UK case law
P (Children) (Fact-Finding – Private Law), Re
[2026] EWFC B 269 · Family Court (B - district and circuit judges) · 2026
The verbatim text of this UK judgment. Sourced directly from The National Archives Find Case Law. Not an AI summary, not a paraphrase — every word below is the original ruling, under Crown copyright and the Open Government Licence v3.0.
Full judgment
DJ BLACKMORE:
1. I am concerned with five children, J, a girl, aged 15, K, a boy, aged 13, L, a girl aged 11, M, a girl aged 8 and N, a girl aged 5.
2. The children’s parents are the parties to these proceedings. The applicant is the father, who is a litigant in person. He has been supported at both case management stage and this fact-finding hearing by a McKenzie Friend.
3. Due to the allegations of domestic abuse, directions were made earlier in the proceedings for the appointment of a QLR to conduct cross-examination of the respondent and her witnesses on the father’s behalf. The QLR appointed was initially Mr Siddiqui but unfortunately, he was taken ill and Ms Kaur took over the role. The Court is very grateful to her for her careful but thorough cross-examination on the father’s behalf. Ms Kaur left the case at the conclusion of the evidence.
4. The respondent to the proceedings is the children’s mother, represented by Ms Jones of counsel, who is instructed by Ms Walton of Howells Solicitors. The Mother has also been supported throughout by an IDAS worker. Introduction
5. These proceedings have had a very difficult history and have, for various reasons, been disjointed in getting to a resolution. I recognise that this has had a significant impact on both of the parties, which in turn will have had an impact on the children when decisions as to their future have been delayed.
6. The father’s application for a child arrangements order (spend time with), a prohibited steps order, and a specific issue order was made on 17 January 2025, over a year ago now. With the mother’s cross application for a child arrangements order, (lives with) and a prohibited steps order being made on 25 March 2025.
7. The case was initially due to be heard with a time estimate of four days beginning on 24 November 2025, but on the first day, just after the mother had completed her evidence-in-chief, the QLR, Mr Siddiqui was taken unwell, requiring the attendance of paramedics and ultimately it became necessary to adjourn the case as I was concerned that a fair hearing would not have been possible as the father had prepared a significant number of questions he wished to ask of the mother and her witnesses and it was simply not possible for me as the judge to determine which questions were relevant in the time available.
8. The Court was able to list the matter relatively quickly, however, and the fact-finding hearing to determine both the mother’s schedule of allegations against the father and the fathers against the mother began on 5 January 2026.
9. At the commencement of the third day, with the mother left to give evidence on two remaining topics, I suffered an accident, meaning I was unable to continue with the case for a two-week period whilst I recovered.
10. The hearing recommenced on 27 January 2026 and concluded with the parties’ making submissions on 5 February 2026. At that stage, the parties were informed that judgment would be reserved until today.
11. Turning to the two schedules that I am asked to determine, the first is a set of findings the mother invites me to make against the father, dated 22 October 2025, comprising of various allegations under six separate headings: (i) Controlling and coercive behaviour (ii) Sexual abuse, including rape (iii) Verbal and emotional abuse (iv) Physical abuse (v) Psychological abuse (vi) Physical and emotional harm of the children and sexual harm of J and L.
12. The father in response vehemently denies the allegations against him and invites me to make findings as set out in his schedule of allegations dated 25 March 2025, that in fact it was the mother who was controlling and coercive of him, including isolating him from his family; that she was emotionally and physically abusive of him and of their son K, and that in relation to the allegations made by J, M & L that these allegations are deliberately fabricated, the mother having coached the children to make them with a view to alienating the girls from him and therefore from them having a relationship with him.
13. As a result of these allegations, special measures were implemented to include the use of screens in the courtroom, together with separate entrances and waiting areas for the parents, these measures being put in place to ensure the Court heard the mother’s best evidence.
14. The mother is additionally vulnerable due to having a diagnosis of epilepsy, in respect of which she suffers from seizures. Unfortunately, and likely because of the unavoidable breaks in the case, resulting in excessive stress, on 27 January, at the resumed hearing, the mother suffered a seizure in the witness box at the recommencement of cross-examination. After that, and to secure her continued participation in the hearing, arrangements were made for her to move to the child witness suite in the court building, from which she was able to give the remainder of her evidence via a CVP link and thereafter to continue to hear the evidence and the submissions through a telephone link. Background
15. The parties met in 2009 and married shortly thereafter. The girls have lived with the mother since the parties separated. K has lived with his father since then. The siblings, therefore, have been living separately for two years now.
