UK case law

Robert Graham Tearle v Registrar of Approved Driving Instructors

[2026] UKFTT GRC 1399 · First-tier Tribunal (General Regulatory Chamber) – Transport · 2026

Get your free legal insight →Email to a colleague
Get your free legal insight on this case →

The verbatim text of this UK judgment. Sourced directly from The National Archives Find Case Law. Not an AI summary, not a paraphrase — every word below is the original ruling, under Crown copyright and the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Full judgment

Decision

1. The appeal is REFUSED. MODE OF HEARING

2. The proceedings were held using CVP. The tribunal was satisfied that it was fair and just to conduct the hearing this way.

3. The hearing was conducted by a Judge, sitting alone. The Tribunal was satisfied that it was appropriate to conduct the hearing in this way.

4. The Appellant did not participate in the remote oral hearing. In section 10 of his Notice of Appeal, the Appellant ticked a box to indicate that he wanted his appeal to be heard without a hearing. There was no representative from the office of the Registrar. BACKGROUND

5. This appeal is from a trainee driving instructor who was granted two trainee licences under s.129 of the Road Traffic Act 1988 (“ the Act ”) and was then refused a further licence at the end of the twelve months’ period. A licence under s.129(1) is granted “for the purpose of enabling a person to acquire practical experience in giving instruction in driving motor cars with a view to undergoing ….. such part of the examination ….. as consists of a practical test of ability and fitness to instruct”.

6. The circumstances in which trainee licences may be granted are set out in s.129 of the Act and in the Motor Cars (Driving Instruction) Regulations 2005 (“the Regulations”). In order to qualify as an approved driving instructor an applicant must pass the qualifying examination, which is in three parts: the written examination; the driving ability and fitness test; and the instructional ability and fitness test (see reg.3(2)). Each part must be passed in the stated order and before the next part is attempted. Three attempts at each part are permitted but the whole examination must be completed within two years of passing the written examination (but subject to reg.3(4)(c) which permits a further attempt at the Part Three test outside the period if the booking was made within it). Failure so to complete requires the whole examination to be retaken. A trainee licence may be granted under s.129 of the Act once the driving ability and fitness test has been passed. The holding of a trainee licence is not a prerequisite to qualification; on the contrary, many applicants qualify without having held such a licence.

3. It is self-evident that the grant of a trainee licence enables applicants to instruct for payment before they are qualified. The Appellant did so and failed to pass the instructional ability and fitness test within the twelve months’ period. The Appellant applied for a further licence prior to the end of this period and by s.129(6) of the Act “where a person applies for a new licence in substitution for a licence held by him and current at the date of application, the previous licence shall not expire ….. until ….. an appeal is finally disposed of”. The effect of this is that the Appellant has been able to continue to instruct under his licence, despite the expiry dates. Of course, if prior to disposal of the appeal he passes the instructional ability and fitness test, he then ceases to be a trainee and is no longer eligible for a further trainee licence. If on the other hand he fails this test after three attempts, the appeal is itself also bound to fail since by reg.13(2)(d) of the Regulations a further trainee licence may not be granted if the instructional ability and fitness test has been failed “more than twice”.

4. I am aware that when applicants apply for a trainee licence, they sign an application form, which includes a declaration that they have read the Department’s ‘Approved Driving Instructor (ADI) Register Guide’, which is available online. This Guide contains the following advice: “Tell DVSA if you stop using your trainee licence. This will count in your favour if you need to apply for another licence.”

5. The Registrar gave the following general reasons for refusal: “(i) The purpose of the provisions governing the issue of licences is to afford applicants the opportunity of giving instruction to members of the public whilst endeavouring to achieve registration. The system of issuing licences is not and must not be allowed to become an alternative to the system of registration; (ii) The licence granted to applicants is not to enable the instructor to teach for however long it takes to pass the examinations, but to allow up to six months experience of instruction. This provides a very reasonable period in which to reach the qualifying standard in the examination and, in particular, to obtain any necessary practical experience in tuition. (iii) The Appellant has already had two trainee licences which cover a period of twelve months. Moreover, by virtue of the Appellant having applied for a third licence before the expiry date of the second, that licence has remained in force to the present time and will allow him to continue to give paid instruction until determination of the appeal.”

