a printout from the GOV.UK website entitled "Goods liable to Excise Duty".
15. The Tribunal's power to admit evidence is contained in Rule 15(2) of the Tribunal Procedure (First-tier Tribunal) (Tax Chamber) Rules 2009. In exercising that power, the Tribunal must seek to give effect to the overriding objective in Rule 2 of dealing with cases fairly and justly.
16. The Tribunal considered that the import declaration data, the evidence relating to previous seizures, and the correspondence from the Appellant's former representatives were all relevant to issues which lay at the heart of the appeal.
17. Mr Okeoma did not object to any of the documents being admitted.
18. The Tribunal accepted the submission made on behalf of the Respondents by Mr Nyoni that the Buzzacott correspondence was, if anything, capable of assisting the Appellant's case rather than prejudicing it. The Tribunal equally accepted that the import data and evidence concerning previous seizures were plainly relevant to matters already in dispute between the parties. None of those documents introduced a new case or altered the issues requiring determination. The Tribunal therefore admitted those three documents into evidence.
19. But the Tribunal reached a different conclusion in relation to the GOV.UK guidance document, because no issue arose in the appeal over whether cigarettes are goods liable to excise duty. That proposition was not disputed and is incapable of serious dispute. The Tribunal therefore concluded that the document was not material and declined to admit it.
20. The Appellant similarly made a late application during the hearing to rely on two additional documents: (1) the Buzzacott correspondence described above (which we had already decided to admit); and (2) a witness statement signed by Mr Bosun Dare, who was said to be the owner and operator of Infinity Limited.
21. The Tribunal observed that the introduction of Mr Dare's witness statement at that very late stage had the potential to cause prejudice to the Respondents, who had not previously had a proper opportunity to consider it.
22. Nevertheless, the witness statement was plainly relevant to the issues in dispute, and Mr Dare was attending the video hearing and would be able to give oral evidence, including in cross-examination. Importantly, Mr Nyoni did not object to Mr Dare’s witness statement being introduced, and he confirmed that provided he was given the lunch break to prepare (which the Tribunal agreed to), he said would be able satisfactorily to cross examine Mr Dare. The Tribunal was grateful to Mr Nyoni for his flexibility in that regard. Although with some hesitation, the Tribunal therefore decided that it would admit Mr Dare’s witness statement into evidence, and it afforded Mr Nyomi the time he had sought over the lunch break to consider the witness statement before cross-examining Mr Dare.
23. Having admitted the documents referred to above, the Tribunal did not consider that their lateness should of itself affect the weight to be attributed to them. No such submission was advanced by either party. The Tribunal therefore decided that it would assess each document according to its substantive evidential value, rather than the circumstances of its production. The Evidence
24. The Tribunal was provided with a hearing bundle prepared by the Respondents, together with an authorities bundle. In addition, for the reasons set out above, the Tribunal admitted the documents described above which were not in the hearing bundle.
25. That documentary evidence included: (1) correspondence concerning the seizure of the cigarettes and the subsequent refusal of restoration; (2) correspondence between HMRC and the Appellant during the course of HMRC's enquiries; (3) the Appellant's Notice of Appeal; (4) the witness statements of Ms Lucy Grant of Border Force and Ms Siwanna Halliday of HMRC, both prepared on behalf of the Respondents; (5) import declaration and customs documentation relating to the shipment; (6) photographs taken by Border Force during the examination of the container; (7) correspondence from the Appellant's former representatives, including both Lawmans Solicitors and Buzzacott LLP; (8) evidence relating to three previous seizures involving tobacco products; and (9) the witness statement of Mr Bosun Dare.
26. The Tribunal carefully considered all of the documentary evidence placed before it (whether or not expressly referred to below).
27. Regrettably, the Appellant did not file and a serve witness statement by Mr Okeoma, who represented the Appellant at the hearing, and whom, with HMRC’s agreement, we nevertheless permitted to give evidence. Nor did it file and serve a witness statement by Mrs Okeoma, despite the fact that some of the material before the Tribunal related to her and on which her testimony may have assisted the Tribunal. Oral Evidence for the Respondents Ms Lucy Grant
28. The Tribunal heard sworn oral evidence from Ms Lucy Grant, a Border Force officer involved in the examination of the container and the seizure of the cigarettes.
29. Ms Grant adopted her witness statement as her evidence in chief and answered questions from Mr Nyoni, the Appellant and the Tribunal.
30. Ms Grant gave evidence concerning: (1) the examination of the container; (2) the discovery and seizure of the cigarettes; (3) the arrangement of the goods within the container; and (4) the photographs and other records created during the course of the seizure.
31. The Tribunal found Ms Grant to be a careful and reliable witness. Her evidence was measured, straightforward and consistent with the contemporaneous documentation. Nothing which emerged during questioning caused the Tribunal to doubt her honesty or reliability.
32. The Tribunal therefore accepts the evidence of Ms Grant in its entirety. Ms Siwanna Halliday
33. The Tribunal also heard sworn oral evidence from Ms Siwanna Halliday, the HMRC officer responsible for the civil evasion penalty investigation.
34. Ms Halliday adopted her witness statement as her evidence in chief and answered questions from Mr Nyoni, the Appellant and the Tribunal.
35. Her evidence concerned: (1) the conduct of HMRC's investigation; (2) the information obtained from the Appellant; (3) HMRC's conclusions concerning the Appellant's knowledge of the cigarettes; and (4) the calculation of the civil evasion penalty.
36. The Tribunal found Ms Halliday to be an honest and reliable witness whose objective was to assist the Tribunal. Her evidence was consistent with the underlying documentation and was not materially challenged in cross-examination.
37. The Tribunal therefore accepts the evidence of Ms Halliday in its entirety. Oral Evidence for the Appellant Mr Moses Okeoma
38. The Tribunal heard sworn oral evidence from Mr Moses Okeoma, a director of the Appellant, who was cross-examined by Mr Nyoni and also answered questions from the Tribunal.