16. The father resides in one area of South Yorkshire and the mother in another.
17. Prior to these proceedings, Children’s Services in the area where the father lives, completed a risk assessment of him. The child and family assessment is dated 23 December 2024. In addition, again prior to proceedings, Children Services in the area where the mother lives completed an assessment of her, these assessments raised concerns that the father was not engaging with the assessment process and presented as a high risk.
18. Children’s Services’ assessment of the father concluded that whilst he could care for K, this was on the basis that his current partner supervised his care of K at all times.
19. Cafcass in their safeguarding letter in these proceedings, queried the reality of this situation continuing, noting that full supervision would be an: ‘impossible task, especially when there is another small child in the home’.
20. I note at this stage that the father has raised significant criticism throughout this hearing about the accuracy of the social work assessments undertaken so far, in particular, the work of the social worker with the local authority who undertook the assessment of the mother, and her conclusions in terms of the risks posed.
21. I note here too that the father has impending prosecutions for rape, sexual assault, and an assault (ABH), coercive control and non-fatal strangulation, arising from the allegations raised against him by the mother. He has bail conditions not to have unsupervised contact with the children without the prior approval of social care, not to enter or go to the mother’s address, and not to contact or interfere directly or indirectly with any prosecution witnesses including the mother.
22. There is also a pending application by South Yorkshire Police seeking disclosure of documents from these proceedings, including this judgment and any findings that are made.
23. The mother has undergone an Achieving Best Evidence interview in relation to her allegations, and the father was interviewed under caution. During his interview, no doubt on advice from his legal representative, and about which I make no criticism, he replied with no comment to most questions asked of him.
24. L, M, and J have also raised allegations against their father and were the subject themselves of ABE interviews. The father was interviewed in relation to the children’s allegations, in which he provides a full account in response to each of the allegations raised.
25. At this fact-finding hearing, I have heard evidence from the mother and the father, who have each been extensively and appropriately cross-examined. From the safeguarding liaison officer at the children’s school and to whom L and M spoke on two occasions in respect of allegations those children made against the father. I have also heard from the maternal aunt, as to what she has observed of the parents’ relationship, and from, the maternal grandmother, in particular in respect of an incident when she was collecting M and L from school, together with N and the children were approached by the father. The Law
26. Before turning to the evidence in detail, I turn first to consideration of the law in respect of this finding-of-fact hearing.
27. I remind myself that the burden of proving any allegation falls upon the person making it, in this case the mother in respect of the allegations against the father, and the father in respect of the allegations he makes against the mother.
28. The standard of proof is, of course, not the criminal standard of beyond reasonable doubt, it is the civil standard, namely the simple balance of probabilities.
29. The law operates a binary approach to allegations, where the only values are zero and one. If an allegation is proved, the Court will proceed on that basis. However, where an allegation is not proved, the Court will proceed on the basis that it did not happen.
30. I have also considered and reminded myself of the decision in Re A (A finding of fact hearing: Speculation) [2011] 1 FCR 141, that is authority for the proposition that findings of fact must be based on evidence, including inferences that can be properly drawn from the evidence, but not on mere suspicion, surmise, or speculation. There is no obligation on the parties to prove the truth of an alternative case put forward by way of a defence, and the failure by a party to establish the alternative case on the balance of probabilities does not, of itself, prove the other party’s case.
31. No case of alleged domestic abuse, including allegations of coercive control, where there is an absence of any probative medical or other direct physical evidence to support a finding can be regarded as being straightforward.
32. The Court must not evaluate and assess the available evidence in separate compartments, rather regard must be had to the relevance of each piece of evidence, supported by other evidence, and to exercise an overview of the totality of the evidence in order to come to a conclusion whether the case put forward has been made out on the balance of probabilities.
33. There is no room for a finding by the Court that something might have happened, the Court can only decide that it either did, or it did not.
34. The failure to find a fact proved on the balance of probabilities does not equate without more to a finding that the alleged allegation is false.
35. I remind myself of the definition of domestic abuse set out at section 1(2) and 1(3) of the Domestic Abuse Act 2021 , namely: “(2) Behaviour of a person (‘A’) towards another person (‘B’) is ‘domestic abuse’ if— (a) A and B are each aged 16 or over and are personally connected to each other, and (b) the behaviour is abusive. (3) Behaviour is ‘abusive’ if it consists of any of the following— (a) physical or sexual abuse; (b) violent or threatening behaviour; (c) controlling or coercive behaviour; (d) economic abuse; (e) psychological, emotional, or other abuse; and it does not matter whether the behaviour consists of a single incident or a course of conduct”.
