UK case law

Paul Henry Simms v The Registrar of Approved Driving Instructors

[2026] UKFTT GRC 1274 · First-tier Tribunal (General Regulatory Chamber) – Transport · 2026

Get your free legal insight →Email to a colleague
Get your free legal insight on this case →

The verbatim text of this UK judgment. Sourced directly from The National Archives Find Case Law. Not an AI summary, not a paraphrase — every word below is the original ruling, under Crown copyright and the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Full judgment

Background to Appeal

1. This appeal concerns a decision of the Registrar of Approved Driving Instructors (“the Registrar”) made on 18 th May 2023 to remove his name from the Register.

2. The Registrar’s reasons for refusal, in summary, were that the Appellant had accrued penalty points for speeding on 4 th June 2025 and 12 th June 2025. The Registrar took the view the offending was serious and allowing him to remain on the Register would undermine confidence in it, and so determined the Appellant must be removed.

3. The Appellant now appeals the Registrar’s decision. Appeal to the Tribunal

4. The Appellant’s Notice of Appeal, dated 16 th December 2025, indicates that he didn’t provide details earlier as he was abroad attending upon his mum, who was unwell. He argued that having instructed for 25 years without issue that removal for these two offences was disproportionate.

5. His grounds of appeal were not the easiest to follow, seeming to indicate 3 offences. He indicated for the first two offences he did not accept that he was exceeding the speed limit on either occasion and challenged the “speeding tickets.” Both offences were recorded at the same time of the day, albeit a few days apart, and with the Appellant travelling at the same speed of 35mph. His appeal was not upheld. He undertook a speed awareness course for one offence and was given 3 points for the second.

6. For the third offence he accepts probably a momentary lapse in concentration meaning he travelled at 24 in a 20 mph in an unfamiliar area. He received 3 further points for this offending.

7. He indicated that removal would have “an enormous impact upon my livelihood.” He said that he has set a speed restrictor setting on his car to avoid similar issues arising again. He argues his strong previous record has to be balanced against the infractions.

8. The Respondent submitted a Response indicating that the Appellant was warned about the first points offence, but not until 19 th September 2025. As the warning came after the later “points” offence the Tribunal felt it right to ignore the same . The Registrar said the Appellant was in charge of teaching young people to drive, and that he required ADIs to be of the highest standard in their use of the roads. Here the Appellant had failed in that regard and it would send out the wrong message if he was allowed to remain on the Register. He was no longer fit and proper. Mode of Determination

9. The case was to be listed for an oral hearing, but on the Appellant absence he was contacted and indicated he would not be attending and wished for a paper determination. The Registrar as Respondent indicated a neutral stance. As a result the Tribunal looked at the bundle provided and in accordance with the Tribunal Rules came to the view that a fair and appropriate determination was possible on the papers and acted accordingly.

10. The Tribunal considered a bundle consisting of 29 pages. The Law

11. Conditions for entry and retention on the Register require the Applicant to be and continue to be a “ fit and proper person ” to have his name on the Register of Approved Driving Instructors – see s. 125 (3) and s. 127 (3) (e) Road Traffic Act 1988 . http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1988/52/part/V/crossheading/registration

12. The Registrar may take the view that a person no longer meets this requirement where there has been a change in circumstances. The burden of showing that a person does not meet the statutory criteria rests with the Registrar.

13. In Harris v Registrar of Approved Driving Instructors [2010] EWCA Civ 808 , the Court of Appeal described the “ http:/www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWCA/Civ/2010/808.html fit and proper person” condition thus: “..the condition is not simply that the applicant is a fit and proper person to be a driving instructor, it is that he is a fit and proper person to have his name entered in the register. Registration carries with it an official seal of approval…the maintenance of public confidence in the register is important. For that purpose the Registrar must be in a position to carry out his function of scrutiny effectively, including consideration of the implications of any convictions of an applicant or a registered ADI. This is why there are stringent disclosure requirements”.

14. An appeal to this Tribunal against the Registrar’s decision proceeds as an appeal by way of re-hearing i.e. the Tribunal stands in the shoes of the Registrar and take a fresh decision on the evidence before it. The Tribunal must give such weight as is considered appropriate to the Registrar’s reasons as the Registrar is the person tasked by Parliament with making such decisions. The Tribunal does not conduct a procedural review of the Registrar’s decision-making process. See R (Hope and Glory Public House Limited) v City of Westminster Magistrates' Court [2011] EWCA Civ 31 . http://www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWCA/Civ/2011/31.html . Approved by the Supreme Court in Hesham Ali (Iraq) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2016] UKSC 60 at paragraph 45 – see https://www.supremecourt.uk/cases/docs/uksc-2015-0126-judgment.pdf . Conclusion

15. The Tribunal considered carefully all the papers before it.

16. Here the Appellant has committed three separate speeding offences within a very short period. The Appellant challenges the first two offences as the timing and speed were the same and this seemed unusual. The third offence is admitted as a lapse of concentration. The Tribunal appreciates that such things can happen, but a momentary lack of attention can have catastrophic consequences. A lack of attention by any driver is serious, but more so for an ADI.

17. The Tribunal comes to the view that the Registrar had no option but to remove the Applicant. The Registrar must ensure that the public has faith in the Register and the only way to do so is to ensure that only those suitable to instruct are on it. To allow the Appellant to appear on the Register would be to send out the wrong message and almost condone the speeding convictions. The Registrar simply can’t do that.

18. The Tribunal gave due regard to a holistic approach but the offences, the close timing of the same and the way the Appellant described the driving resulted in all of his good character going to one side. The series of offences were such that even 25 years of instruction was insufficient to counter the loss of character the offending caused. The Registrar must ensure that the Register is being upheld to the appropriate standard and allowing the Appellant to remain would undermine the same. The Tribunal agrees here with the Registrar.

19. The consequences of removal were considered carefully by the Tribunal to determine if it was proportionate in all the circumstances, and came to the firm view it was. A simple warning was insufficient for an ADI that had shown a disregard for the road and for his registration. Removal was entirely appropriate.

20. The Appeal is dismissed with immediate effect. The Registrar’s decision was correct. (Signed) HHJ David Dixon David Rawsthorn Martin Smith DATE: 27 th August 2026