39. Mr Okeoma gave evidence concerning: (1) the Appellant's business; (2) its importation arrangements from Nigeria; (3) the operation of what he described as a “groupage” system for the shipment of goods belonging to third parties; (4) the role played by Infinity Limited and Mr Bosun Dare; (5) the seizure of the cigarettes; (6) his request for restoration; and (7) the circumstances surrounding the previous seizures relied upon by the Respondents.
40. Mr Okeoma also gave evidence that the entity identified on the shipping documentation as “Moses Okeoma Nig Ltd” did not in fact exist, but was simply a name used for convenience on shipping documentation.
41. Mr Okeoma’s evidence was that he had been very angry with Mr Dare following the seizure of products from the shipment under consideration in this appeal, and he claimed not to have undertaken any business with him since that date.
42. The Tribunal did not find Mr Okeoma to be a truthful witness.
43. As explained in more detail below, the Tribunal found that significant aspects of his evidence were inconsistent with: (1) the contemporary documents; (2) the photographic evidence; (3) the objective shipping records; and (4) earlier explanations advanced on the Appellant's behalf.
44. The Tribunal was also concerned by the evolution of the Appellant's account over time. The Appellant was previously represented first by Lawmans Solicitors and later by Buzzacott LLP. In each case, the firm concerned was purportedly acting upon instructions provided by the Appellant.
45. The factual account advanced by Buzzacott LLP differed materially from that previously advanced by Lawmans Solicitors. In particular, the later representations developed and expanded explanations concerning the operation of the groupage arrangements, the ownership of the cigarettes, the alleged involvement of "Mr Abiodun", the significance of handwritten names on boxes, the additional tape observed by Border Force, and the reason why the Appellant sought restoration of the seized goods.
46. Of particular significance was the explanation ultimately advanced in relation to the restoration request. The Tribunal notes that this aspect of the Appellant's case was reframed by Buzzacott LLP as part of the contention that the Appellant was acting on behalf of a third party who owned the cigarettes. That explanation was consistent with the evidence later given by Mr Dare. However, for the reasons already explained, the Tribunal rejected that evidence and rejected the underlying factual premise upon which it depended.
47. The Tribunal accepts that legal representatives may refine or improve the presentation of a client's case. However, what occurred here went beyond mere refinement. Material aspects of the factual narrative changed over time. The Tribunal found it difficult to reconcile those changing accounts with the contention that the Appellant was simply recounting a truthful and consistent explanation of events.
48. This was a factor which contributed to the Tribunal's conclusion that the evidence of Mr Okeoma was not reliable and that the explanations ultimately advanced on behalf of the Appellant had been reconstructed in an attempt to answer difficulties identified in the original account rather than to describe what had actually happened. We reached the view that material parts of Mr Okeoma's evidence were intentionally false and designed to mislead the Tribunal.
49. One aspect of Mr Okeoma’s evidence that the Tribunal does accept was in respect of the use of “groupage” arrangements. The Tribunal notes that, in the ordinary language of the shipping and freight-forwarding industry, "groupage" refers to the consolidation of consignments from multiple customers into a single container or shipment, with the transport costs being shared between those customers.
50. The Tribunal accepts that groupage arrangements are a common and legitimate feature of international shipping and accepts that the Appellant genuinely used such arrangements in relation to some consignments. The existence of groupage arrangements therefore formed no part of the Tribunal's reasoning against the Appellant. The difficulty for the Appellant was that the evidence demonstrated that the mere fact of the groupage arrangement did not provide a credible explanation for the presence of the seized cigarettes in this case.
51. The Tribunal accepts that persons wishing to send goods from Nigeria to the United Kingdom could agree for their goods to be included within containers shipped for the Appellant's business under a groupage arrangement. Those customers were charged by reference to the weight of the goods shipped on a per-kilogram basis. Mr Okeoma and Mr Dare described this as a means of allowing several customers to share shipping and transport costs. On arrival in the United Kingdom, the Appellant would receive the container, and the individual owners would then make arrangements with it (via Mr Okeoma) to collect their goods. The Tribunal accepts that such arrangements genuinely existed and formed part of the Appellant's business model.
52. However, for the reasons explained below, the Tribunal does not accept that the groupage arrangements provide an innocent explanation for the cigarettes seized from the shipment in question.
53. In his evidence, Mr Okeoma explained his view that conducting business in Nigeria is entirely unlike conducting business in the UK, and arrangements are often informal, unwritten, arranged at the last-minute, and based on personal relationships. To that extent, the Tribunal is willing to accept Mr Okeoma’s evidence in general terms.
54. Mr Okeoma accepted in cross-examination that this informality was used by some in Nigeria to facilitate and disguise criminal endeavours, but he claimed that he would never participate in such matters. Mr Nyoni put to Mr Okeoma that, contrary to his claim that he would never participate in smuggling operations, three seizures of cigarettes in shipments to the Appellant had occurred before this one – in those cases, by air freight.
55. Mr Okeoma’s evidence about the prior seizures was confusing, and it was hard for the Tribunal to ascertain to what extent, if at all, Mr Okeoma accepted the fact of the three prior seizures. On the one hand, Mr Okeoma denied that the Appellant had had any prior involvement with tobacco seizures. He even said he was unsure whether he even had any knowledge of them, and could not recall whether he had received official correspondence about them. But on the other hand, on further questioning, he changed his position, saying that the earlier seizures had occurred because third parties had used the Appellant’s name in their own smuggling enterprise, and that the seized cigarettes had had nothing to do with the Appellant. Mr Nyoni put it to Mr Okeoma that the seized cigarettes had arrived in the UK as part of the Appellant’s own shipments, to which Mr Okeoma replied that this was because third parties who were not known to him had abused the groupage arrangement.