36. As well as reminding myself of Practice Direction 12J, and in particular the general principle set out within it, that “domestic abuse is harmful to children and/or puts children at risk of harm, including where they are victims of domestic abuse, for example by witnessing one of their parents being violent or abusive to the other parent, or living in a home in which domestic abuse is perpetrated, (even if the child is too young to be conscious of the behaviour). Children may suffer direct physical, psychological and/or emotional harm in living with and being victims of domestic abuse and may also suffer harm indirectly where the domestic abuse impairs the parenting capacity of either or both of their parents”.
37. The Court of Appeal in the important case of H-N & Ors (Children) (Domestic Abuse: Finding of Fact Hearings) [2021] EWCA Civ 448 , (30 March 2021), makes it clear that Practice Direction 12J is written and functions properly and does not need rewording, but stresses the importance of it being followed and properly applied. I remind myself of paragraph 29 when determining the allegations in this case, namely: “the Court should, wherever practical, make findings of fact as to the nature and degree of any domestic abuse which is established and its effect on the child, the child’s parents, and any other relevant person.”
38. In H-N & Ors , the Court of Appeal emphasised the important task the Court has in taking allegations of domestic abuse seriously and in taking seriously the need to get to the truth of the allegations and properly assess the impact they have on the issues of where children live and whom they spend time with. The task of reviewing the approach to domestic abuse is a complicated one, in respect of what is the understanding of society. The case accepted that it would be both impossible and inappropriate for the Court of Appeal, following a short hearing of four separate appeals to lay down comprehensive guidance, but this judgment aimed at resolving or even identifying the many difficulties that are said to exist and which are the very subject of these other more extensive endeavours. The focus, therefore, had to be limited to offering guidance on those matters which are most directly relevant to the court process.
39. In respect of cases involving allegations that a parent has engaged in alienating behaviours, which has resulted in a child’s unexplained reluctance, resistance, or refusal to spend time with the other parent, I remind myself of the Family Justice Council’s guidance of December 2024, in particular: Section 3: Guidance Note on Case Management, Alienating behaviours - three necessary elements, which states: “In Re C (‘Parental Alienation; Instruction of Expert) [2023] EWHC 345 (Fam), para 103, Sir Andrew McFarlane adopted the definition proffered by the Association of Clinical Psychologists that ‘parental alienation’ is not a syndrome capable of being diagnosed, but a process of manipulation of children perpetrated by one parent against the other through what are termed as alienating behaviours. He observed that what is important is the particular behaviour that is found to have taken place within the individual family before the court, and the impact that that behaviour may have had on the relationship of a child with either or both of his/her parents. A court would therefore need to be satisfied that three elements are established before it could conclude that Alienating Behaviours had occurred: 1) the child is reluctant, resisting or refusing to engage in, a relationship with a parent or carer; and 2) the reluctance, resistance or refusal is not consequent on the actions of that parent towards the child or the other parent, which may therefore be an appropriate justified rejection by the child, or is not caused by any other factor such as the child’s alignment, affinity, or attachment; and 3) the other parent has engaged in behaviours that have directly or indirectly impacted on the child, leading to the child’s reluctance, resistance, or refusal to engage in a relationship with that parent. Alienating Behaviours range in intensity and their impact on children. They can be observed in both families where parents remain together and in those where parents separate. Either or both parent(s) could engage in psychological manipulation which may or may not manifest in reluctance, resistance, or refusal on the part of a child”.
40. Courts are well used to conducting finding-of-fact hearings in which, arriving at findings substantially relies upon the judge piecing together strands of evidence, both expert (in some cases) and lay direct and circumstantial. By way of example, only rarely will there be a witness to a baby being shaken, that does not however mean that at a conclusion of a trial, having considered all the evidence, a judge is prevented from making findings on the balance of probabilities that the cause of death was shaking and to identify the unseen perpetrator. In reaching such a conclusion, the judge will rightly have looked at all the evidence, contemporary, written, and oral. Inevitably in such cases the oral evidence of the key protagonists, in this case the mother and the father, is highly significant. Case law has developed in a way designed to ensure that whilst there is recognition of the fact that the oral evidence of lay parties is often critical, is also has its limitations. There are dangers in an over-reliance by the judge of either demeanour or upon the fact that a witness has told demonstrable lies.
