UK case law
Oluwatomilayo Ayomikun Akinbolagbe v Ofsted
[2026] UKFTT HESC 1444 · Care Standards · 2026
The verbatim text of this UK judgment. Sourced directly from The National Archives Find Case Law. Not an AI summary, not a paraphrase — every word below is the original ruling, under Crown copyright and the Open Government Licence v3.0.
Full judgment
The AppeaL
1. Miss Oluwatomilayo Ayomikun Akinbolagbe (“ the Appellant ”) has brought an appeal against Ofsted’s (“ Ofsted ”) decision dated 12 November 2025 to refuse her application for registration on the Early Years Register and both the Compulsory (“ CCR ”) and Voluntary (“ VCR ”) parts of the Childcare Register as a childminder.
2. The appeal was listed for its final hearing over two days on 13 and 14 October 2026. For the reasons set out below, the hearing was extended to a third day, 15 October 2026. Attendance
3. The Appellant represented herself. She had no witnesses but was supported in the hearing on day one by her sister, Ms Yetunde Adebiyi.
4. The Respondent was represented by Mr Joe O’Leary, Counsel. The Respondent’s witness was: a. Mrs Joanne Wildman, Early Years Senior Officer. Preliminary matters Adjustments
5. Before the hearing, the Appellant requested a number of adjustments to the hearing process on the basis that she was a litigant in person and processed information best when it was provided clearly and one step at a time.
6. At the commencement of the hearing on 13 October 2026, the Tribunal considered the Appellant’s requests for adjustments. In doing so, the Tribunal had regard to the overriding objective in rule 2 of the Tribunal Procedure (First-tier Tribunal) (Health, Education and Social Care Chamber) Rules 2008 (“ HESC Rules ”), including the need to deal with the case fairly and justly and, so far as practicable, to ensure that the parties were able to participate fully in the proceedings. The Tribunal considered each of the requested adjustments individually and agreed that: a. regular timetabled breaks would be taken, and the Appellant could request an additional break whenever she required one and the Tribunal would accommodate that if possible; b. questions would be put to the Appellant one at a time and in clear and plain language; c. if the Appellant did not understand a question, it would be rephrased or clarified rather than simply repeated; and d. if the Appellant required time to process any information including any question or answer she was permitted to take that time.
7. The Tribunal explained the anticipated running order for the day but made clear that this was subject to any changes required by the progress of the hearing or further directions of the Tribunal.
8. Throughout the hearing, the Tribunal kept those adjustments under review. The Tribunal checked regularly with the Appellant that they remained appropriate and that the pace of questioning was suitable for her. She was reminded that she should take the time she needed to process each question and formulate her answer, and that she could request a break or indicate if she required a question to be rephrased or clarified. The hearing proceeded on that basis. The Appellant’s Application to Adjourn
9. The hearing of this appeal commenced on 13 October 2026. The Appellant commenced giving oral evidence but did not complete her oral evidence before the end of the day.
10. On the morning of 14 October 2026, the Tribunal received an email from the Appellant’s sister, Ms Adebiyi, explaining that the Appellant had been unable to sleep during the night, had experienced a panic attack, had sought medical attention and would not be attending the hearing that day. The Tribunal treated that e-mail as an application to adjourn the hearing.
11. The Tribunal did not determine the application at that stage. Instead, having regard to the overriding objective in HESC Rule 2 and its case-management powers under HESC Rule 5, the Tribunal afforded the Appellant an opportunity to provide evidence sufficient to enable it properly to assess whether she was medically unable to participate in the hearing.
12. Following the guidance given by the High Court in Levy v Ellis-Carr [2012] EWHC 63 (CH), the Tribunal directed the Appellant, to confirm either: a. that she was fit and well enough to proceed; or b. to provide medical evidence which: i. stated the exact medical condition which rendered her unfit; ii. explained the specific features of that condition which prevented her from participating in the hearing, including why she was unable to answer questions or make submissions; and iii. provided a reasoned prognosis as to when she was expected to be fit to return.
13. The hearing was extended to a third day, and the parties were stood down until 10:00 am on 15 October 2026.
14. At 15:38 on 14 October 2026, the Appellant sent to the Tribunal a Statement of Fitness for Work (“ the Fit Note ”) form her General Practitioner (“ GP ”). Accompanying that Fit Note were notes which we understand were prepared by her GP. Those notes stated: “I am unable to say whether she is “fit” to attend court or not…” The Request to Withdraw
15. As directed in the Tribunal’s order of 14 October 2026, the Tribunal proposed to decide the Appellant’s application to adjourn and any consequential directions at the start of the hearing on 15 October 2026.
16. But at 16:40 on 14 October 2026, the Appellant sent to the Tribunal an application to withdraw her appeal (“ the Notice of Withdrawal ”). Her reasons were: a. She has represented herself throughout the proceedings and now considers that this was an error of judgement. b. During the hearing on 13 October 2026, she came to understand that the purpose and scope of the appeal differed from her previous understanding, causing her to reconsider whether she could continue with the proceedings. c. The proceedings have had a significant adverse effect on her mental and physical health, and she is concerned about the impact of continuing with the hearing. d. Having considered those matters, she has made a considered decision that she no longer wishes to pursue the appeal. e. She understood that the consequence of her withdrawal would leave Ofsted’s decision refusing her application for registration undisturbed.
17. The Appellant joined the hearing by video on 15 October 2026. The Tribunal confirmed with her that she did intend to withdraw and that this meant that the proceedings would come to an end and that Ofsted’s decision dated 12 November 2025 would remain undisturbed.
18. The Tribunal enquired whether the Appellant would feel different if she was permitted to continue with the hearing by video and if further adjustments were considered. The Appellant was grateful to the Tribunal for the adjustments it had already made but she confirmed she did not wish to continue.
19. These are proceedings that concern the suitability of the Appellant to work with children and therefore under HESC Rule 17(2)(a) the Tribunal’s consent to the application is not required.
20. Mr O’Leary queries in his submissions whether the Tribunal’s consent was required. In the Tribunal’s judgment it is not for the reasons set out above.
21. But even if we are wrong on that, the Tribunal provides its consent. We are satisfied that the Appellant’s decision to withdraw the appeal is a considered one. Her application explains the matters which have led her to that decision and makes clear that she understands the consequence of withdrawal, namely that Ofsted’s decision refusing her application for registration will remain undisturbed. There is nothing before us to suggest that she does not understand the nature or effect of the application she has made.
22. The Tribunal has also taken account of the stage which the proceedings have reached and the fact that the final hearing has commenced. Those matters do not, in the Tribunal’s judgment, provide a sufficient reason to refuse consent. The Appellant no longer wishes to pursue the appeal and there is no proper basis upon which she should be required to do so.
23. To the extent that the Tribunal’s consent is required, we consent to the withdrawal of the appeal.
24. In accordance with rule 17, the proceedings are brought to an end and there is no longer any need for the Tribunal to determine the Appellant’s application to adjourn or to make the consequential directions contemplated in its order of 14 October 2026. ORdER It is ordered that:
1. By order made pursuant to Rule 17 of the Tribunal Procedure (First–tier Tribunal) Health, Education and Social Care Chamber) Rules 2008 the appeal is withdrawn.
2. The Appellant may apply to the Tribunal under Rule 17(4) for the case to be reinstated. Any application must be made in writing and be received by the Tribunal within 28 days after the date on which the Tribunal received the initial written notice of withdrawal.
3. This is the final order in the appeal and the proceedings are concluded. Judge O’Neill First-tier Tribunals (Care Standards & Primary Health Lists) 21 October 2026