56. The Tribunal accepts on the balance of probabilities that the three prior seizures did occur. The Tribunal considers that Mr Okeoma, for the Appellant, must have known of those seizures because it is highly implausible that he could have been unaware of them. However, the Tribunal did not have full facts about the earlier seizures in evidence before it, and it was therefore unable to come to any concluded view as to the involvement or otherwise of the Appellant in respect of them. For the reasons explained below, this was not a material factor in the Tribunal’s determination of this appeal. Mr Bosun Dare
57. The Tribunal also heard sworn oral evidence from Mr Bosun Dare, who described himself as the owner and operator of Infinity Limited.
58. Mr Dare adopted his witness statement as his evidence in chief.
59. In summary, his evidence was that: (1) he was responsible for arranging and loading the container in Nigeria; (2) the Appellant ordered only hair extension products; (3) the cigarettes had been introduced into the shipment by another individual whom he identified as “Mr Abiodun”; (4) the Appellant was unaware of the cigarettes; and (5) following the seizure, the Appellant had sought restoration on behalf of that individual.
60. As recorded in Mr Dare’s witness statement, which he confirmed in his oral testimony, Mr Dare’s evidence was that: The orders the Appellant makes are never sufficient to fill a shipping container. Therefore, to reduce the shipping costs to the Appellant, and to supplement our income, we work with the Appellant's agent, Solanik Nigeria Limited, to operate a Groupage scheme whereby we find individuals (usually businesses) who also wish to ship items to the UK. Those people bring their items to Infinity’s premises when we are loading the container for transport. The particular container in question was loaded on 7 September 2022. The container was sent to us for loading, and the Appellants goods were loaded along with the other parcels provided by users of the Groupage scheme. Towards the end of the day, when the container was almost ready to leave, another customer of mine, Mr. Abiodun, who also often brought hair extensions from Infinity, arrived with some individuals who worked with him and asked for his goods to be included in the container. As there was space, I allowed them to load those goods into the container. I didn’t supervise the loading and nor did I ask what he was shipping. He had a large number of parcels, and I estimate the loading took 90-120 boxes.
61. During the course of Mr Dare’s evidence, the Tribunal developed significant concerns regarding the reliability and truthfulness of his account. Upon questioning by the Tribunal, Mr Dare accepted that two relatively minor – but easily verifiable – points in his witness statement were untrue: first, that he had “ worked with the Appellant for around 25 years ”, which he accepted in answer to a question from the Tribunal was not the case, as Mr Okeoma’s evidence was that the Appellant had only been trading since 2017; and secondly, that “ The orders the Appellant makes are never sufficient to fill a shipping container ”, on which Mr Dare’s own oral evidence, together with that of Mr Okeoma, was that the Appellant’s shipments did, on occasion, fill an entire container.
62. Whilst Mr Dare's oral evidence demonstrated that his command of spoken English was limited, as he experienced some difficulty in expressing himself clearly, the witness statement purportedly attributed to him (and apparently signed by him, albeit with a defective statement of truth) is written in relatively fluent English. In light of these issues, Judge Austen asked Mr Dare whether he had prepared his Witness Statement himself, and whether he relied on it. Mr Dare said that he had, and he did. Whilst it is rarely appropriate for the Tribunal to make a positive finding as to who drafted a witness statement in the absence of evidence on the point, the Tribunal considers it unlikely on the balance of probabilities that Mr Dare's linguistic abilities could vary so markedly between his written witness statement and his oral evidence. We are not satisfied that the statement represents Mr Dare's own language and recollection, as it purports to do. That conclusion is reinforced by the presence of factual assertions within the statement which Mr Dare himself accepted were incorrect. These factors significantly reduced the Tribunal’s confidence in Mr Dare’s evidence, and this is reflected in the weight the Tribunal can accord it.
63. At multiple points in his oral evidence, Mr Dare was evasive and failed to answer questions (either satisfactorily or at all) put to him by Mr Nyoni in cross examination or by the Tribunal. For example, after Mr Nyoni took Mr Dare through his evidence about “Mr Abiodun” adding boxes to the container (those boxes allegedly containing the cigarettes – unbeknownst to Mr Dare, he said), Mr Nyoni asked Mr Dare whether he could describe any differences between the boxes purportedly added to the container by “Mr Abiodun” and those containing the Appellant’s products. Mr Dare was unable to answer this simple question. Judge Austen put the same question to Mr Dare four times, in slightly different ways, and again Mr Dare was unable to answer it. Judge Fairpo then put it to Mr Dare that she believed she had heard him say that the boxes “Mr Abiodun” had brought were different to the boxes containing Xpression hair extensions belonging to the Appellant, which Mr Dare confirmed. Mr Nyoni then asked Mr Dare if all the boxes apparently added by “Mr Abiodun” had the name “Samuel” written on them, which Mr Dare confirmed was the case. Mr Nyoni followed up by asking whether Mr Dare accepted it was ‘convenient’ that a person whom it was impossible to trace, and whom Mr Dare said he did not personally see load boxes, was supposed to be the owner of the cigarettes, even though Mr Dare could on the one hand not describe any differences between the Appellant’s boxes and “Mr Abiodun’s” boxes, though on the other hand knew that “Mr Abiodun’s” boxes had the name “Samuel” written on them. Mr Dare answered "Yes", adding only that this was "because Mr Moses [Okeoma] had Xpression hair". The Tribunal was unable to discern any logical connection between the question posed and the answer given. At other times, Mr Dare repeatedly said that “Mr Moses [Okeoma] is a good person to work with”, in reply to questions about entirely different points, such as the existence or otherwise of “Mr Abiodun”.
64. During the course of his evidence, the Tribunal became sufficiently concerned about the truthfulness of Mr Dare's account that Judge Austen considered it necessary to remind him that he was giving evidence on oath and to explain the legal consequences which may arise if a witness knowingly gives false evidence. Mr Dare was expressly invited to reflect upon the evidence he had given and to correct or amend any part of it if he wished to do so. He declined that opportunity and confirmed that he wished his evidence to stand unchanged.