41. I have in mind the guidance given by Baker J, as he then was, in Gloucestershire County Council v RH & Ors [2012] EWHC 1370 (Fam) and in particular paragraph 42, his point seven: “Seventh, the evidence of the parents and any other carers is of the utmost importance. It is essential that the court forms a clear assessment of their credibility and reliability. They must have the fullest opportunity to take part in the hearing, and the court is likely to place considerable weight on the evidence and the impression it forms of them”.
42. Baker J’s reasoning in the Gloucestershire case was approved by the President in Re M (Fact-Finding Hearing: Injuries to Skull) [2013] 2 FLR 322 .
43. The Court must be mindful of the fallibility of memory and the pressures of giving evidence and the relative significance of oral and contemporaneous evidence will vary from case to case. What is important is that the court assesses all the evidence in a manner suited to the case before it and does not inappropriately elevate one kind of evidence over another.
44. I have had in mind throughout that the witness may lie for many reasons and the fact a witness has lied about some matters does not mean he or she has lied about everything. I remind myself of R v Lucas [1981] QB 720 . The relevant principles as they apply in children cases were outlined by Ryder J, as he then was in Re M (Children) [2013] EWCA Civ 388 , namely: (a) A lie told by a defendant does not of itself necessarily indicate guilt because the defendant may have some other reason for lying; i.e. they may lie for innocent reasons. (b) A witness may lie because they lack credibility, or because they have an innocent motive for lying. (c) If they lie about the key fact in issue, that is one thing; if they lie about collateral facts, that may be quite another
45. Macur LJ in the case of Re A, B and C (Children) [2021] EWCA Civ 451 reminds the Court that the principles laid down in Lucas remain the same, but they must be tailored to the facts and circumstances of the witnesses before the court. The Evidence
46. I have read and considered in full the extensive trial bundle which is over 850 pages long in this case. In addition to the oral evidence I have heard I have also had the benefit of transcripts of the various interviews undertaken by the police in respect of the criminal investigation, namely: (i) Audio recorded interviews of the father. (ii) Video recorded interview of the mother. (iii) Video recorded interviews of M, L, and J.
47. I have viewed the video recordings which were conducted using the Achieving Best Evidence guidance and listened to the audio recordings of the father’s interviews.
48. At case management stage of these proceedings, the question of whether the father wished to make an application for the children to give evidence at this fact-finding hearing was considered. The father made it clear that he did not seek permission for any of the children to give evidence, which could then have been challenged as his case is that the children have only made the allegations they have because they have been coached and influenced to do so by the mother.
49. I have, therefore, assessed the evidence the children gave in their interviews in that context and taking into account their respective ages. I consider that each of them, whilst understandably nervous at being in such an unfamiliar and no doubt intimidating environment, gave accounts that are in line with their respective stages of development and which were appropriately inconsistent at times, such as if the allegations they make had been told to them by the mother or they have been coached to make them by her, there would not have been such inconsistencies, there would most likely have been a script that they had to follow. I bear in mind the girls’ evidence to the police when I come to assess the other evidence I have heard in this case and in formulating my findings. The Evidence of the Mother
50. As I have already set out, I heard from the mother in a very disjointed way, through no fault of hers, but in circumstances that have been very trying for her. It took place over a period of two and half days, during which time she was extensively and appropriately cross-examined by Ms Kaur on the father’s behalf and the father’s case was put to her in clear terms.
51. On the morning of the final day of her evidence, with what could be described as the two most difficult topics, namely the sexual abuse and rape of her by the father, and the allegations that the children make against their father, as she entered the witness box, she suffered a seizure.
52. I note the opinion of her consultant neurologist, in respect of the likely cause of the mother’s seizures outside her epilepsy which is well controlled with medication. He says: “Dissociative seizures commonly occur in the context of trauma and may occur in abusive relationships. The fact that the seizures described to me stopped suddenly when the Mother disclosed her husband’s abuse and left him, would be very much in keeping with this diagnosis”.
53. It is striking, therefore, that when faced with the prospect of going over and potentially reliving traumatic events in the upcoming minutes and hours resulted in the mother’s seizure on 27 January.
54. Overall, therefore in the face of such disruption to her evidence, I found the mother to be an impressive witness who was trying her best throughout to assist the Court whilst also trying to contain her emotion and express herself.
