UK case law
Paul William Little Sallis v The London Borough of Barking and Dagenham
[2026] UKFTT PC 1188 · Land Registration Division (Property Chamber) · 2026
The verbatim text of this UK judgment. Sourced directly from The National Archives Find Case Law. Not an AI summary, not a paraphrase — every word below is the original ruling, under Crown copyright and the Open Government Licence v3.0.
Full judgment
ADV1 Application – Applicant continuing to use land after expiry of licence- Cases referred to: Lord Advocate v. Lord Lovat (1880)5 App.Cas. 273 Powell v McFarlane (1977) 38 P and CR 452 J A Pye (Oxford Ltd) v Graham [2003] AC 419 Allen v. Matthews [2007] P&CR 441
1. The Applicant, Mr Sallis has applied to HM Land Registry to be registered as proprietor of land on the north side of The Chase, Rush Green, Romford (“the Land”). His application is made under schedule 6 of the Land Registration Act 2002 . Mr Sallis claims to have been in adverse possession of the land for a period of ten years prior to the date of his application. The owner of the land is the London Borough of Barking and Dagenham (“the Council”). The Council gave notice requiring the application to be dealt with under paragraph 5 of Schedule 6. Mr Sallis relies on the first condition in paragraph 5. He says that it would be unconscionable for the Council to dispossess him due to an equity by estoppel and the circumstances justify his being registered as proprietor.
2. I visited the site on the afternoon before the hearing. Mr Sallis, counsel for both parties and representatives of the Council attended the site visit. The site is accessed from a road called The Chase. The Chase runs approximately west to east. At the eastern end on the south is a building called the Discovery Centre (formerly called The Millenium Centre), which is owned by the Council. Also on the southern side is a travellers’ site. On the northern side there are two large lakes, called Eastbrook Pond and Chase Waters. This lake, the land around it and land on the south side of The Chase together comprise part of a nature reserve. The Land is to the east of Chase Waters. It comprises a smaller lake and surrounding land. The Chase provides access at its eastern end to a cemetery called Eastbrookend Cemetery. The south, east and north sides of the Land adjoin the cemetery.
3. Access to the Land is through two large metal gates. There is a sign on the gates reading “British Waterways Private No Parking Permitted”. The words “British Waterways” are in a much smaller font than the other words on the sign. There is a carpark across the road from the gates into the Land.
4. The Land is securely fenced on all sides. Between the cemetery and the Land there is a fence of a fence of vertical metal bars. There are other fences between the Land and the nature reserve to the west. In places, there are metal and wire fences and a fence of wooden plans against the other fences. At the request of the Council, I walked around the outside of the Land, both in the cemetery and the open land to the west.
5. A curving driveway lined on both sides with hedges and bushes leads from the gates to an open, hard-surfaced area. This was referred to as the parking area and I shall so refer to it. All that is visible from the gates is the driveway and part of the parking area beyond.
6. On the south side of the parking area is a home, constructed from three portacabins. The exterior of the portacabins has been clad in timber and a roof of corrugated metal sheets has been built over them. There is a yard, surfaced in part with concrete and in part with tiles, running across the front of the portacabins and divided from the parking area to the north by a fence. Small trees, bushes and plants grow between the yard fence and the parking area. Inside the home, there is a bathroom, dressing room, kitchen, sitting room and bedroom. It is fully furnished. The home has electric lights and power. It also has central heating and hot water. At the end of the portacabins there is an open shed in which there is a touring caravan, now stripped of its furnishings and being used for storage.
7. To the west of the parking area and north of the drive (hidden from the drive by bushes) is another area on which there is a large metal container used for storage and an area being used as a garden.
8. Most of the area of the Land is occupied by a lake. There are two small islands in the lake. The lake is surrounded by trees. There is a path around the lake. On the west side of the lake there is a channel that formerly linked the lake to Chase Waters. There is a bridge over this channel. The path round the lake gives access to several level areas by the side of the lake, called “swims” and being areas from which anglers can fish, giving room to set up chairs and rods and put bait boxes and other equipment. Six of the “swims” are equipped with small huts, referred to by Mr Sallis as “chattels”. Anglers can shelter from poor weather in the huts or even stay overnight in them. An oxygenating pump is installed by the southeast corner of the lake. To the south of the path along the south side of the lake, between the pump and the portacabin home, are wooden buildings providing toilet and shower facilities, a club room and storage. A sign saying “Obsession Fishing Club” is attached to the front of the club room building. History
9. In July 2006 Mr Sallis began negotiations with the Council for the grant of a lease of the Land. Mr Simon Farrow, Group Manager in the Parks and Leisure Department of the Council wrote to Mr Sallis on 21 st July 2006 saying he was in a position to negotiate a lease for one of the lakes at the Eastbrookend Country park and asking for details of who was in the club and what was proposed in terms of investment in fish and improvements to the lake. Mr Sallis replied on 22 nd July 2006. In that letter Mr Sallis set out the work proposed to be done, being repairing fencing and installing a new fence, installing swims and paths, shoring up and cleaning the lake, clearing the car park, placing a container for storage on the land, fencing off an area for the storage of materials, putting in about £3000 worth of fish and then running it as a “small club water”. He named the members of the club as himself, Allen Marsh, Eric Thorne, Steve Young, Gary Gifford and Mark Sallis.
