UK case law
PPT v Independent Television News Limited & Anor
[2026] EWHC KB 2560 · High Court (King's Bench Division) · 2026
The verbatim text of this UK judgment. Sourced directly from The National Archives Find Case Law. Not an AI summary, not a paraphrase — every word below is the original ruling, under Crown copyright and the Open Government Licence v3.0.
Full judgment
Mr Justice Nicklin : A: Introduction
1. This judgment concerns applications for derogations from the principle of open justice. It does not determine the substantive merits of the claim.
2. The Claimant is identified by the cipher “PPT”. By an order made on 5 October 2026, which has been published on the Judiciary website , I directed that the Claimant should be identified in these proceedings by the cipher “PPT”. The order requires the Claimant’s identity to be withheld from the public and imposes reporting restrictions prohibiting the publication of his identity or of any information likely, directly or indirectly, to identify him as the Claimant in these proceedings. https://www.judiciary.uk/judgments/ppt-v-independent-television-news-limited-and-guardian-news-and-media-limited-anonymity-and-reporting-restrictions-order/
3. Pending determination of an application by the Claimant to anonymise the Defendants, the identities of the First and Second Defendants were also temporarily withheld. They were given temporary ciphers of SKG and GVA. That was an interim measure intended to preserve the position until the Court could determine whether their identities should remain withheld.
4. On Monday 5 October 2026, there was a hearing in private to determine the applications concerning anonymity. It was necessary for that hearing to take place in private because a public hearing of the arguments and evidence would itself have disclosed information which the applications sought to protect. I indicated in open court on that day that I would provide a public judgment explaining as much as could safely be disclosed about the proceedings and the applications, without undermining the orders made by the Court.
5. I have concluded that the Claimant must remain anonymous, but that the Defendants should be identified.
6. It is not possible in this public judgment to set out the full background to the applications. To do so would risk disclosing information which the Court has determined should be withheld in order to protect the Claimant’s identity. This judgment therefore explains the nature of the claim, the applicable principles and the reasons for the Court’s decision only to the extent that this can safely be done.
7. Following the hearing on 5 October 2026, a fuller judgment was provided to the parties in private. Nothing in this public judgment should be taken as indicating that the material omitted from it is unimportant. Its omission is necessary to preserve the effectiveness of the orders protecting the Claimant’s identity. B: The claim
8. The Defendants are media organisations. Each has conducted a journalistic investigation into allegations concerning the Claimant’s conduct towards a number of individuals.
9. The proposed publications concern serious allegations about the Claimant’s conduct over a period of years. The matters alleged are said to have arisen in a variety of professional and personal contexts.
10. Before publication, each Defendant notified the Claimant of the substance of the matters which they proposed to publish and invited his response. The Claimant’s case is that the notification and prospect of publication caused a serious deterioration in his mental health, including serious attempts to take his own life and the need for psychiatric treatment.
11. The Claimant contends that publication would expose him to a real and immediate risk of serious harm or death. He relies upon medical evidence and contends that publication would be incompatible with the protection afforded to him by Articles 2 and 3 of the European Convention on Human Rights and, to the extent necessary, Article 8.
12. The Claimant has given a broad denial of the allegations which the Defendants propose to publish.
13. The Defendants resist the claim. They dispute that the legal requirements for a final injunction are satisfied and rely upon their rights under Article 10. They also rely upon the public interest which they contend is served by the proposed publications.
14. The Claimant seeks a final injunction restraining the Defendants from publishing or broadcasting the information which is the subject of their investigations, or substantially similar information. The relief sought is founded upon the Claimant’s case that publication would expose him to a continuing risk to life arising from suicide.
15. The psychiatric issues have been addressed through expert evidence. The nature and degree of the risk relied upon by the Claimant, the legal significance of that risk and the extent to which it can effectively be mitigated are matters for determination at trial.