55. The father’s case which was being put to her was aimed at showing her to be an aggressive, unstable person, who is in fact the perpetrator of abusive behaviours towards the father and on occasions to the children. The father alleges that the mother had ‘psychopathic’ episodes in which she flew into rages and behaved erratically and without any sense. Having heard the mother and seen her at times emotional responses to the cross-examination questions and considering the context in which any erratic or emotionally charged behaviours whilst in relationship with the father were displayed, I am satisfied that those outbursts were most likely because the mother was trying to stand up for herself, she having reached the end of her tether and she was reacting to what the father had put her through. Her evidence, overall, was credible and consistent.
56. The assertion of the father that the mother has simply fabricated all the allegations and that if they were true, why did she not go to the police or tell her family what was happening is a common one in cases regarding allegations of domestic abuse. I remind myself that it is now recognised that survivors of such abuse commonly take a long time to be able to be strong enough to leave a relationship or indeed to recognise that what they are enduring is abusive and seek support and help.
57. The mother’s evidence in respect of the first time she was raped by the father in some shrubland whilst walking home from her parents’ house and whilst pregnant with J was particularly compelling in the way that it was delivered and the detail with which it was described. The mother’s acquiescence thereafter to attacks by the father upon her sometimes involving her being threatened with a kitchen knife, such as even now she does not like to see knives out in the open in the kitchen, supports further the desperate situation she found herself in. She was completely stuck, and I accept frozen, struggling, certainly since N was born with managing frightening and debilitating seizures as well as not knowing how to leave the relationship given that the father was in control of all of the families’ finances.
58. I am therefore more than satisfied that what the mother has told me is the truth and that her actions throughout these proceedings and since the parties’ separation are consistent with someone who has suffered significant domestic abuse over a long period of time. Safeguarding Liaison Officer
59. The Safeguarding Liaison Officer at the children’s school, knows L and M well. She has never met J who did not attend the school, and she only has limited experience of K, who only attended the school for a short period.
60. She gave evidence about the conversations she had with M and L, which she recorded on CPOMs.
61. In March, she recorded that L had completed a ‘3 islands sheet’ and on the ‘house of worries’ section, L had written: “I don’t want to see dad because he hits us when we are not with mum”.
62. On 2 May, the mother reported to the school that M and L had told her the evening before that their father had touched them inappropriately. The Safeguarding Liaison Officer spoke with the girls and simply said to them the mother had told her that they had told the mother that they were worried about something. In response to this, M described: “Dad’s hands going into her trousers under her underwear and slapping her buttock, this was the only private area that he touched. M also told me that dad once ripped her unicorn dress by pulling her into the car”.
63. L wrote her comments to the Safeguarding Liaison Officer down, namely: “he used to put his hand over my bottom when he laid next to me”. The Safeguarding Liaison Officer is, I consider, an experienced safeguarding officer who is well aware of her duties in recording allegations of this nature and I am satisfied that the evidence she has given to me is exactly what the children told her and she has captured their voices as they were expressed to her at that time.
64. With that in mind I attach significant weight to The Safeguarding Liaison Officer’s evidence when assessing, as I have already explained, the quality of the evidence I have from the girls in their ABE interviews. Maternal Aunt
65. Is one of the mother’s sisters and is a teacher. Whilst of course she gave evidence in support of her sister, I do not consider that she did so blindly and with a view to giving false and untruthful evidence. On the contrary I was particularly struck by the evidence that she gave to me about the way in which the father would speak to the mother when other family members were around, not only in terms of the derogatory words he would use but also the manner in which he would address her, using a low deep voice with an ominous warning-like quality.
66. The evidence she gave in respect of hearing what she thought to be a loud slap in the next-door room and thereafter confronting the couple, noticing a red mark on the mother’s face and asking her, “has he hit you”, with the mother thereafter minimising matters, looking scared and saying everything was fine was, I find, compelling.
67. It was also particularly noteworthy, in my judgment, that the father required a question put on his behalf by Ms Kaur, to suggest that the maternal aunt was lying about a slap because a red mark would not show up on dark skin. This was an incredible thing to suggest and is evidence, I consider, of the father’s mindset and supportive of the mother’s and the maternal aunt’s evidence of the father’s racist views. I accept the maternal aunt’evidence in its entirety. Maternal Grandmother
68. The children’s grandmother was understandably nervous when entering the witness box and it was clear that English is not her first language. Her evidence was largely in respect of one matter, an incident, whereby the father, in a car, was driving close to M and L’s school at the end of the school day and when the maternal grandmother was charged with collecting them. She had N with her at the time and M and L were all walking along the pavement behind them and they heard the father’s voice shouting towards the girls.