10. Although Mr Farrow wrote about negotiating a “lease”, no document described as a lease was granted. On 13 th November 2006 Mr Page, Acting Ranger Services Manager for the Council and Mr Sallis as chairman on behalf of Obsession Angling Club signed a licence and service level agreement. The licence is expressed to be between the Council as licensor and Obsession Angling Club as licensee. By paragraph 1 the Council granted “… a Licence for the purpose of fishing and no other purpose whatsoever … to the Licensee for the benefit of the current and future members of The Syndicate only”. The term “The Syndicate” is not defined in the Licence. The Licence is expressed to be for a term of 5 years from 6 th November 2006 to 13 th November 2011 and “subject to annual reviews by the Council and the Licensee”. The licence fee was to be £585 for the first year “payable on demand” and “£720 + RPI” for the second year and “£900 + RPI” for the third year. The licence fee was to be reviewed on an annual basis and payable from the date specified in a notice of increase. Clause 5 provided that the Licensee was “to submit copy of their constitution to Parks and Leisure Development Section of the Council”.
11. By clause 7 of the Licence, the licensee agreed (inter alia) (a) to provide a written annual costed work programme (b) to employ bailiffs to provide “at least a daily presence” to protect and preserve the fish and angling rights (c) to maintain the Lake and land surrounding it (d) to put and keep the Lake and banks of the Lake in good and substantial condition (e) to insure the Council and lawful visitors against all claims arising from exercise of the rights conferred by the Licence. The Licence gave the Licensee the right to erect such notices on the licensed area as should first be approved by the Council.
12. The Service Level Agreement (“SLA”) was signed by Mr Page for the Council and by Mr Sallis “on behalf of Obsession Angling Club”. The SLA was expressed to be between the Council and “The Syndicate”, the latter term not being defined. Clause 2 included the following “2.1 The club will provide an annual written, costed work programme to be agreed with the Council (in accordance with the licence) on an agreed date 2.2 The club and a representative of the Ranger Service will meet on a quarterly basis to co-ordinate the implementation of the annual work programme 2.3 Any proposals for work to the lake and surrounding area or stocking of fish in addition to the annual work programme must be submitted to the Ranger Services manager in writing and agreed before commencement.” Clause 6 provided as follows 6.1 The Council will grant permissive access on foot to the fenced area around the lake for the purposes of fishing and the undertaking of maintenance works 6.2 The Council will permit a storage container (of agreed dimensions) for use by the club to be placed within the boundary of the fenced area. Subject to the correct legal permissions the club will also be allowed to install an electric and water supply to the said storage container if undertaken by approved and agreed contractors. All costs to be the responsibility of the club. 6.3 Parking for a maximum of 6 cars will be permitted in the fenced area around the lake. Names of club members and registration details to be parked on site to be provided.”
13. Curiously, on 21 st August 2006, that is prior to the signing of the Licence and Service Level Agreement, FH Bundle delivered to Mr Sallis “c/o The Chase Next Door to Eastbrook Cemetery” some metal palisade fencing and posts.
14. On 11 th January 2007 “Obsession Fishing Club” was insured by Insuresport Mutual Ltd and by Royal and Sun Alliance Insurance PLC in respect of civil liability, the indemnity liability being split equally between the two insurers.
15. On 20 th March 2007 AJS Ltd invoiced Mr Sallis for running a new electricity supply from Eastbrook Cemetery to the Land, in the amount of £1,450.41. The invoice was paid in cash on 10 th May 2007. There is no documentary evidence as to how the supply came to be made or as to whether the Council gave permission. The supply runs from a building in the cemetery, which stands some considerable distance from the edge of the Land. The making of the supply must have involved the digging of a long trench through the cemetery.
16. From 15 th January 2007 “Obsession FC” was on the role of members of the National Association of Fisheries and Angling Consultatives and a membership fee of £60 was paid.