6. In addition, the Registrar added further reasons which were specific to the individual case. Those discrete reasons are set out in below

7. Two licences were granted to the Appellant under section 129 of the Act for the purposes of enabling him to undergo the examination of his ability to give instruction in the driving of motor cars and were valid from 17 March 2025 to 16 March 2026. On 2 March 2026 the Registrar received an application from the Appellant for a third licence. Following notification to the Appellant that the Registrar was considering the refusal of his application for the third licence, the Appellant made representations to the Registrar. After considering those representations, the Registrar decided to refuse the application and notified the Appellant of that decision by way of correspondence dated 21 April 2026. The Appellant has appealed against the decision dated 21 April 2026.

8. In his notice of appeal, the Appellant indicated that he did not wish to attend the oral hearing of his appeal but wished the Tribunal to consider the appeal on the papers alone.

9. In the Statement of Case the Registrar has set out the reasons for the refusal of the application. These included the general reasons set out in paragraph 5 and the following reasons specific to this Appellant: - Since passing his driving ability test the Appellant has failed the instructional ability test twice. Despite ample time and opportunity the Appellant has not been able to reach the required standard for qualification as an Approved Driving Instructor; and - The refusal of a third licence does not bar the Appellant from attempting the instructional ability test of the Register examinations. He does not need to hold a licence for that purpose, nor is it essential for him to give professional tuition under licence in order to obtain further training. The Appellant could attend a training course, or study and practice with an Approved Driving Instructor or give tuition on his own (provided that he does not receive payment of any kind for this). These alternatives are used by some trainees who acquire registration without obtaining any licences at all.

10. I have a copy of the DSA print-out, which shows that the Appellant failed the Part III test on 18 July 2025 and 16 October 2025. The Appellant had made a booking to take the Part III test on 17 August 2026, but it is not known whether the Appellant took the test on that date and, if he did, what the outcome was.

11. In his notice of appeal, the Appellant made the following submissions: ‘As you may see from my records, I have thus far taken two attempts at Part 3. My first attempt was taken too early, and I should have sought a mock test or observed lessons which were not available to me at the time under my original training establishment. I booked my second attempt but at that time was not satisfied with the level or training I was receiving and began to change trainer who is now my current training provider and franchise company. At around the time or my second attempt my wile had to reduce her work hours to half her normal due to ill health. In addition to the increase in financial burden falling on me, my former training establishment sought recompense for lost franchise fee and threatened me with court proceedings for a sum that amounted to everything I had in savings at that time. I sat my second attempt whilst under the cloud of stress from these situations in my personal life and failed again. In the last five months I have tried to rebuild my confidence, sought expert training in the form of observed live lessons and my trainer has reported a huge improvement in the quality of my lesson delivery. I now feel ready to try again much more confident in my ability to deliver a safe, value for money, constructive and informative lesson. I have booked to hold for test in early May leaving time lor one more training session. The feedback from my examiner was very positive and highlighted the areas for improvement very clearly. Since then I have worked very hard to deal with these problem areas. With hindsight I should have cancelled the second attempt and booked again for when those pressures had abated as they are now beginning to do so. I was, at that time, concerned about the wait times for testing that I had previously experienced. I cannot provide evidence or missed time as such and I do not consider all of my time under my original training provider as lost time as I did receive 60 hours of instructional training. However, I was then left to my own devices for 6 months unaware that I was not working to the best of my potential. Now that I have sought this additional training I believe I have rectified the faults that were allowed to exist under my original training establishment. Please consider the aforementioned reasons for the award of a third training badge.’

12. The submissions made by the Appellant in his notice of appeal reflect parallel submissions made by him in his written representations to the Registrar. REASONS

13. As at the date of this decision the Appellant had had the benefit of a Trainee Licence for over 18 months. In my judgment he has now had more than enough time in which to gain practical experience in giving instruction.

14. In his notice of appeal and written representations to the Registrar, the Appellant has indicated that he had booked and an appointment for and taken his first attempt at the Part III examination ‘too early’.

15. There was, in my view, a clear learning point from that miscalculation. The Appellant should have ensured that when he made an appointment to take the Part III examination for the second time that he was ready to do so and had undertaken the necessary training in preparation. The Appellant has submitted that to undertake the necessary preparation, he had changed his training provider. I return below to the training which was undertake.

16. The Appellant asserts that having made a booking to take the test for the second time, two factors impinged on his working life. The first was that his wife had to reduce her own working hours due to ill health, thereby imposing an increase on the financial burden falling on him. He submits that his financial concerns were exacerbated by his former training establishment seeking recompense for a lost franchise fee and that he was the subject of a threat of court proceedings for a sum which equated to the total sum of his savings.