69. The maternal grandmother’s evidence to me was clear and compelling, that the children immediately showed signs of fear and ran into their grandmother’s open arms, with M saying: “look, my heart is beating, touch my heart”, they were frightened and upset that their father, who had had no contact with them for one year by this time, had tried to approach them.
70. I accept the maternal grandmother’s evidence in respect of this incident and the impact, therefore, that it had, particularly on M and L. Father
71. Turning then to the final witness I heard from, which is of course the father. He gave evidence over several hours amounting in time to approximately a full court day. He was robustly yet appropriately challenged by Ms Jones on behalf the mother. From the moment he went into the witness box, I was immediately struck by the tightly controlled way in which he gave his evidence, speaking in a very even tone and not getting emotional, in marked contrast to the mother.
72. He was very keen for me to know that he is a qualified teacher, well respected, as he runs together with his brothers, an organisation that supports young people with autism and other learning difficulties, and he sought to portray himself as a thoroughly western, modern father and husband, who took loving responsibility for his family, being the one, due to the mother’s ill health both her epilepsy and her mental ill-health, who was responsible for the full running of the household, cooking and cleaning as well as being the breadwinner and out of the house for hours of the day, working outside the home.
73. I am afraid that I have not been at all impressed by the father’s evidence, or the case that he has pursued relentlessly against the mother, being vociferous in alleging repeatedly that it is the mother who was a violent and abusive and single-minded woman intent on destroying not only his reputation but also his relationship with his children.
74. I have been referred regularly during the hearing to the Domestic Abuse Perpetrator Risk Assessment undertaken by the social worker with the local authority in the area where the mother lives, which resulted in a “high-risk of the perpetrator’s behaviour continuing” conclusion.
75. The father told me in evidence that he has made a formal complaint about the social worker and that the assessment has factual inaccuracies within it. He did not, however, seek for the social worker to be called to give evidence, which would have enabled him to challenge her in cross-examination, as he did with the Safeguarding Liaison Officer. I note in particular what the father said when discussing the issue of ‘control’ as part of the assessment, and I quote: “Father said he did expect mother to be covered up, He said this is their way of life and this is a must ”, and I emphasise that word, “Father said he would have left mother if she did not cover up as this would be a conflict of interest in their religion. Father said mother would also not be allowed” again my emphasis, “to be perfumed outside, however she had the freedom to sell candles and perfumes”.
76. The way in which the father answered all of the questions within this risk assessment process was, I find, in a very similar vein to that which he gave evidence to me. Potentially plausible answers to the allegations made against him, for example in respect of the expectations of Muslim women in society in terms of their attire, the father seeks to portray himself as simply encouraging female members of his family to follow the teachings of their culture and to wear appropriate clothing, but I find that he holds a more extreme view, which is evidenced in this extract from the risk assessment as well as in the evidence that I have from the mother, J, M, L, maternal aunt and maternal grandmother. The father, I find, holds extreme views about the role of women in society and within the family, considering that an education for his female children is not important, and in fact he was the one responsible for taking the family out of the UK and enrolling them in schools in Africa and at times homeschooling them. All of which was done with a view to ensuring that they were not going to be influenced by western norms and values.
77. I note here that within these proceedings and without application to the Court, or informing the mother who has parental responsibility for him, the father took proactive steps, including putting K into an entrance exam to enrol him in a grammar school some 50 miles away. This information only came out because K told his mother that he was going to visit the school and would be moving away to start at the school in a few weeks time. The father, I find, did this because he considered that he was entitled to do so, such is his arrogance about his position. It is only because the Court made a prohibited steps order preventing any change of school or relocation that this did not happen.
78. The father has, I find, in the presentation of his own case, provided evidence within these proceedings which shows that it is his behaviours that are controlling and abusive. He has filed with the court a huge number of screenshots of WhatsApp messages between K and the mother and other maternal family members. When I asked him how he had obtained these messages and whether he had asked K, now 13, whether he had his permission to take the screenshots, he told me simply that K had given them to him. I simply do not accept that.
79. The father, I find, has been, at the very least, discussing these proceedings with K to such an extent that he has been overseeing K’s phone use to be able to thereafter know what is on it, for him to use to further his own case.