17. On 4 th June 2008 Mr Sallis and Eric Thorne met Fiona Gardner, then a Lakes Ranger for the Council. A note of the meeting records that they discussed the water levels, the behaviour of a traveller’s child, work plans, the possibility of stocking the lake with perch and the placing of a container or containers on the land. Paragraph 6.0 of the note states “FG noticed that the club have put up a container/s without gaining permission from the Ranger Service prior to the construction. FG asked that all work to be laid out in an annual work plan and agreed in advance with the Ranger Service”. Photographs
18. Mr Sallis produced some photographs of portacabins. Photographs dated 10 th April 2010 show a portacabin suspended in the air from a crane. Photographs dated August 2011 show a portacabin or portacabins on the ground, with windows covered with wire mesh, and a paved area with the portacabin on one side and fencing on the other. There are a dog kennel and several pots of flowers on the paving. A photograph taken in October 2011 shows the portacabin behind the fencing. Another photograph taken in February 2012 shows the full length of the portacabins. Mr Sallis also produced photographs taken on 16 th October 2011 of dogs in the yard in front of the portacabins. In one of the photographs a kennel can be seen against the wall of the portacabins and there are hanging baskets filled with flowering plants mounted on the same wall. He also produced photographs of a Christmas party taking place on 27 th December 2016 in what he said was the home made from the portacabins. The photographs taken in a kitchen show the same or a very similar layout to the kitchen seen on the site visit and the same or very similar style of kitchen units. Mr Sallis’s Evidence
19. Mr Sallis confirmed the contents of his witness statement dated 19 th December 2025 and was cross-examined. Mr Sallis said that he was granted the licence and that he was the person liable to pay the licence fee. He was not provided with bank details into which payment of the licence fees could be made and no demands or invoices for the fees were sent to him during the five-year period of the licence.
20. Mr Sallis said that he erected a fence around the Land to deter unauthorised entry, installed a lock on the front gate and placed a “Private No Parking” sign on the gate. Asked in cross-examination as to why the sign on the gate said, “Thames Water”, Mr Sallis said that he found the sign and decided to use it, without paying much attention to the “Thames Water” lettering. He just wanted to put up a sign to say the land in front of the gate was private and should not be used for parking.
21. Mr Sallis listed in his witness statement works that he said he had carried out to the lake. These included (a) improving the standard and condition of the lake, as by supplying chemicals to improve water quality, removing silt and large debris such as bicycles, trolleys, disused gas meters, tyres and other waste. (b) improving existing pathways and creating new ones, fencing and establishing shelters for fishermen (c) purchasing and supplying fish to the lake (d) installing and maintaining a bridge (e) laying bark on the pathways and swims (f) pruning and cutting back trees and shrubs to maintain the grounds (g) painting the gates, hits, kitchen area, toilets and swim fronts (h) emptying the cesspit three times a year (i) removing a fallen willow tree and cutting down a dead poplar tree (j) removing weeds from the lake and thinning out the water lilies (k) adding barley straw to the lake twice a year (l) cutting the grass (m) removing excess fish (n) creating habitats for wildlife, including bird boxes (o) erecting handrails around the pathways (p) rebuilding huts (q) re-surfacing the clinker bricks in the carpark and walkway areas. He said he had spent £36,000 by 2011 in works to the Lake. In cross-examination about who did the work, Mr Sallis said that though some of the club members listed in the letter of 22 nd July 2006 helped with work on the Land for the first two or three weeks, thereafter he did the work with the help of only Mr Eric Thorne.
22. Mr Sallis’s evidence about living on the land was that he began living in a caravan on the land during the period of the licence. He also said that he bought and erected a portacabin on the area next to the lane, expanded it into a residential home and had lived in it since 2007. He said creating the home cost him £20,000. He had installed a kitchen purchased from B&Q. Mr Sallis produced an email quote from B&Q dated 2 nd November 2012 for a gloss black slab kitchen with black work tops. The kitchen seen on the site view had gloss black slab doors and black work tops. Mr Sallis also produced an email sent by his partner, Ms Tanya Marnham to B&Q on 13 th November 2012 saying that the kitchen had been received but some parts were missing. Mr Sallis said he installed double glazing, insulation, central hearing, a shower and toilet. He upgraded the exterior, including erecting a fence with internal gates, paving areas, and creating gardens, planting trees and other plants. Those features can be seen in the photographs Mr Sallis produced. Mr Sallis said Ms Marnham moved into the portacabin to live with him in 2010.
23. Mr Sallis was cross-examined about the Obsession Fishing Club. He had not produced any constitution, accounts, minutes of meeting, lists of members or other documentation to show the existence of the club or how it was run. There was the list of members in the letter to Mr Simon Farrow of 22 nd July 2006. He did not call anyone on that list to give evidence. Mr Sallis said that he was the one who ran the fishing lake. There was no club constitution. He said that there were 12 members of the club, each of whom paid an annual fee of £250. He collected the membership fees and decided how to spend what was raised. He did in fact spend it all on maintaining and improving the lake. He said that he ran and controlled the club. He decided what should be done. He controlled when and how the members came onto the Land.
24. Mr Sallis agreed that in signing the licence he was signing on behalf of the members of the club and committing them to the terms set out in the licence. However, he said that taking the licence of the lake was his idea and he made all the decisions.