65. Having considered the evidence as a whole, the Tribunal concluded that Mr Dare's account of the circumstances in which the cigarettes came to be loaded into the container was untrue. In reaching that conclusion, we have taken into account, amongst other matters, the inaccuracies contained within his witness statement, his evasiveness when answering straightforward questions, his inability to provide coherent explanations for significant aspects of his account, and the inherent improbabilities within the version of events he advanced. The Tribunal is satisfied that material parts of Mr Dare's evidence were fabricated and that he was deliberately seeking to mislead the Tribunal.
66. The Tribunal therefore rejected Mr Dare’s evidence save where it was independently supported by other evidence which the Tribunal accepted. Findings of Fact The shipment and seizure
67. On 23 November 2022 officers of Border Force examined container ACLU9681666 following its arrival at Tilbury.
68. The container had been consigned to the Appellant.
69. During the examination, Border Force officers discovered 506,400 cigarettes concealed within the goods contained in the shipment.
70. The cigarettes had not been declared for customs or excise purposes.
71. The cigarettes were seized.
72. The Tribunal accepts without reservation the evidence of Ms Lucy Grant concerning the examination of the container, the discovery of the cigarettes and the photographic evidence created during the seizure process.
73. The Tribunal finds that the cigarettes had been deliberately concealed within boxes of goods appearing to contain Xpression hair extension products.
74. The Tribunal further finds that the concealment was deliberate and sophisticated. The cigarettes were not readily visible without opening the relevant boxes and removing the products which had been placed around or above them. The Appellant's importation arrangements
75. At all material times, the Appellant operated a business importing hair extension products from Nigeria into the United Kingdom.
76. The Tribunal accepts that the Appellant had, on previous occasions, used what was described as a "groupage" arrangement under which goods belonging to third parties were included within containers shipped to the United Kingdom in the Appellant's name.
77. The Tribunal also accepts that the shipment which is the subject of this appeal included goods belonging to at least one third party, namely noodles which were transported within the same container.
78. The Tribunal therefore accepts that a genuine groupage arrangement existed in relation to some of the contents of the container.
79. However, the Tribunal finds that the existence of that groupage arrangement does not explain the presence of the concealed cigarettes. The exporter and the Nigerian shipping arrangements
80. The shipment documentation identified the exporter as "Moses Okeoma Nig Ltd". The Tribunal accepts Mr Okeoma's concession in evidence that no such separate legal entity existed, and that the name was used despite that fact in connection with shipping arrangements originating from Nigeria. The Tribunal makes no finding as to the Appellant’s intention or purpose in using the name of a non-existent company as the named exporter on shipping documents concerning the importation of goods into the UK.
81. The Tribunal does, however, find that Mr Okeoma’s concession that "Moses Okeoma Nig Ltd" does not exist does show that no independent third-party exporter (other than the Appellant) was concerned in the seized shipment.
82. The Tribunal accepts, and finds as fact, that Mr Bosun Dare, trading through Infinity Limited, played an important role in arranging and loading shipments in Nigeria. However, the Tribunal does not accept that Mr Dare acted independently of the Appellant. The Tribunal found Mr Dare to be an unreliable and untruthful witness whose evidence on material matters was deliberately false. Having considered all the evidence, the Tribunal finds that, in relation to the shipment which is the subject of this appeal, Mr Dare acted on behalf of and as agent for the Appellant, and with the Appellant's knowledge and authority in relation to the shipment.
83. The Tribunal finds that the Appellant exercised a high degree of control over the materially relevant aspects of the shipping arrangements at both the Nigerian and United Kingdom ends of the transaction. The seized cigarettes and the Appellant's boxes
84. The Tribunal rejects the Appellant's contention that the cigarettes were concealed within boxes belonging to unknown third parties participating in the groupage arrangement. Conversely, the Tribunal accepts the Respondents' evidence that the cigarettes were concealed within boxes of Xpression hair extensions associated with the Appellant.
85. In reaching those conclusions, the Tribunal places particular weight on: (1) the photographic evidence recorded by Border Force; (2) the evidence of Ms Grant; (3) the shipping documentation; (4) the numerical inconsistencies which emerged from the Appellant's account when compared with the number of boxes shipped, seized and ultimately received; and (5) the Tribunal's rejection of the evidence given by both Mr Okeoma and Mr Dare concerning the alleged involvement of "Mr Abiodun".
86. Having carefully reviewed the documentary material before the hearing, the Tribunal repeatedly sought an explanation from Mr Okeoma during his oral evidence for the discrepancy which would arise, if his evidence was to be believed, between: (1) the number of boxes of hair extension products which the Appellant expected to receive; (2) the number of boxes seized by Border Force; and (3) the number of boxes ultimately received by the Appellant.
87. The import declaration recorded the shipment as containing 464 packages of hair products (“Xpression” coloured nylon hair extensions), and 1,500 packages of noodles. The Appellant's evidence was that the hair products belonged to it, whereas the noodles belonged to a third party who was participating in a groupage arrangement.
88. The Appellant's case was that the concealed cigarettes had been introduced into the container by others and were not concealed within the Appellant's own products.
89. The Tribunal examined that proposition by reference to the number of Xpression boxes which the Appellant expected to receive, the number of boxes seized by Border Force, and the number of boxes ultimately received following release of the legitimate goods.
90. The Tribunal finds that, if the Appellant's account were correct, the arithmetic does not work. The Appellant's evidence was that it had ordered 464 boxes of Xpression hair extension products. Following the seizure, all goods not containing cigarettes were released. In those circumstances, if the boxes seized by Border Force had belonged to other participants in the groupage arrangement, the Appellant would ordinarily still have expected to receive the full quantity of its own Xpression products.
91. However, that is not what occurred. The evidence demonstrates that there would be a significant shortfall between the number of boxes which the Appellant expected to receive and the number ultimately obtained if Mr Okeoma’s evidence was to be believed.
92. The Tribunal finds that the existence of that shortfall provides compelling evidence that at least some of the boxes seized by Border Force formed part of the Appellant's own shipment of Xpression products.