16. Nothing in this judgment, or in the judgment provided privately to the parties, expresses any conclusion upon those issues. Those matters remain entirely for determination at trial. C: Open justice
17. Open justice is a fundamental constitutional principle and an aspect of the rule of law. Its purposes include enabling public scrutiny of the work of the courts, maintaining confidence in the administration of justice and enabling the media to report court proceedings: A -v- British Broadcasting Corporation [23]–[26]. [2015] AC 588
18. The ordinary position is that hearings take place in public, the parties are named, and judgments and orders are publicly accessible. The identification of the parties is itself an important aspect of open justice. Names provide context and enable reports of proceedings to be concrete and intelligible rather than abstract or disembodied: JIH -v- News Group Newspapers Ltd [21] and [35]–[36]. [2011] 1 WLR 1645
19. The principle is not absolute. The Court has power to withhold or anonymise the identity of a party or witness, and to impose a corresponding reporting restriction, where that derogation from open justice is strictly necessary in the interests of justice: PMC -v- Cwm Taf Morgannwg University Health Board [79]–[89]. [2026] KB 209
20. CPR 39.2(4) requires the Court to order that a person’s identity must not be disclosed if, and only if, non-disclosure is necessary to secure the proper administration of justice and to protect that person’s interests.
21. Where the Court withholds a name or other matter from the public, s.11 Contempt of Court Act 1981 permits it to prohibit publication of that information where this is necessary for the purpose for which it was withheld.
22. A derogation from open justice is not a matter of convenience. The Court must start by according very substantial weight to the principle of open justice. There is a clear presumption in its favour unless that presumption is displaced by a sufficiently powerful countervailing justification: Tickle -v- Surrey County Council [49]; [2025] Fam 105 PMC [91].
23. The burden rests upon the person seeking the derogation. The application must be supported by clear and cogent evidence. The Court must consider whether the protection sought can be achieved through some less restrictive measure. Any derogation must go no further than is necessary to achieve its legitimate purpose: JIH [21]–[22]; Various Claimants -v- Independent Parliamentary Standards Authority [33]–[40]. [2022] EMLR 4
24. Each proposed derogation must be justified separately. The fact that it is necessary to anonymise one party does not establish that every other party, witness or person associated with the proceedings must also be anonymised.
25. The Court must identify the particular interest requiring protection, the nature and likelihood of the harm which disclosure would cause, and the extent to which the proposed restriction would diminish the important public interests served by open justice.
26. Article 8 is a qualified right. Where Articles 8 and 10 are both engaged, neither has automatic precedence. The Court must conduct an intense focus upon the comparative importance of the particular rights in the individual case, the justification for interfering with each of them, and the proportionality of the proposed restriction.
27. An anonymity order is not necessarily deprived of value merely because some individuals know, suspect or may be able to deduce the identity of the person protected by it. An order may continue to provide substantial protection against further or wider dissemination, notwithstanding some residual possibility of identification.
28. Equally, it does not follow that every restriction which would make identification more difficult is necessary. The test is not whether an additional restriction would confer some further protection. It is whether that additional restriction is established by clear and cogent evidence to be necessary and proportionate. D: The Claimant’s anonymity
29. I am satisfied that it is strictly necessary for the identity of the Claimant to be withheld.
30. The nature of the claim means that the proceedings necessarily concern highly sensitive medical evidence and an asserted risk of grave harm. Public identification of the Claimant in connection with these proceedings would connect him with the subject matter of the proposed publications and would risk undermining the effective determination of his claim. Anonymising the Claimant also permits substantially more information about the proceedings and their eventual determination to be made public than would otherwise be possible. In that respect, the order supports, rather than simply restricts, the objectives of open justice.
31. The Defendants do not oppose the continued anonymity of the Claimant. The determination of whether there should be a derogation from open justice is not, however, a matter which can be agreed between the parties. It requires judicial determination.
32. The Claimant will therefore continue to be identified publicly as PPT. The order I have made prohibits publication of: i) the Claimant’s identity; ii) the fact that any named individual is PPT or the Claimant in these proceedings; and iii) any matter likely, directly or indirectly, to identify him as the Claimant in these proceedings.
33. Public versions of documents filed in the proceedings must be prepared so as to comply with that order. Information likely, directly or indirectly, to identify PPT as the Claimant must be withheld or expressed in suitable neutral terms.
34. The fact that the order may not eliminate every possibility of private knowledge, speculation or deduction does not mean that it fails to provide substantial and effective protection for the Claimant’s interests. The reporting restrictions prohibit anyone from publishing the Claimant’s identity, or information likely, directly or indirectly, to identify him as the Claimant in these proceedings. E: The Defendants’ identities
35. The Claimant submits that the identities of the Defendants should also be withheld. He contends that identifying them would materially weaken the protection afforded by his own anonymity and could assist some people in identifying him. The Claimant does not contend that identification of the Defendants would itself create or materially increase a risk of serious injury or death so as to engage Articles 2 or 3. His application to anonymise the Defendants is instead founded upon the interference with his Article 8 rights which, he submits, their identification would cause.