25. Asked whether he knew that the licence could be terminated on one month’s notice, Mr Sallis said that the terms of the notice were something of a blur. He did not take into consideration that the licence could be terminated.
26. Mr Sallis said that the first two portacabins came onto the site towards the end of 2007 or early 2008. He was unable to explain why in his statement of case at paragraph 13(d), he stated that the portacabins came onto the Land in 2009. The third portacabin was brought onto the Land on 10 th April 2010.
27. Mr Sallis accepted that he did not intend to exclude the Council from the land in 2008. In 2008 he met with Fiona Gardner, one of the Park Rangers, on the site. They stood beside the two portacabins that were then on the site and had been turned into living accommodation with a bedroom and wc in one and a kitchen/living room in the other. Fiona Gardner raised with him the issue of a container being on the land. She did not say anything about Mr Sallis living on the site. Mr Sallis said that he did not intend to exclude the Council “initially” but at the end, he did so intend .
28. Mr Sallis denied having any conversation with Martin Page after 2006. He did not speak to him between June 2008 and 2010 to tell him that the lake would be “moving to a lease”. He did not know the difference between a lease and a licence and wasn’t aware that a different department of the Council managed leased property from that which managed licenced property.
29. Mr Sallis was insistent that Council employees were aware of what Mr Sallis was doing on the land. He said that Council employees did nature walks around the country park and would have seen that he had erected a home on the Land. He said that bailiffs on other lakes called him at night to say there was anti-social behaviour happening on the others lakes and asking him to come to help them. A lady from the Council called Valerie, who looked after swans, had called him at times to say that there were swans on the Lake and to ask if she could come to collect them. He said that the management of the cemetery knew he was on the Land. In his witness statement, Mr Sallis said that Peter Hyams and Alan Marshall were employed by the Council as Park Police. They were fishing enthusiasts and visited him at his home in the portacabins for tea. He also named Martin Lamb as an employee of the Council who knew he was on the Land. Neither Mr Hyams, nor Mr Marshall nor Mr Lamb were called to give evidence by either Mr Sallis or the Council. Mr Sallis’s explanation as to why he had no contact with the Council about the land from 2008 when he met with Ms Gardner until 2021 was that the Council had forgotten about the lake.
30. Mr Sallis was cross-examined about his communications with Mr Gareth Winn in 2021. Mr Sallis said he could not recall saying to Mr Winn that he made payments to the Council for the lake or that the current fee was £1,400. Asked why he did not tell Mr Winn that the Land was now his and he was in possession, Mr Sallis said that he wanted to find the Licence agreement to see what his position was in law. He said that he had put so much effort and expense into the land, he was intending to exclude all but he needed to find the Licence and see legally where he stood.
31. In his witness statement Mr Sallis said that the Council’s inaction led him to believe up to 2022 “I owned the Disputed Land and Lake I had or would have a proprietary interest through my long uninterrupted use. That after more than 10 long years of uninterrupted use of the Disputed Land and Lake I would be registered as legal and beneficial owner ….”. Mr Sallis accepted that he did not receive any positive indication from the Council that he would own the Land or have an interest in it. He said that by standing by and letting him do what he wanted on the Land, the Council led him to believe that he could do what he wanted with it. In answer to questions from the Tribunal, Mr Sallis said that there was no guarantee the Council might not change its mind. He said he was running the risk that the Council might change its mind and he would not be able to stay on the Land.
32. Mr Sallis said he spent about £20,000 on the portacabins and that he spent a total of £36,000 on works on the Land up to 2011. From 2011 to 2022 he spent another £36,300 but this was funded from money generated from the Land.
33. Mr Sallis produced written statements from Erik Thorne, Maurice Archibald, Mark Robertson, John Hodge, Marie Roythorne, Mrs Y Crockson and Francesca Colting. These statements do not contain statements of truth and the makers were not called to give evidence. I shall not give any weight to their contents. The Respondent’s Witnesses
34. The Council called Mr Gareth Winn to give evidence. Mr Winn confirmed the contents of his witness statements made on 29 th March 2022 and 19 th December 2025. He was cross-examined. Mr Winn was employed by the Council as Senior Conservation Ranger between 2006 and 2013. He was the direct line manager for Fiona Gardner, who was the Lakes Ranger and as such responsible for overseeing the lakes. Mr Winn was based at the Discovery Centre on The Chase. Mr Winn returned to work for the Council in 2019 as Ranger Team Leader. As such, he is responsible for the management of Eastbrookend Country Park, including the Land.