93. The Tribunal therefore rejects the suggestion that the seized cigarette boxes belonged exclusively to unknown third parties participating in the groupage arrangement.
94. This conclusion is reinforced by the restoration request made by the Appellant. The Tribunal notes that the Appellant sought restoration of a quantity of boxes broadly corresponding to those seized. As Judge Fairpo put to Mr Okeoma during his evidence, had the seized boxes not formed part of the Appellant's own order, there would have been no obvious reason for the Appellant to seek their restoration because the Appellant would already have received the Xpression products it had ordered. Mr Okeoma had no satisfactory reply to that point.
95. The Tribunal regards this point as particularly significant because, unlike many of the disputed issues in the appeal, it does not depend primarily upon an assessment of witness credibility. It arises from the objective consequences of the Appellant's own account. The Tribunal was unable to reconcile that account with the documentary and numerical evidence.
96. The Tribunal therefore finds that the seized cigarettes were concealed within boxes forming part of the Appellant's own consignment of Xpression hair extension products.
97. The Tribunal finds that the discrepancy is incapable of being reconciled with the Appellant's account of the cigarettes having been introduced into boxes belonging to other participants in the groupage arrangement.
98. The Tribunal finds that the discrepancy is consistent only with the concealed cigarettes having been contained within boxes associated with the Appellant's own products.
99. The Tribunal therefore rejects the factual basis of the Appellant's explanation for the presence of the cigarettes.
100. The Tribunal is also reinforced in these conclusions by its conclusions about Mr Dare's credibility (set out below). The central explanation advanced by the Appellant for the presence of the cigarettes depended upon Mr Dare's account that they had been introduced into the container by an individual known as "Mr Abiodun". For the reasons explained in the following section, the Tribunal rejects that account in its entirety. Mr Dare’s evidence
101. The Tribunal found Mr Dare to be an unreliable witness. We were not impressed by his evidence and concluded that he was knowingly attempting to mislead the Tribunal by giving evidence which he knew to be false.
102. In reaching that conclusion, the Tribunal has had regard to the guidance contained in the Equal Treatment Bench Book concerning intercultural communication and the need for caution when evaluating matters such as communication style, emotional expression, body language and other aspects of demeanour. The Tribunal has accordingly been careful not to place weight upon matters which may be influenced by cultural background or other personal characteristics. Our conclusion rests instead upon the substance of Mr Dare's evidence when considered alongside the documentary evidence, the inherent probabilities of the case, the admitted inaccuracies within his witness statement, Mr Dare’s inability to provide coherent explanations for significant aspects of his account, and his inadequate responses to questioning by both Mr Nyoni and the Tribunal.
103. The Tribunal found significant aspects of Mr Dare's account inherently implausible. In particular, the Tribunal found it improbable that a person supposedly responsible for introducing more than half a million illicit cigarettes into the container would be someone whose identity, whereabouts and involvement could not be established other than through Mr Dare's own evidence.
104. The Tribunal rejects Mr Dare's evidence that an individual referred to as "Mr Abiodun" was responsible for introducing the cigarettes into the container. The Tribunal does not accept that the cigarettes were loaded into the container by an unknown third party acting independently of both the Appellant and Mr Dare, nor does it accept that the cigarettes belonged to such a person.
105. The Tribunal likewise rejects Mr Dare's evidence concerning the alleged efforts made after the seizure to identify or contact "Mr Abiodun". We do not accept that account as truthful.
106. Having considered the evidence as a whole, the Tribunal finds that the account advanced by Mr Dare concerning "Mr Abiodun" was fabricated. The Tribunal is satisfied that Mr Dare knowingly gave false evidence about the circumstances in which the cigarettes came to be loaded into the container. That conclusion remains the Tribunal's finding notwithstanding the opportunity expressly afforded to Mr Dare during his oral evidence to correct or amend any part of his account if he wished to do so.
107. The Tribunal therefore rejects Mr Dare's evidence save where it is independently corroborated by other evidence which the Tribunal accepts. Previous seizures
108. Prior to the events giving rise to this appeal, there had been three earlier seizures involving tobacco products connected with shipments associated with the Appellant.
109. The Tribunal finds that those earlier seizures occurred as described by the Respondents.
110. The Tribunal accepts that its findings in relation to those earlier incidents must necessarily be limited by the fact that complete evidence concerning them was not before it.
111. Nevertheless, the Tribunal finds that Mr Okeoma was aware of those earlier seizures.
112. The Tribunal further finds that, notwithstanding those earlier seizures, the Appellant did not implement effective procedures capable of preventing a recurrence of cigarette smuggling within containers shipped in its name. The Appellant’s restoration request
113. Following the seizure, the Appellant applied for restoration of the goods.
114. The Tribunal has carefully considered the Appellant's explanation of the restoration request in the context of all the other evidence before it.
115. The Tribunal rejects the proposition that the Appellant’s restoration request was made on behalf of an individual named "Mr Abiodun", who was the real owner of the seized cigarettes. It does not accept that the restoration request represented an attempt by the Appellant merely to assist an unknown third party.
116. The Tribunal finds that the restoration request was made by the Appellant in relation to cigarettes in which it had a direct interest. That conclusion is reinforced by the fact that the Appellant sought restoration of goods which, on its own account, should not have formed part of its order, and we reject as inherently implausible the Appellant’s stated reason for pursuing restoration at Mr Dare’s suggestion. Credibility
117. The Tribunal accepts the evidence of Ms Lucy Grant and Ms Siwanna Halliday in its entirety.
118. The Tribunal rejects the evidence of Mr Moses Okeoma and Mr Bosun Dare wherever it conflicts with the evidence accepted by the Tribunal or with the contemporaneous documentary material.
119. The Tribunal finds that both Mr Okeoma and Mr Dare deliberately sought to mislead the Tribunal concerning the circumstances in which the cigarettes were loaded into, and concealed within, the container. The Tribunal consequently treats their evidence with the utmost caution and accepts it only where independently corroborated by evidence which the Tribunal otherwise accepts. The Law Statutory Framework
120. Section 8(1) Finance Act 1994 provides, so far as material, that a person is liable to a penalty if: (a) he engages in conduct for the purpose of evading any duty of excise, and (b) his conduct involves dishonesty.