80. At the same time, the father has provided a huge number of transcripts of WhatsApp messages between himself and the mother, which he says evidences the mother as the abuser and the aggressor, who is perpetrating alienating behaviours in respect of the girls, as well as producing various video clips, including a clip from CCTV footage taken whilst the mother and the children were at a restaurant. An upsetting incident took place, where the mother was attempting to take K’s phone from him, as he was seeking to video call or record the events to show or send to the father. As well as this clip, there are videos of the mother when she was fitting, which were not produced with the mother’s knowledge or consent. This evidence, I find, is in fact evidence of the father’s controlling and coercive behaviour towards the mother and the children.
81. The incident at the restaurant was a very unfortunate one, that arose ultimately because the father has, I find, sought to use K as a pawn in these proceedings in order to assist him in his quest to obtain evidence against the mother. I have no doubt that the father has encouraged K to record conversations between himself and his mother and his sisters, and to thereafter give these recordings to his father. This I find is abusive in itself. It has perpetuated the fear in the mother of the father’s abusive behaviours continuing and has led to a now very difficult relationship between mother and son.
82. I have reminded myself of the Family Justice Councils’ guidance in respect of cases involving alienating behaviours and the three necessary criteria that must be present for such a finding to be made. In applying those criteria, I am satisfied that rather than the mother coaching the girls to reject their father, it is in fact the father and his influence over K that has significantly damaged the mother and K’s relationship.
83. Further I consider that K is not immune either from fearing his father, he is stuck in the middle of his parents’ abusive relationship. On one occasion, K messaged his mother saying that he did not want to go on holiday with his father out of the jurisdiction, in the school summer holidays and was asking to stay with her. Of note is that in that message, K appears increasingly anxious for his mother to read the messages so that he could then delete them. I find that was so his father would not know about them and K would therefore not be in trouble with him.
84. As far as the father’s treatment of the girls is concerned, I find that is characterised by his extreme misogynistic views, and he uses his self-proclaimed role as the head of the household to exert power and control over them. Treating them harshly, getting angry and shouting in their faces, so much so that on occasions he was spitting. Wanting them to do his bidding and be completely subservient to him, he used his physical and psychological strength, which included him overbearing and touching them on the bottom to make them feel uncomfortable.
85. I say at this stage though, I am not however satisfied that in respect of the children at least, that these actions were sexually motivated, more to impress upon them his superiority over them.
86. Having said all of that, I do find that at times, the family would have some good times and that the father does indeed love his children, but on his terms and provided all other members of the family were behaving according to his rules and standards, then all would be well.
87. Ultimately, I am satisfied, assessing all the evidence I have in this case in the round and holistically, given that the mother and the father’s respective cases are diametrically opposed to each other, that it is the mother’s case that I prefer on all aspects of it. I do not accept at all the father’s assertions as set out in his Scott Schedule of findings sought and, in fact, I am satisfied that those allegations are untrue. The Allegations
88. With those findings made, for the avoidance of doubt, the allegations made by father against the mother in his Scott Schedule and dated 25 March 2025 are dismissed in their entirety.
89. Turning then to the schedule of allegations made by the mother and preferring her evidence on all matters, and considering each of the six areas under which findings are sought and in light of my analysis of the evidence, I have outlined in this judgment, the findings I make in this case are as follows: Controlling and Coercive Behaviour
1. Between 2010 and 2024, after the parties were married until separation, the father was controlling and coercive in the marriage and as a father, in that he ruled his family with an ‘iron fist’, such that there was an atmosphere of fear within the family, in particular: (a) He forced the mother, using threats of violence and his physicality to completely cover herself in the clothes she wore when outside the home, including at times forcing her to wear the niqab and the jilbab. (b) He demanded that the mother and the female children when older, walk either next to or behind him and never in front of him when outside the home. (c) He prevented the mother from attending her sister’s wedding and used threats of violence and his physicality to prevent her from speaking with any male family members or male family friends. (d) When the family lived in the Midlands, he on occasion locked the mother, J, and K in the bedroom upstairs when he had male friends visiting and frightened them into remaining silent. (e) He prevented the mother and the children on occasions, from watching television as he believed Western TV to be corrupting of his family, notwithstanding that he would watch television himself. (f) He controlled the family’s finances, including taking control of the mother’s benefit claims, in particular her Personal Independence Payment claim. (g) He made it clear that he considered women to be inferior to men by amongst other things insisting to the mother that he considered the female children of the family should be married at age 15 or 16 which the mother considered herself powerless to prevent. Sexual Abuse
2. When the mother was pregnant with J, the father raped her. As they were walking near to the river/canal, the father pushed the mother off the path and into some shrubland, where he roughly pulled her down and despite the mother saying no, the father forced himself upon her.
