UK case law

R v Tamim Ahmed

[2026] EWHC SCCO 2573 · High Court (Senior Court Costs Office) · 2026

Get your free legal insight →Email to a colleague
Get your free legal insight on this case →

The verbatim text of this UK judgment. Sourced directly from The National Archives Find Case Law. Not an AI summary, not a paraphrase — every word below is the original ruling, under Crown copyright and the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Full judgment

Background

1. On 27 November 2021 police officers in Newcastle stopped a vehicle in which the Defendant (Applicant in the appeal to the Court of Appeal) was a rear-seat passenger, based on concerns as to how the vehicle was being driven.

2. The Defendant fled the vehicle but was soon after detained, searched and found to be in possession of cocaine in the form of a large rock of white powder and five snap bags of white powder, plus three mobile phones and £832.62 in cash. The total value of the drugs seized was £1,250.

3. A black Nokia phone seized from the Defendant was found to contain 76 text messages evidencing onward supply to others including references to dropping off, “Do you have any K?” and “Are you about to do a 20 drop at an address in Jesmond?”

4. At a subsequent police interview the Defendant gave a prepared statement saying that the drugs were for personal use, explaining he had bought them from a dealer and that he ran from the police because although he was not a drug dealer, he knew that he would be arrested as such.

5. The Defendant said that the cash was earnings from lawful employment and had been intended as a Christmas present for his family.

6. No comment was then offered for any questions beyond the Defendant’s statement.

7. The Defendant later pleaded guilty on the basis that he was a drug user who had fallen into debt with his dealer and was engaged in selling drugs to reduce his debt.

8. On 13 September 2023 in the Crown Court at Newcastle Upon Tyne the Defendant pleaded guilty to Possessing a Controlled Drug of Class A with Intent contrary to s.5(3) Misuse of Drugs Act 1971 .

9. On 15 February 2024 the Defendant was sentenced to 27 months’ imprisonment.

10. On 13th March 2024 the appealed against sentence with grounds of appeal prepared by Mr Hedworth, who appeals the remuneration decision of Criminal Appeal Office. Claim

11. The Appellant claimed 5 hours 50 minutes for “Preparation of Advice & Grounds of Appeal- Completion of Forms NG and B; Consideration of transcripts obtained by Court of Appeal”, “Legal research”, and “Preparation of oral submissions in advance of abandoned hearing before Full Court”, at a rate of £150/hr amounting to a total claim of £875 plus VAT.

12. By way of e-mails in March and April 2025, the Appellant was advised that the time had been allowed as claimed but at a rate of £75/hr, a decision which the Appellant first challenged on 15 April 2025. Relevant Legislation

13. The Criminal Legal Aid (Remuneration) Regulations 2013, schedule 3, paragraph 1 provides: “1. —(1) The provisions of this Schedule apply to proceedings in the Court of Appeal. (2) In determining fees the appropriate officer must, subject to the provisions of this Schedule— (a) take into account all the relevant circumstances of the case including the nature, importance, complexity or difficulty of the work and the time involved; and (b) allow a reasonable amount in respect of all work actually and reasonably done.” Submissions

14. The Respondent has confirmed they do not wish to attend the hearing of this appeal and have not submitted any written submissions for the hearing.

15. They rely on the response to the Appellant's request for redetermination dated 17 July 2025, in which the Determining Officer stated: “However, £150 per hour as claimed was considered a bit high on this Sentence appeal, where counsel was well familiar with the relevant facts and issues on appeal having acted below. About £75 per hour was allowed on this matter, which was considered commensurate with the level of responsibility presented by the facts and issues involved in this matter, given counsel’s familiarity with the relevant issues as stated.”

16. On 21 July 2025 the Appellant requested written reasons, citing his representation of “.. a young man who had never been sent to prison before and his entire life had been crushed. He was his parents’ carer and so the appeal had to be done urgently.”