35. In 2021 Mr Winn was in the process of setting up a lease agreement for another lake and wanted to use the agreement with Mr Sallis as a basis for drafting the new lease agreement. Copy emails disclosed by the Council show that Mr Winn on 8 th April 2021 asked a colleague, Mr Andy Bere for the current lease fee for “Obsession Angling Lake” because he wanted to look at the fee to work out charges for another lake on the country park. Mr Bere referred the enquiry to Robert Barry, who was the sales, lease and conveyancing officer. Mr Barry wrote to Mr Winn and to Andy Johnson, Lead Commissioner Parks, saying that he could not locate Obsession Angling Lake within the portfolio. Nikki Moon, Data Officer in the Asset Management department emailed Mr Winn on 13 th April 2021 to say she had not heard of Obsession Angling Lake. Mr Winn emailed Nikki Moon, Robert Barry and Andy Johnson saying “Do I take it Obsession is not paying any lease/licence fee?”. Mr Winn then obtained a telephone number for Mr Sallis from Asset Management. Mr Winn telephoned Mr Sallis on 27 th April 2021 to ask him for a copy of his agreement for use of the Land. On Tuesday 27 th April at 16.18 Mr Winn sent a text to Mr Sallis reading “Hi Paul, thanks for speaking with me this morning. When do you think you can get me a copy of your licence/lease? Thanks Gareth”. Mr Sallis replied, “Hi Gareth as soon as I get a chance I will email you a copy cheers”. Mr Winn replied, “Thanks paul. If you can get it over by this Friday I would greatly appreciate it. Cheers Gareth”. On the same day, Mr Winn emailed Nikki Moon stating as follows “I tracked down a contact number for Sallis from Obsession. He has confirmed that he’s paying £1,400 per year for the lake and is going to forward me the lease/licence and is going to confirm the annual payments he has been paying for 15 years plus”. On Friday 30 th April at 13.39 Mr Winn sent a text chasing for a copy of the licence. In his text he wrote “I’ve spoken to Asset management and they say that there is no licence for you to be on the lake and they have no record of any annual payments from you for the lake. I really need this information and proof of annual payment as if not Asset Management will take action”. He also asked for an email address for Mr Sallis so that the Council “can contact your formally”. Mr Sallis replied on Saturday 1 st May at 11.56 “Hi Gareth I have not found it yet I think it must be in my lock box at my mum’s so as soon as I get down there I’ll check”. He then gave his email address. Mr Winn replied on the same day at 13.56 (he was not asked about working on a Saturday), asking for “copies of your payments to the council so at least that shows you have still been paying annually for the lake”. Mr Sallis did not reply.
36. Mr Neil Pearce is the Head of Sustainability, Net Zero and Parks Commissioning for the Council. Since 2022 he has led the division that contains the rangers team. Both Mr Pearce and Mr Winn gave evidence of the Council’s internal arrangements for the management of licensed and leased property. Leased property is dealt with by the Asset Management Team. Licenses to use fishing lakes would be dealt with by the Ranger Team. Both witnesses offered as a suggestion as to why the Council may have taken no action in relation to Mr Sallis’s use of the Land between the end of the licence period and 2021 that the Ranger Team may have thought responsibility for Mr Sallis being on the Land had passed to Asset Management and Asset Management may have been unaware of the transfer. This was mere speculation and not evidence of fact. Neither witness gave any explanation as to why Asset Management had Mr Sallis’s telephone number when Mr Winn asked for it.
37. Mr Alexander Tayler is employed as Principal Development Management Officer by Be First (Regeneration) Ltd., a company undertaking statutory development management planning and planning policy functions on behalf of the Council. In that role, he dealt with the planning application Mr Sallis made in respect of the Lake and his subsequent appeal against the refusal of permission. He explained that the application for a certificate of lawful development for the use of the portacabins as a residential dwellinghouse was refused because the Council was not satisfied that the property had been in continuous residential use since 22 nd October 2022. That decision was based on the absence of council tax records, of reference to the portacabins on the electoral roll and of bank statements giving the portacabins as Mr Sallis’s address. The Council also considered that the British Waterways sign may have been used to conceal the use of the portacabins.
38. Mr Paul Clark is the Head of Service for Parks, Green Spaces and Highways at the Council. As such, he is in charge of the management of Eastbrookend Cemetery. He accepted that a supply of electricity had been made from the cemetery to the Land in 2007. He said that Gareth Winn and Andy Johnson asked his department to pay an invoice for an electricity sub-meter in the cemetery in 2020 but he did not know until 2023 that the supply was being used by the Land. He knew Mr Sallis but did not know what Mr Sallis was doing on the Land. Law
39. Schedule 6 paragraph 1(1) to the Land Registration Act 2002 provides that a person may apply to the registrar to be registered as the proprietor of a registered estate in land if he has been in adverse possession of the estate for the period of ten years ending on the date of the application. The question to be answered when considering whether a person occupying land is “in adverse possession” is “…whether the Defendant squatter has dispossessed the paper owner by going into ordinary possession of the land for the requisite period without the consent of the owner…Beyond that…the words possess and dispossess are to be given their ordinary meaning.” (per Lord Browne-Wilkinson in J A Pye (Oxford Ltd) v Graham [2003] AC 419 at paragraphs 36, 37).