36. I accept that withholding the Defendants’ identities would provide the Claimant with some additional protection against identification or speculation. The question, however, is not whether anonymity for the Defendants would provide any additional protection. Almost any further suppression of information would make identification more difficult.
37. The issue is whether the substantial additional derogation from open justice which the Claimant seeks is shown by clear and cogent evidence to be necessary and proportionate for the protection of his Article 8 rights.
38. Anonymising a defendant is a serious step. It is particularly serious in this case because the Defendants are media organisations whose identities and journalistic activities form an important part of the factual and legal context of the claim.
39. The nature of the investigations undertaken by the Defendants, their editorial and journalistic processes, and the conduct of those working for them may well form part of the evidence at trial.
40. The Claimant advances criticisms of aspects of the Defendants’ investigations. The Defendants rely upon their journalistic experience and decision-making in resisting the claim. An intelligible public account of the parties’ competing cases would be made materially more difficult if the Defendants could not be identified.
41. Anonymity for the Defendants would also have significant consequential effects. It would be likely to require the Court to prevent the identification of journalists, editors and other witnesses whose names or positions would reveal the organisations for which they work.
42. That would severely constrain the evidence and submissions which could be heard or reported in public. It might require substantial parts of the trial to be conducted in an abstract and artificial form, or possibly in private, simply to preserve the anonymity of the Defendant organisations.
43. Those are not incidental consequences. They would affect the ability of the public and the media to understand the nature of the claim, the conduct challenged, the competing rights asserted and the Court’s reasons for its eventual decision.
44. The Claimant already benefits from substantial protection. He is identified by a cipher; public versions of documents must not identify him; identifying material is protected from public access; and the reporting restriction prohibits publication of his identity or of information likely, directly or indirectly, to identify him as the Claimant.
45. Those measures cannot eliminate every possibility of private speculation or deduction. That is not the applicable test. The question is whether the evidence establishes that those measures are insufficient and that anonymity for the Defendants is therefore strictly necessary.
46. I am not satisfied that the Claimant has established by clear and cogent evidence that the existing measures are insufficient or that anonymity for the Defendants is strictly necessary.
47. The additional protection which withholding the Defendants’ identities would provide is limited. It does not justify the substantial derogation from open justice which their anonymity would entail, including the severe constraints which it would be likely to impose upon the conduct and reporting of the trial. Nor would the limited additional protection be proportionate to that interference with open justice.
48. The application to withhold the Defendants’ identities is therefore refused. The Defendants will be identified publicly by their corporate names. F: The trial
49. The claim has been expedited. The trial is listed to take place on 27 and 28 October 2026.
50. There will be a pre-trial review on 16 October 2026. At that hearing, the Court will consider how the trial should be managed and whether any further derogations from open justice are strictly necessary.
51. The starting point will be that the trial should take place in public.
52. Any party contending that a particular part of the trial must be heard in private, or that particular evidence or information must be withheld from the public, will be required to identify with precision: i) the evidence or submission which cannot safely be given in public; ii) the harm which would result from publicity; iii) why the existing anonymity and reporting restrictions are insufficient; and iv) why the necessary protection cannot be achieved by a less restrictive measure.
53. The Court will consider whether any necessary protection can be afforded through the careful use of ciphers, targeted redactions, reporting restrictions, controlled disclosure of evidence or other measures falling short of excluding the public.
54. No decision has yet been made as to whether any part of the trial will be heard in private, what evidence or information may be reported, or the form in which particular witnesses or information may be identified publicly. G: Disposal
55. For those reasons: i) the Court has directed that the Claimant’s identity must be withheld from the public in connection with these proceedings and that he is to be identified publicly as PPT; ii) the Court has imposed reporting restrictions prohibiting publication of PPT’s identity or of information likely, directly or indirectly, to identify him as the Claimant in these proceedings; iii) public versions of documents from the proceedings must be prepared so as not to identify PPT; iv) the Claimant’s application to withhold the identities of the Defendants is refused, and the Defendants may be identified publicly by their corporate names; and v) all questions concerning the conduct and reporting of the trial, including whether any further derogation from open justice is necessary, are reserved for consideration at the pre-trial review on 16 October 2026.