17. The Appellant argued that a rate of £75hr “is the sort of rate a pupil barrister in the magistrates would be paid to do a road traffic trial in his second six pupillage, not the preparation of Appellate work in the Court of Appeal”, and that a rate of “£150 per hour.. is a fraction of the hourly rate that would be claimed on a private basis for work of this nature. It is submitted that the hourly rate claimed was reasonable.”

18. Accordingly the Appellant sought written reasons.

19. The Respondent relies on their written reasons dated 17 October 2025 as their comprehensive response as to why the request for redetermination remained refused. No further written submissions have been produced by the Defendant.

20. The Appellant’s Notice and supporting documents express concern as to the approach adopted by the Respondent in considering the Appellant’s fees claim, suggesting that a generic approach had been applied which failed to have proper regard for the work he had undertaken and all relevant circumstances.

21. Mr Hedworth, the Appellant, appeared on his own behalf remotely. He further expressed his concern, via oral submissions, as to the approach adopted by the Respondent in considering his fees claim, suggesting that a generic approach had been applied which failed to have proper regard for the work he had undertaken and all relevant circumstances.

22. He also expressed concern that the Respondent had allowed for hourly rates which were much less than those regularly allowed in similar costs appeals in the SCCO, and failed to account for the economic reality of work done in the period covered. Analysis and decision

23. The underlying case facts are set out above.

24. Whilst the Appellant pragmatically accepts this was not the most complex or difficult of cases, I accept that the Senior Courts Costs Office has consistently recognised that advocates instructed in the Court of Appeal have a greater level of responsibility placed on them than when appearing in any of the divisions of the lower courts.

25. I also concur that there is an irreducible minimum amount of time one requires to prepare arguments for the Court of Appeal regardless of prior familiarity with the case.

26. In any event, citing prior familiarity is not sufficient without also recognising that the nature of an appeal to the criminal division of the Court of Appeal is different from the hearing of the original convictions.

27. In this appeal, the time claimed is not in dispute. This comes as no surprise because the time claimed is modest. However, I simply comment that if prior familiarity was to have any bearing on a remuneration claim then it would be to the time spent, not the rate applicable.

28. Time spent has the potential to reduce the time to be spent. However, time spent cannot reduce the complexity, value, importance, or wider implications of a case.

29. In terms of rates, the Appellant relies on Evans and others v Serious Fraud Office [2015] EWHC 1525 (QB) . He is not seeking £240 per hour and recognises the distinctions to be drawn between Evans and the index matter. However, the Appellant relies on the fact he is more senior than the junior in Evans , and that the Evans decision is over 10 years old.

30. It is in that context that the Appellant pleads a rate of £150 per hour to be reasonable. I accept that the £75 per hour permitted should be departed from but not to the extent pleaded.

31. Whilst the appeal of sentence was of no doubt important to an offender who had never been to prison before, and was the main carer for his parents, this is not a level of importance which is sufficient to justify the rate claimed, even for preparation for an appeal to the Court of Appeal.

32. The underlying case facts were otherwise accepted and uncomplicated, relating to offending that was of low value, and thus providing for clear points of appeal to be taken against sentencing.

33. I consider £140 per hour to be appropriate in this matter.

34. Thus given the agreement to 5 hours and 50 minutes, applied at £140/hr, I allow the appeal in the sum of £816.67 plus VAT and direct that the balance be paid to the Appellant. Costs

35. The Appellant seeks £800 in costs plus the appeal fee of £100, citing his preparation time and rearrangement of his diary. The latter reason is not a sound basis for the costs of the appeal save for where the SCCO was approached to consider hearing the appeal at a different time or date and refused. I am not aware of any such request but would have been prepared to consider the same.

36. I will allow £700 for the costs of the appeal on a fully inclusive basis. COSTS JUDGE NAGALINGAM

R v Tamim Ahmed [2026] EWHC SCCO 2573 — UK case law · My AI Judge