40. Legal possession is comprised of two elements: (1) A sufficient degree of physical custody and control (“factual possession”); and (2) An intention to exercise such custody and control on one’s own behalf and for one’s own benefit (“intention to possess”). “What is crucial is to understand that, without the requisite intention in law there can be no possession. Such intention may be, and frequently is, deduced from the physical acts themselves.” ( ibid paragraph 40).
41. Factual possession has been described as follows: “It signifies an appropriate degree of physical control. It must be a single and [exclusive] possession…Thus an owner of land and a person intruding on that land without his consent cannot both be in possession of the land at the same time. The question what acts constitute a sufficient degree of exclusive physical control must depend on the circumstances, in particular the nature of the land and the manner in which land of that nature is commonly used or enjoyed …Everything must depend on the particular circumstances, but broadly, I think what must be shown as constituting factual possession is that the alleged possessor has been dealing with the land in question as an occupying owner might have been expected to deal with it and that no one else has done so.” Per Slade J in Powell v McFarlane (1977) 38 P and CR 452 at pp. 470-471, cited at paragraph 41 in J A Pye (Oxford) v Graham .
42. Whether the alleged possessor has been dealing with the land as an occupying owner might have been expected to deal with it depends on the particular facts. Lord O’Hagan in Lord Advocate v. Lord Lovat (1880)5 App.Cas. 273 at p. 288 set out the test as follows “As to possession, it must be considered in every case with reference to the peculiar circumstances. The acts, implying possession in one case, may be wholly inadequate to prove it in another. The character and value of the property, the suitable and natural mode of using it, the course of conduct which the proprietor might reasonably be expected to follow with regard to his own interests – all these things, greatly varying as they must, under various conditions, are to be taken into account in determining the sufficiency of possession”.
43. Schedule 6 paragraph 3(1) provides that the registered proprietor of the estate may require the application to be dealt with under paragraph 5. If he does so then the applicant is only entitled to be registered as the new proprietor of the estate if at least one of the three conditions set out in paragraph 5 is met. The Council as required the application to be dealt with under paragraph 5. Mr Sallis’s case is that the first condition of paragraph 5 is met. Paragraph 5(2) provides that the first condition is that “(a) it would be unconscionable because of an equity by estoppel for the registered proprietor to seek to dispossess the applicant, and (b) the circumstances are such that the applicant ought to be registered as the proprietor”.
44. As to estoppel, counsel for Mr Sallis referred me to Megarry and Wade: The Law of Real Property (10 th edition) and to Snell’s Equity (34 th edition). The elements of estoppel are set out in chapter 15 of Megarry and Wade. The first is encouragement or acquiescence. At 15-008 the editors say “The owner of the land, O must have encouraged C by words or conduct to believe that C has or will in the future enjoy some right or benefit over O’s property that is not merely personal in nature. … O’s conduct may be either active or passive , and need not be the promise of a specific right or interest, provided it is “clear enough” in the circumstances and concerns a right to property”. At 15-010 the editors discuss “passive encouragement”: “Passive encouragement occurs when O, an owner of land, stands by and allows C to act to his or her detriment knowing that C mistakenly believes that C has or will obtain an interest or right over O’s land. … The one element that is clearly essential is that O’s conduct should have encouraged C to act as he or she did. Mere inaction in the face of an infringement of O’s rights cannot therefore amount to acquiescence because it does not induce C to act. In cases of passive encouragement, it is unlikely that O’s conduct will be regarded as unconscionable unless O was aware of, or should have been aware of: (i) O’s own proprietary rights (ii) C’s expenditure or other detrimental acts; and (iii) C’s mistaken belief that he had or would acquire an interest in or over O’s land”.
45. The second element of estoppel is detrimental reliance. At 15-014 the editors of Megarry state “”C must have acted to his or her detriment in reliance on the belief that C has or will acquire some right over O’s land”. The requirement for reliance is discussed at 15-109: “C must have acted in reliance upon O’s actine or passive encouragement. However, such reliance will be readily inferred once it is shown that O encouraged C and C in fact acted to his or her detriment. In such circumstances, the onus will be on O to show that there was no such reliance.”
46. The third element is unconscionability. “To establish an equity by estoppel, it must be unconscionable for O to act in such a way as to defeat the expectation that C had been encouraged or induced to believe. ... It is not essential that O should have been guilty of unconscionable conduct in permitting C to assume that he could act as he did. It is O’s subsequent refusal to permit C’s use or enjoyment of the land that must be unconscionable”. – 15-020.