3. From approximately 2014 onwards, the father regularly raped the mother. He considered her to be his property, and he could have sex with her whenever he wanted to. In particular: (a) He would grab the mother around the mouth, forcefully at times when she was doing household chores and rape her. On many of these occasions, the mother would freeze with fear until the attack was over. (b) He would rape the mother during times when she was sleeping. (c) Around 2018/2019, the father forced a courgette into the mother’s vagina without her consent to cause the mother pain and embarrassment. Verbal and Emotional Abuse
4. From approximately 2012 until the parties separated, the father has verbally and emotionally abused the mother, in particular: (a) He made racist comments about the colour of the mother’s skin as well as derogatory comments about the mother’s body in respect of her weight, calling her ‘fat’ and ‘ugly’. (b) He has misogynistic views about women and considers that their only purpose in life is to marry, which he repeatedly made known to the mother. (c) He would regularly demean the mother by calling her a ‘bitch’ and a ‘prostitute ‘and ‘disgusting’ whilst he spat in her face. (d) He told the mother, “You’re dumb and cannot cook”, as well as saying, “you and the kids will never be successful and will be nothing without me”. (e) He shouted at the children when they became upset upon seeing him shouting and hurting their mother, which they did on occasion. (f) The father repeatedly moved the family both around South Yorkshire and Derbyshire and took them to Africa and Egypt to live and for the children to be educated, meaning there was instability in their lives, including the mother being away from British health services in respect of her epilepsy and disruption to the children’s education. Physical Abuse
5. In 2014, the father slapped the mother on two separate occasions across the face because he considered that she had not cleaned up correctly.
6. The father hit the mother when she was pregnant with L.
7. In approximately 2016/2017, the father threatened the mother and held a kitchen knife to her throat on several occasions. The children were present and witnessed this behaviour on some occasions. The father used the knife as a way to make the mother perform sexual acts on him.
8. In 2019, the father punched the mother in the front of her head, causing her to fall backwards onto the stairs. He did this when the mother attempted to prevent him from coming into the family home. He blamed the mother for this attack, saying that if she had not done what she had done, then he would not have hit her.
9. In 2019, on an occasion in front of the children, the father forcefully pulled the mother out of the bedroom, ripping her clothes and slapping and punching her. Psychological Abuse
10. When N was three weeks old, the mother was diagnosed with epilepsy with focal bilateral tonic clonic seizures. She also has a diagnosis of possible dissociative (non-epileptic) seizures which her neurologist, considers likely to be caused and brought on by trauma associated with domestic abuse. Physical and Emotional Harm of the Children
11. The father has imposed and continues to impose his misogynistic views upon K which has resulted in K considering himself to be superior to his sisters and to have a difficult relationship with his mother.
12. The father has used K to further his own case within these proceedings by encouraging him to keep in regular contact with the father during any periods of time that K spends with his mother and/or his maternal family, which has disrupted the time spent. In addition, he has at best encouraged, and at worst instructed K to record conversations between himself and his mother and at times his sisters. This led ultimately to their being an unfortunate incident in a restaurant, where the mother upset and distraught that K was again either recording conversations or on a video call to the father whilst he was spending time with the mother and his sisters, attempted to grab K’s phone from him and a physical incident, upsetting for all took place.
13. The father has on numerous occasions: (a) Slapped the children on their arms and legs, causing pain and engendering fear of him in them. These assaults were perpetrated most against the female children with K being treated more leniently. (b) Screamed and shouted at the children with such force that he at times was spitting in their faces. (c) Allowed the children to witness him assaulting, both physically and verbally, their mother.
14. The father has on several occasions forced himself into J’s personal space, hugging her tightly from behind, kissing her on her neck, and touching her bottom. He did this to exert power over J. This behaviour caused J to feel very uncomfortable and embarrassed.
15. The father has on numerous occasions forced himself into L’s personal space by touching her bottom, both over and under her clothes. He did this to exert power over L. This behaviour caused L to feel very uncomfortable.
16. Those are the findings that I make and that is my judgment. End of Judgment. Transcript of a recording by Acolad UK Ltd 291-299 Borough High Street, London SE1 1JG Tel: 020 7269 0370 [email protected] Acolad UK Ltd hereby certify that the above is an accurate and complete record of the proceedings or part thereof.