UK case law

Margal Estates Ltd v The Pensions Regulator

[2026] UKFTT GRC 1430 · First-tier Tribunal (General Regulatory Chamber) – Pensions · 2026

Get your free legal insight →Email to a colleague
Get your free legal insight on this case →

The verbatim text of this UK judgment. Sourced directly from The National Archives Find Case Law. Not an AI summary, not a paraphrase — every word below is the original ruling, under Crown copyright and the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Full judgment

1. By this reference Margal Estates Ltd (“the Employer”), challenges a fixed penalty notice of £400 (“FPN”) issued by the Regulator on 11 th March 2026.

2. The FPN was issued under s. 40 of the Pensions Act 2008 . It required the Employer to pay a penalty of £400 for failing to comply with the requirements of a Compliance Notice issued on 14 th January 2026. The Appeal

3. Under s. 44 of the 2008 Act , a person who has been issued with a FPN may make a reference to the Tribunal provided an application for review has first been made to the Regulator. The role of the Tribunal is to make its own decision on the appropriate action for the Regulator to take, taking into account the evidence before it. The Tribunal may confirm, vary or revoke a FPN and when it reaches a decision must remit the matter to the Regulator with such directions (if any) required to give effect to its decision.

4. The Employer’s Notice of Appeal dated 13 th April 2026 the Appellant seeks a removal of the FPN due to the fact that they say they did not receive any earlier indication that issues needed attention. They assert that they did not receive the CN or any earlier correspondence. Upon receiving the relevant notification they suggest that they acted promptly to correct the position and that they are now fully compliant.

5. The Regulator’s Response indicates that a Review took place on 31 st March 2026 and a decision was made to maintain the FPN. The Regulator sets out the correspondence that was sent to the Appellant about automatic enrolment, the reminder letters sent and the warning letter before the CN was issued. Nothing was received from the Appellant and as a result the FPN was issued. Shortly thereafter, with the penalty being imposed, the Appellant contacted the Regulator challenging the FPN saying that no earlier correspondence was received.

6. The Regulator relies upon the standard presumptions of service for all of the documentation supplied to the Appellant, including the CN. The acceptance of receipt of the FPN, sent to the same address as the other correspondence, is relied upon by the Regulator. Determination

7. The case was listed for a paper hearing.

8. All parties agreed to a paper determination, and having considered the bundle in full the Tribunal agreed that a fair and proper decision could be reached without oral evidence. As a result, in accordance with the Tribunal Rules, the case was considered on the documentary materials provided.

9. The Tribunal considered a bundle of 159 pages. Discussion and Conclusion

10. The Tribunal looked at and considered the papers and evidence before it with care.

11. Here there is a failure to comply when required. The Appellant argues that it never received the relevant indications that it must file a declaration by a CN. The Regulator has provided details of the documents supplied to the Appellant, which were sent to the company registered address. The Appellant accepts receiving the FPN as it was acted upon. The Regulator relies upon the presumption of service that indicates in basic terms that if post is properly addressed and sent, then it is deemed to have arrived unless and until cogent evidence is provided to doubt the same.

12. In accordance with s7 Interpretation Act 1978 presumptions, by sending letters and emails to the Companies Registered address the Regulator had met its obligations and more. The further presumptions within the Employers Duties (Registration and Compliance) Regulations 2010 (SI 2010/5), particularly Regulation 15, further support the Regulator’s position.

13. A simple denial of receipt is not enough to displace the presumption. Here there is only a denial of receipt nothing else to suggest the presumption is inappropriate. Iti s somewhat strange that only one of 5 letters (at least) arrived. It is more than noteworthy that the document that levelled a penalty was received and acted upon. The receipt of the FPN supports the presumption, nothing detracts and therefore I find that the CN was served and received. The failure to act upon it triggered the FPN quite properly.

14. As recent cases have made clear the Appellant must be able to show that there were difficulties with the postal system to raise an argument against the presumption. Here there is simply an email saying we were surprised to receive a FPN nothing more. The Appellant seems at stages to be blaming the Regulator for not chasing them properly to comply. The burden is on the Appellant to comply, not the Regulator. It was, and remains, the employers obligation to operate a proper scheme and to notify the Regulator of all appropriate matters as required. Here they failed. It was their responsibility.

15. The Appellant did not file a declaration of compliance when required, the FPN that followed was perfectly proper and I can see no basis for finding to the contrary. The appeal against the penalty itself is without merit.

16. In all the circumstances the Tribunal determines the appeal must be dismissed and it is remitted to the Regulator, upholding the Fixed Penalty Notice.

17. No further directions are required.