47. Counsel also referred me to Snell’s Equity at 12-040 where the editors state “It is certainly the case that a proprietary estoppel cannot arise where B simply hopes to acquire a right in A’s land and so does not have any belief that he has, or will necessarily acquire, such a right”. Possession 2007 to 2011
48. From 2007 to 2011 Mr Sallis had the right to use and carry out activities on the Land under the terms of the Licence and the SLA. His case is that the Obsession Angling Club was to all intents and purposes himself. He cannot therefore say that he did not have the rights to use and carry out activities on the Land granted by the Licence and SLA. The right granted by the Licence was to use the Land for the purpose of fishing. The activities authorised (and in some cases, required) by the Licence and the SLA included maintaining the Land, putting the lake and its banks into good condition, placing a storage container on the Land and installing supplies or electricity and water to the container.
49. In Allen v. Matthews [2007] P&CR 441, Lawrence Collins LJ said “[86] …whether a person with limited permission to use or occupy land might rely on more extensive activity to claim adverse possession is a question of fact turning on the circumstances of the case. [87] There must be a change in the nature of occupation in order for use or occupation by consent to become adverse possession and it is not enough simply to increase use beyond what was permitted or contemplated. But certainly, use with consent that becomes occupation without consent would result in adverse possession”.
50. I do not consider that there was such a change in the nature of the use and occupation of the Land by Mr Sallis during the period of the Licence as to turn his use and occupation of the Land into adverse possession. His use of the Land was substantially that which was permitted under the Licence. His use was for the purposes of fishing. His activities on the Land were all broadly of the type authorised by the Licence and SLA. He stayed overnight on the Land but did so in connection with running the fishery and in against a background of the requirement in the Licence to have bailiffs on the Land to protect the fishing rights. Possession from 2011
51. The Licence expired by effluxion of time on 13 th November 2011. I do not find that the Licence was extended to 2013. The only evidence that the Council sought to rely on as showing an extension until 2013 is a spreadsheet extract said to have come from the Council’s Asset Management department in which the date of occupation of the Land is given as “unknown – licence expires 2013”. There is no evidence as to who compiled the spreadsheet or when. The statement that the licence expires in 2013 could be a simple mistake. The spreadsheet is not sufficient for me to find on the balance of probabilities that the Licence was extended.
52. Once the Licence had come to an end, Mr Sallis was not on the Land with permission. The Council appears to have done nothing to remove him and thus it may be said that the Council tolerated his presence on the Land but toleration is not the same as permission.
53. After 2011 Mr Sallis continued to live on the Land and from 2010, he lived there with his partner, Ms Marnham. I accept Mr Sallis’s evidence in this regard. The photographs he produced taken in show the portacabins furnished and equipped like a home. The photographs taken in October 2011 showing the dogs and dog pen with kennel outside the portacabins and the hanging baskets, flowers and plants all support a finding that Mr Sallis was then using the portacabins as a home. The photographs of a Christmas party also support a finding that Mr Sallis was living in the portacabins. I do not accept that the fact Mr Sallis did not pay Council Tax for the portacabins should lead me to conclude that he did not live in the portacabins. Mr Sallis could not have received a Council Tax bill unless the portacabins were on the valuation list. It was not submitted that Mr Sallis was under a legal obligation to notify the Council or the Valuation Office of the conversion of the portacabins into a dwelling. He may have been but I was not taken to any statute or case law showing that he was. In any event, Mr Sallis being in breach of a legal obligation of this type (if that be the case) would not mean he was not living in the portacabins as he states. 54 Mr Sallis continued after 2011 to control access to the Land. He kept the entrance gate padlocked and controlled access by giving keys to those who he permitted to fish on the lake. He did not give a key to the Council. After 2008 when Mr Sallis met with Fiona Gardner, there is no evidence that any officer of the Council went on to the Land.
55. From 2011 Mr Sallis dealt with the Land as an occupying owner might be expected to deal with it. Having constructed a home for himself, he lived on the Land, cultivated part of it as a garden, and controlled access. Intention to Possess
56. Mr Sallis demonstrated the intention to use the Land as his own by not leaving following the expiry of the licence, by living on it, locking the gate and controlling who had access.