121. Section 25(1) Finance Act 2003 contains materially equivalent provisions in relation to customs duty and import VAT.
122. Accordingly, before liability to a penalty can arise, the Respondents must establish: (1) conduct by the Appellant; (2) that the conduct was for the purpose of evading duty; and (3) that the conduct involved dishonesty.
123. There is no dispute in the present appeal that the cigarettes found within the container were excise goods or that, had they been imported successfully without declaration, duty would have been evaded.
124. The principal dispute concerns whether the Appellant was knowingly involved in that attempted evasion. Amount of the Penalty
125. Where liability to a civil evasion penalty is established, the statutory penalty is equal to the duty evaded or sought to be evaded.
126. However, section 8(4) Finance Act 1994 and section 29 Finance Act 2003 confer power upon HMRC, and upon the Tribunal on appeal, to determine the amount of the penalty in such amount as is considered appropriate.
127. In civil evasion penalty matters, the Tribunal therefore possesses jurisdiction both to determine liability and, if liability is established, to consider whether the amount of the penalty should stand in the amount assessed by the Respondents, or varied to some other amount. The Tribunal’s powers in respect of the quantum of a penalty are broad: as decided by this Tribunal in ERF Ltd v HMRC [2010] UKFTT 238 (TC) ( per Judge Hellier), the Tribunal's jurisdiction is to determine the appropriate level of penalty, and not merely to review the Respondents’ decision on public-law grounds. Subject to the applicable statutory regimes, the Tribunal is therefore free to impose any penalty (not exceeding the amount of duty evaded or sought to be evaded) that it may determine. Burden and Standard of Proof
128. In this case, the Appellant’s dishonesty is properly pleaded by the Respondents, and the burden of proof rests upon the Respondents throughout. It is for the Respondents to establish, on the balance of probabilities, each of the statutory elements required for liability to a civil evasion penalty.
129. The Tribunal nevertheless bears in mind that an allegation of dishonesty is a serious one, and that whilst that fact does not of itself displace the ordinary civil standard of proof ( Aircall International Ltd v. HMRC [2016] UKFTT 406 (TC) at [72]), “cogent”, or “substantial”, evidence will ordinarily be required before such a finding is made: Re Dellow’s Will Trusts [1964] 1 WLR 451 at 455; Barlow Clowes International Ltd v. Henwood [2008] EWCA Civ 577 at [88]. Dishonesty
130. The leading authority on dishonesty is Ivey v Genting Casinos (UK) Ltd [2017] UKSC 67 , [2018] A.C. 391 (“ Ivey ”).
131. Applying Ivey , the Tribunal must first determine the individual's actual state of knowledge or belief as to the relevant facts.
132. Having determined that state of knowledge or belief, the Tribunal must then decide whether, viewed objectively, the conduct in question would be regarded as dishonest by the standards of ordinary decent people.
133. There is no requirement that the individual concerned must himself have appreciated that his conduct would be regarded as dishonest by ordinary decent people.
134. In the present appeal, the first question is therefore whether the Appellant knew, or believed, that cigarettes were concealed within the shipment.
135. If that question is answered in the affirmative, the second stage of the Ivey analysis requires the Tribunal to consider whether participation in the concealment and attempted importation of those cigarettes without declaration would be regarded as dishonest by ordinary decent people. Discussion Overview
136. The Tribunal reminds itself that this is not a strict liability regime, and the fact that cigarettes were discovered within the container does not, by itself, establish that the Appellant was knowingly concerned in their importation. Nor does the existence of a groupage arrangement, considered in isolation, establish either innocence or guilt.
137. The critical issue throughout the appeal is whether the Respondents have established that the Appellant knew that the concealed cigarettes were present within the shipment.
138. In determining that issue, the Tribunal has considered all of the evidence in the round. No single fact is determinative by itself. Rather, the Tribunal's conclusion arises from the cumulative effect of a number of findings which point consistently in the same direction. The “groupage” arrangement
139. The Tribunal accepts that a genuine groupage arrangement existed.
140. We accept that goods belonging to third parties, including noodles, were included within the container and were intended to be collected following importation into the United Kingdom. To that extent, the Appellant's account is correct. However, the Tribunal does not accept the further proposition that the existence of a groupage arrangement explains the presence of the concealed cigarettes.
141. The central difficulty with the Appellant's case is that the evidence does not support a finding that the cigarettes were concealed within boxes belonging to third parties. On the contrary, having regard in particular to the photographic evidence and the evidence of Ms Lucy Grant, the Tribunal finds that the cigarettes were concealed within boxes containing the Appellant's own Xpression hair extension products. Once that finding is made, the significance of the groupage arrangement diminishes substantially.
142. The existence of third-party goods elsewhere in the container provides no satisfactory explanation for cigarettes concealed within the Appellant's own goods. The number of boxes
143. The Tribunal considers the arithmetical discrepancies identified during the hearing to be of particular significance.
144. The Tribunal repeatedly sought from Mr Okeoma an explanation reconciling: (1) the number of boxes which the Appellant expected to receive; (2) the number of boxes seized by Border Force; and (3) the number of boxes ultimately received by the Appellant.
145. No coherent explanation was provided. We do not regard this as a minor numerical discrepancy. Rather, it strikes at the heart of the Appellant's explanation. Had the cigarettes genuinely been concealed in goods belonging to unknown third parties participating in the groupage arrangement, the discrepancy identified by the Tribunal should not have arisen. The fact that it did arise is strongly supportive of the Respondents' case that the concealed cigarettes were contained within the Appellant's own boxes.