17. I have noted that the Appellant has not provided any additional evidence in connection with these two factors and has not participated in the oral hearing to provide further detail. Even if the evidence which he has provided is accepted, the obvious course of action was for the Appellant to cancel the appointment for the second attempt at the Part III examination and refocus on his training and other preparation. That is an outcome which the Appellant now accepts was appropriate.

18. I return to the nature and amount of training which the Appellant has undertaken to date. In the email correspondence dated 21 April from the Registrar to the Appellant and in which the Appellant was informed that his application for a third trainee licence had been refused, the Registrar stated: ‘He (the Registrar) came to this conclusion because no evidence has been provided for to support lack of pupils or practice time.’

19. In his notice of appeal, the Appellant addresses the Registrar’s statement as follows: ‘I cannot provide evidence provide evidence or missed time as such and I do not consider all of my time under my original training provider as lost time as I did receive 60 hours of instructional training.’

20. This is, in my view, a significant amount of training, which the Appellant considers was not lost, and, as such, must have been to his benefit. In addition, the Appellant has had the benefit of training provision from a new training provider, and a trainee licence, at least from the date of his failure of the Part III examination at the second attempt. Further, the Appellant has stated: ‘However, I was then left to my own devices for 6 months unaware that I was not working to the best of my potential.’

21. There is no further detail provided by the Appellant as to why he felt that he was ‘unaware’ that he was not working to his potential. Further, there is action which the Appellant could have taken. As noted above, I am aware that when applicants apply for a trainee licence, they sign an application form, which includes a declaration that they have read the Department’s ‘Approved Driving Instructor (ADI) Register Guide’, which is available online. This Guide contains the following advice: “Tell DVSA if you stop using your trainee licence. This will count in your favour if you need to apply for another licence.”

22. The Appellant chose not to return his licence.

23. The Appellant’s notice of appeal is dated 22 April 2026. In his grounds of appeal, the Appellant has stated that due to additional training, he had ‘rectified the faults that were allowed to exist under my original training establishment.’ This suggests that he was, at that stage, ready to undertake the Part III examination for a third time. Indeed, he had stated that he had ‘booked to hold’ for a Part III examination in May 2026 ‘… leaving me for one more training session’. There is no evidence from the Registrar that the Appellant undertook a Part III examination in May 2026. In addition, the Appellant stated: ‘In the last five months I have tried to rebuild my confidence, sought expert training in the form of observed live lessons and my trainer has reported a huge improvement in the quality of my lesson delivery. I now feel ready to try again much more confident in my ability to deliver a safe, value for money, constructive and informative lesson.

24. I have already noted that the Appellant had made an appointment to undertake the Part III examination on 17 August 2026, but it is not known whether the Appellant took the test on that date and, if he did, what the outcome was.

25. It is clear, however, that the appointment was not taken up. As was noted in paragraph 3 above, if prior to disposal of the appeal, the Appellant passes the instructional ability and fitness test, he then ceases to be a trainee and is no longer eligible for a further trainee licence. If on the other hand he fails this test after three attempts, the appeal is itself also bound to fail since by reg.13(2)(d) of the Regulations a further trainee licence may not be granted if the instructional ability and fitness test has been failed “more than twice”. The Registrar has not noted the Tribunal of either of those outcomes.

26. As was noted by the Registrar, the refusal of a second licence does not bar the Appellant from attempting the instructional ability test of the Register examinations. He does not need to hold a licence for that purpose, nor is it essential for him to give professional tuition under licence to obtain further training. The Appellant could attend a training course, or study and practice with an Approved Driving Instructor or give tuition on his own (if he does not receive payment of any kind for this). These alternatives are used by some trainees who acquire registration without obtaining any licences at all.

27. I have given a degree of credit to the Appellant for his stated commitment to a career as a professional ADI.

28. I uphold the Registrar’s decision and accept and endorse the reasons given for that decision by the Registrar as set out in the Statement of Case. Accordingly, the appeal is refused with immediate effect. Kenneth Mullan Judge of the Upper Tribunal 9 October 2026

Robert Graham Tearle v Registrar of Approved Driving Instructors [2026] UKFTT GRC 1399 — UK case law · My AI Judge