57. I find that Mr Sallis was in possession of the Land from November 2011 when the Licence expired. He was thus in possession of the Land for a period of ten years prior to the making of his application under Schedule 6 to the Land Registration Act 2002 . However, as the Council required the application to be dealt with under paragraph 5 of Schedule 6, Mr Sallis cannot be registered unless he shows that the condition on which he relies is met. Knowledge of the Council
58. Mr Sallis’s case is that the Council knew he was on the Land after 2011, knew he was living on the Land and knew he was doing works on the Land. Mr Sallis said that the Council knew he was on the Land because various officers or employees of the Council, such as park rangers, bailiffs working on other fishing lakes and those working at the Eastbrookend Cemetery would have seen him on the Land. Mr Sallis did not call any officer or employee of the Council, whether currently or previously employed, to give evidence that they knew Mr Sallis was living on the Land and doing works on the Land. I accept and find that the Council knew that Mr Sallis was continuing to use the Land. It knew Mr Sallis went onto the Land under the Licence and was there in 2008 when Fiona Gardner visited. There is no evidence the Council took any steps to see if Mr Sallis left the Land at the expiry of the Licence or that it had any grounds for believing he had left. Mr Winn knew Mr Sallis was on the Land in 2020 and was able to get Mr Sallis’s contact details from the Asset Management department. However, in the absence of any supporting evidence from any officer or employee of the Council, I do not find the Council knew Mr Sallis was living on the Land after the Licence expired or knew of any works he did on the Land after November 2011. Encouragement
59. Mr Sallis does not say that there was any active encouragement by the Council. Mr Sallis relies on passive encouragement in the form of acquiescence. That requires him to show that the Council knew he believed he had or would obtain an interest or right in the Land and stood by while he acted to his detriment in reliance on that belief. There is no evidence that the Council knew that Mr Sallis believed he had or would obtain an interest in the Land.
60. Even if the Council knew that Mr Sallis was living on the Land and knew of the work Mr Sallis said he did on the Land after the expiry of the Licence, I do not consider that the Council would or should have deduced that Mr Sallis believed he had an interest in the Land. It does not follow from the fact that Mr Sallis was living on the Land and maintaining the fishery that he believed he had a property interest in the Land. The major works Mr Sallis did on the Land, such as bringing on the portacabins and creating a dwelling, were in fact done during the period of the Licence. If Mr Sallis was prepared to do those works when he knew he was occupying under a Licence, then knowing that he was continuing to live on the Land and to maintain it would not reasonably have led the Council to conclude that he thought he had or would acquire some different interest from the works he did after the Licence period expired. The Council could quite reasonably have concluded that Mr Sallis had simply decided to continue to use the Land until he was told to leave. Mr Sallis’s Belief
61. What Mr Sallis pleaded at paragraph 38 of his Statement of Case was that the Council encouraged him to believe that “he would enjoy possession and/or an interest in the Disputed Land by remaining in possession and acting to his detriment in developing the said land and residing thereon”. He did not plead what interest, that was not merely personal, he thought he had or would acquire.
62. Mr Sallis set out in his witness statement at paragraph 57 three beliefs that he said he had as to the Land as the result of “inaction” by the Council. These were that he thought he “owned the Land”, that he thought he “had or would have” a “property interest” and that after ten years use, he would be entitled to be registered as proprietor and it would be inequitable for the Council to deny him continued use of the Land. The three “beliefs” he set out are inconsistent. If he thought he was the owner of the Land then he would not also have thought that he would acquire a property interest at some time in the future. The third belief is essentially a statement that he thought he could rely on Schedule 6 of the Land Registration Act 2002 . That belief does not sit easily with a belief that he was already the owner or that he would acquire a property interest in the future.
63. I do not find that Mr Sallis believed he owned the Land or that he had or would acquire an interest in the Land. His answers to questions about his conversation with Mr Winn indicates that he did not know what, if any, interest in the land he then had. He said that he wanted to obtain a copy of the Licence so he could see what his legal position was. I have no doubt that if Mr Sallis had thought he owned the Land then when Mr Winn that he owned the Land. Likewise, if Mr Sallis believed that he had some interest in the Land (other than any interest he had under the Licence) then he would have told Mr Winn. Furthermore, when Mr Winn sent a text message to Mr Sallis saying that he needed proof of annual payment or the Council would take action, Mr Sallis would not have simply replied as he did saying he needed to look for the Licence at his mother’s property if he then believed that he owned the Land or had an interest in it.
64. Mr Sallis’s understanding as to his interest or right in the Land is shown by his answers to questions from the Tribunal: he said that it was convenient for the Council to have him on the Land but he knew he was running the risk that the Council might change its mind and he would not be able to stay.
65. I do not find that Mr Sallis believed he had or would be given by the Council a proprietary right in the Land. What he believed was that he could stay on the Land unless and until the Council required him to leave. Conclusions
67. Mr Sallis was in possession of the Land from 2011, having both factual possession and the intention to possess. However, the first condition of paragraph 5 of Schedule 6 to the Land Registration Act 2002 is not satisfied. Mr Sallis did not believe that he had or would be granted an interest in the Land by the Council. If he had had such a belief, it would not have been one encouraged by the Council. Costs
68. The Tribunal has power to award costs in a land registration case. The usual practice of the Tribunal is to order the unsuccessful party to pay the costs of the successful party. I am aware of no reason why the usual rule should not apply in this case. My preliminary view is that Mr Sallis should pay the Council’s costs to be assessed. Any party who wishes to submit that some different order should be made as to costs, should serve written submissions on the Tribunal and on the other party by 28th August 2026. DATED THIS 12th AUGUST 2026 Judge Michael Michell BY ORDER OF THE TRIBUNAL