146. The Tribunal therefore regards the box-number analysis as one of the most significant objective indicators that the Appellant's explanation is untrue. Mr Dare and the loading of the container
147. The Appellant's explanation depended to a substantial extent upon the evidence of Mr Dare. The Tribunal rejected that evidence. We are satisfied that Mr Dare was not attempting honestly to assist the Tribunal by recounting events as he remembered them. Rather, we concluded that material aspects of his account had been deliberately fabricated. We reach that conclusion notwithstanding the opportunity expressly afforded to him during the hearing to reconsider and correct his evidence.
148. In particular, the Tribunal rejects the evidence that an individual called "Mr Abiodun" arrived with boxes containing cigarettes and independently arranged for them to be loaded into the container without the knowledge of either Mr Dare or the Appellant.
149. We similarly reject the evidence that the subsequent restoration request was made on behalf of that individual.
150. The Tribunal finds that both Mr Dare and the Appellant sought to distance themselves from responsibility for the cigarettes by advancing an account which both of them knew to be deliberately false. Previous seizures
151. The Tribunal has approached the evidence concerning the previous seizures with caution. We do not treat those incidents as demonstrating a propensity to commit wrongdoing merely because they occurred. Nor do we regard them, by themselves, as proving knowledge in the present case. But we consider that they are nevertheless relevant facts. We consider that Mr Okeoma must have known of them, and his initial denials of their existence, and his contradictory statements which subsequently acknowledged them, but sought to place the blame for them elsewhere, lacked credibility.
152. At the very least, we consider the existence of three prior seizures of cigarettes in shipments to the Appellant to be relevant factors to the context of the seizure of cigarettes in this shipment to the Appellant. However, the full facts of the earlier seizures are not before the Tribunal, and we are not able to come to any concluded view as to the complicity or otherwise of the Appellant in relation to them. For that reason, we place very limited weight on them in our consideration of the facts in relation to this penalty.
153. What we do say is, that if Mr Okeoma’s explanation was accurate, and that his protestation that he would never become involved in smuggling (as he accepted that others in Nigeria do) was true, then we should have expected the Appellant to have made substantial improvements to its shipping procedures after the earlier seizures, to ensure that contraband goods could not again be introduced into containers shipped in the Appellant's name. But the evidence demonstrates that the Appellant made no such positive changes. Indeed, when it was put to Mr Okeoma that the regulations concerning air freight shipments at least require the details of the consignor and consignee to be identified for every package within a container, which (at least in theory) allows forensic tracing of every article, Mr Okeoma’s evidence was that the Appellant ceased using air freight in favour of container shipping after the three seizures, ostensibly for costs reasons, despite the lack of such precise itemisation for products shipped by sea.
154. In those circumstances, the Tribunal considers that the previous seizures are relevant to the Appellant's knowledge of risk, the degree of control exercised over the shipping arrangements, and the overall credibility of the Appellant's explanation. As noted above, however, we place low weight on them, and the outcome of this appeal would have been unchanged if they had not occurred (or had not been in evidence before us). Restoration
155. The Tribunal has considered the nature of the restoration request submitted by the Appellant shortly after the seizure. We accept that, viewed in isolation, the wording of that request is capable of more than one interpretation. However, the document must be considered in its factual context. The explanation ultimately advanced by the Appellant depended upon the existence of "Mr Abiodun" and upon a contention that the Appellant was acting solely on his behalf. For the reasons already given, the Tribunal rejects that explanation.
156. The Tribunal finds that the restoration request was made because the Appellant sought the return of cigarettes in which it had an interest. Recovery of the cigarettes: control of the shipping process
157. A particularly important aspect of the case concerns the practical question of how the cigarettes were intended to be recovered had they not been seized.
158. Smuggling operations necessarily require that the persons controlling them must have had a realistic mechanism by which the smuggled goods may be recovered following importation.
159. The Appellant's case failed to provide any credible explanation of how such recovery could have occurred if the cigarettes genuinely belonged to unknown third parties.
160. This problem becomes particularly acute once it is recognised that the cigarettes were concealed within the Appellant's own boxes. In those circumstances, recovery by an independent third party would require access to boxes associated with the Appellant's own products after importation and distribution. No workable explanation for such recovery was provided.
161. The Tribunal therefore concludes that the only realistic inference from the evidence is that the cigarettes were intended to be recovered by the Appellant or by persons acting on its behalf. That conclusion is consistent with the Tribunal's factual findings set out above, whilst it is inconsistent with the Appellant's explanation. Knowledge, dishonesty, and liability
162. We now turn to consider whether the Respondents have discharged the burden of proving that the Appellant engaged in conduct involving dishonesty for the purpose of evading duty.
163. In accordance with Ivey , we must first determine the Appellant's actual state of knowledge or belief as to the relevant facts.
164. The Appellant's case was that it did not know that cigarettes were concealed within the shipment. The Appellant contended that the cigarettes had been introduced into the container by unknown third parties participating in a groupage arrangement and that neither the Appellant nor Mr Dare had any prior knowledge of them. We have rejected that account.
165. For the reasons set out above, the Tribunal found that the cigarettes were concealed within boxes containing the Appellant's own Xpression hair extension products and not within goods belonging to other participants in the groupage arrangement.
166. We consider that the evidence shows the Appellant to have exercised a high degree of control over the materially relevant shipping arrangements, and that Mr Dare was acting on behalf of, and as agent for, the Appellant in Nigeria.
167. We have rejected the evidence of both Mr Okeoma and Mr Dare concerning the circumstances in which the cigarettes came to be loaded into the container. We are satisfied that material parts of their evidence were deliberately false and designed to distance the Appellant from responsibility for the cigarettes.
168. We have likewise rejected the account involving "Mr Abiodun", finding that this explanation was fabricated and was advanced in an attempt to explain away the presence of the cigarettes and the subsequent restoration request.
169. We have placed particular weight upon the objective evidence concerning the number of boxes shipped, seized and ultimately received. As explained above, the Appellant's account cannot be reconciled with that evidence. The discrepancy identified by the Tribunal demonstrates that the seized cigarette boxes formed part of the Appellant's own consignment.
170. We also place weight upon the practical question of how the cigarettes were intended to be recovered had they not been seized. Having found as a fact that the cigarettes were concealed within the Appellant's own boxes, we consider that there is no credible explanation by which unknown third parties could recover those cigarettes without the Appellant's knowledge or participation. Whilst we remain conscious that the burden of proof rests upon the Respondents throughout, the Tribunal would nevertheless have expected some coherent explanation, consistent with the Appellant's case, as to how such recovery was intended to occur. No satisfactory explanation was provided.
171. In our judgment, the only realistic explanation consistent with the facts found is that the cigarettes were being imported for the Appellant, and were intended to be recovered by the Appellant or persons acting on its behalf at the same time as the legitimate goods contained within the shipment.
172. We also take into account (to the extent noted above and no further) the three previous tobacco seizures associated with the Appellant. We do not rely upon those incidents as demonstrating a mere propensity to wrongdoing. Rather, we regard them as relevant to the Appellant's knowledge, its degree of control over shipping arrangements, and the credibility of its explanation in the present appeal.
173. Having considered all of the evidence in the round, we are satisfied, on the balance of probabilities, and on the “cogent” and “significant” evidence before us, that the Appellant knew that cigarettes were concealed within the shipment. The first stage of the Ivey test is therefore satisfied. We conclude that the Appellant's actual state of knowledge included awareness that the container contained concealed cigarettes which had not been declared to the authorities.
174. Turning to the second stage of the Ivey analysis, we have no hesitation in concluding that the conduct established by the evidence would be regarded as dishonest by the standards of ordinary decent people. The cigarettes were deliberately concealed within legitimate goods. They were imported without declaration. The obvious purpose of the concealment was to evade the payment of duty. We have found that the Appellant knowingly participated in that scheme. Ordinary decent people would unquestionably regard such conduct as dishonest.
175. We therefore conclude that the Appellant engaged in conduct involving dishonesty for the purpose of evading excise duty, customs duty and import VAT. As such, the statutory requirements of s.8 Finance Act 1994 and s.25 Finance Act 2003 are satisfied.
176. The Appellant is accordingly liable to a civil evasion penalty. Penalty mitigation
177. Having concluded that the Appellant is liable to a civil evasion penalty, we must consider whether there is any basis for reducing the penalty imposed by the Respondents.
178. The Respondents assessed the penalty at £181,201 after allowing mitigation equivalent to a 20% reduction from the maximum amount otherwise chargeable. The Respondents did not seek to disturb that reduction and did not contend that the penalty should be increased.
179. We have considered whether any further reduction would be appropriate, and we conclude that it would not be. The Appellant has not made any admission of responsibility. On the contrary, the Appellant's position throughout these proceedings has been to deny any knowledge of the cigarettes and to advance an explanation which the Tribunal has rejected in its entirety. We have found that both Mr Okeoma and Mr Dare deliberately sought to mislead the Tribunal concerning the circumstances in which the cigarettes came to be loaded into the container and the identities of those responsible for them. We also rejected the explanations provided in relation to the restoration request and the previous seizures. In those circumstances, we can identify no disclosure, cooperation or other mitigating factor beyond those already taken into account by the Respondents when fixing the penalty.
180. Indeed, we might add that we consider the 20% reduction already afforded by the Respondents to have been extraordinarily generous when viewed in light of the facts ultimately established before us. However, since no application has been made to increase the penalty, we have ultimately concluded that we are content not to vary the level of mitigation allowed by the Respondents.
181. The penalty therefore remains in the amount assessed. Decision
182. The Tribunal finds that the Appellant knowingly participated in the importation of 506,400 concealed cigarettes into the United Kingdom.
183. The Tribunal finds that the cigarettes were concealed within the Appellant's own Xpression hair extension boxes and were intended to be recovered by the Appellant, or by persons acting on its behalf, following importation.
184. The Tribunal rejects the Appellant's contention that the cigarettes belonged to unknown third parties participating in a groupage arrangement.
185. The Tribunal rejects the evidence of Mr Moses Okeoma and Mr Bosun Dare concerning the circumstances in which the cigarettes came to be loaded into the container.
186. Applying the test in Ivey , the Tribunal finds that the Appellant knew that the cigarettes were present within the shipment and that its participation in the concealment and attempted importation of those cigarettes without declaration was dishonest.
187. The Tribunal is satisfied that the Respondents have established, on the balance of probabilities, that the Appellant engaged in conduct involving dishonesty for the purpose of evading duty.
188. The statutory requirements for liability under s.8 Finance Act 1994 and s.25 Finance Act 2003 are therefore satisfied.
189. The Tribunal declines to make any further reduction to the penalty assessed by the Respondents.
190. Accordingly, the appeal is dismissed.
191. The Tribunal notes one further matter. Mr Okeoma's evidence was that the Appellant does not possess sufficient assets or funds to satisfy the penalty if the appeal is unsuccessful. If that evidence is correct, the practical consequence may be that the substantial penalty upheld by this Decision will prove wholly or largely irrecoverable. The Tribunal is concerned by that possibility. The evidence before the Tribunal did not address what consideration, if any, was given by the Respondents to the possibility of personal liability on the part of Mr Okeoma or to the use of any alternative statutory mechanisms directed at those responsible for the conduct in question. However, those matters do not fall within the issues which the Tribunal is required to determine in this appeal and so it is not for us to express any view on them. Right to apply for permission to appeal
192. This document contains full findings of fact and reasons for the decision. Any party dissatisfied with this decision has a right to apply for permission to appeal against it pursuant to Rule 39 of the Tribunal Procedure (First-tier Tribunal) (Tax Chamber) Rules 2009. The application must be received by this Tribunal not later than 56 days after this decision is sent to that party. The parties are referred to “Guidance to accompany a Decision from the First-tier Tribunal (Tax Chamber)” which accompanies and forms part of this decision notice. Release date: 09 th OCTOBER 2026