UK case law
Social Care Wales v Anthony Balogun
[2026] UKFTT HESC 1340 · Care Standards · 2026
The verbatim text of this UK judgment. Sourced directly from The National Archives Find Case Law. Not an AI summary, not a paraphrase — every word below is the original ruling, under Crown copyright and the Open Government Licence v3.0.
Full judgment
The Application
1. This is an application by Social Care Wales pursuant to section 148 of the Regulation and Inspection of Social Care (Wales) Act 2016, to extend the Interim Suspension Order imposed upon the Respondent, Anthony Balogun, on 4 April 2025. The Interim Suspension Order was imposed for a period of 18 months and is due to expire on 3 October 2026. The Applicant seeks an extension of the order until 3 October 2027. The application arises in the context of ongoing criminal proceedings against the Respondent, which are currently listed for trial before Swansea Crown Court on 22 February 2027. Social Care Wales submits that continuation of the order remains necessary for the protection of the public and otherwise in the public interest pending the conclusion of the criminal proceedings and any subsequent fitness to practise process. Attendance
2. The Applicant was represented by Ms Phillips, Solicitor, and relied upon the evidence of Mrs Suzanne Simcock, Senior Fitness to Practise Officer at Social Care Wales, who adopted her witness statement and answered questions from the Tribunal. The Respondent did not attend and was not represented. We were satisfied that the Respondent had been given proper notice of both the application and the hearing. The evidence before us was that Social Care Wales notified the Respondent of its intention to make this application on 4 August 2026 and subsequently corresponded with him regarding the application on 7 September 2026, 9 September 2026 and 17 September 2026. The Tribunal also provided notice of the hearing using the Respondent's registered email address held by Social Care Wales.
3. Having considered rule 27 and all the circumstances of the case, including the absence of any request for an adjournment or explanation for non-attendance, we concluded that the Respondent was more likely than not aware of the proceedings. We further concluded that an adjournment was unlikely to secure his attendance on a future occasion. We were therefore satisfied that it was fair and in the interests of justice to proceed in his absence. Tribunal bundle and documentary evidence
4. The Tribunal was provided with an electronic hearing bundle comprising approximately 303 pages. The bundle included the application and supporting evidence of Social Care Wales, the witness statement and exhibits of Mrs Suzanne Simcock, the determinations of the Interim Orders Panels, correspondence relating to the criminal proceedings, safeguarding materials, and the Applicant's skeleton argument. We considered all of the material contained within the bundle, together with the oral submissions of Ms Phillips and the oral evidence of Mrs Simcock, insofar as relevant to the issues arising on this application. Background
5. The Respondent, Anthony Balogun, first registered with Social Care Wales as an Adult Care Home Worker on 27 September 2023. At the material time he was employed by HC One Limited as a Direct Care-Carer.
6. On 29 December 2023, the Respondent was suspended by his employer following allegations that he had sexually harassed and sexually assaulted a female colleague whilst at work. The matter was referred to Social Care Wales on 2 January 2024 and a Fitness to Practise case was opened on 23 February 2024. The Respondent subsequently contacted Social Care Wales via its online portal regarding his suspension and employment status.
7. The allegations were reported to Dyfed Powys Police, which commenced a criminal investigation. The Respondent attended a voluntary police interview on 26 February 2024 and denied the allegations. On 20 December 2024 the Crown Prosecution Service authorised a charge of sexual assault by touching. The Respondent subsequently entered a not guilty plea and criminal proceedings remain ongoing.
8. In parallel with the criminal investigation, Carmarthenshire Council undertook safeguarding enquiries under its safeguarding and Person in a Position of Trust procedures. A professional strategy meeting was held on 13 January 2025. The minutes of that meeting were subsequently disclosed to Social Care Wales on 3 March 2026 and recorded a unanimous decision to substantiate the allegations.
9. On 4 April 2025, a Social Care Wales Interim Orders Panel imposed an Interim Suspension Order for a period of 18 months on the grounds that it was necessary for the protection of the public and otherwise in the public interest. The order was subsequently reviewed on 3 October 2025 and 31 March 2026 and was continued on both occasions.
10. The Tribunal also heard evidence concerning a subsequent issue relating to a request for a reference associated with the Respondent. Concerns were raised that a reference may have been sought through an inappropriate route. No findings have been made in relation to that matter and the evidence before us was that it remains separate from the principal allegations which gave rise to these proceedings.
11. The criminal proceedings have not yet concluded. The trial originally listed for 20 October 2025 was relisted to 29 June 2026 and subsequently vacated owing to a lack of court space. The matter is now listed before Swansea Crown Court on 22 February 2027. Legal Framework
12. This application is made pursuant to section 148 of the Regulation and Inspection of Social Care (Wales) Act 2016. In determining the application, we have applied the principles set out in GMC v Hiew [2007] EWCA Civ 369 . We remind ourselves that the Tribunal acts as the primary decision-maker and is not a rubber stamp for the Applicant's views. The question for the Tribunal is whether continuation of the Interim Suspension Order remains justified on the grounds of public protection, the public interest, or the interests of the Respondent. In making that assessment, we have considered the seriousness of the allegations, the nature of the evidence, the reasons why the substantive proceedings have not been concluded, the views previously expressed by the Interim Orders Panels, and the prejudice to the Respondent arising from continued suspension. We further remind ourselves that our function is not to determine the truth or falsity of the allegations but to assess whether the allegations, and the circumstances of the case, justify the continuation of the interim order pending final determination. Evidence
13. At the hearing we heard oral submissions from Ms Phillips on behalf of the Applicant and oral evidence from Mrs Suzanne Simcock, Senior Fitness to Practise Officer at Social Care Wales, who adopted her witness statement and exhibits. Mrs Simcock was questioned by the Tribunal regarding the progress of the criminal proceedings, the reasons why Social Care Wales had not advanced its own substantive investigation whilst those proceedings remained ongoing, the effect of the Carmarthenshire Council safeguarding process, the significance of the reference request issue, and the likely future timetable following either a conviction or an acquittal. We also considered the Applicant's written application, the witness evidence, the previous Interim Orders Panel determinations, the safeguarding materials, and all other relevant documents contained within the bundle.
14. Mrs Simcock confirmed that there had been no material change in circumstances since the Interim Suspension Order was imposed and that, in the Applicant's assessment, the risk previously identified remained. She explained that Social Care Wales had not progressed its substantive fitness to practise investigation whilst the criminal proceedings remained ongoing because it did not wish to interfere with that process and was awaiting disclosure arising from the criminal investigation. She further explained the separate role of the Carmarthenshire Council safeguarding process and confirmed that, whilst the safeguarding findings formed part of the available information, Social Care Wales was not bound by them and would undertake its own independent assessment. Mrs Simcock also addressed the concerns arising from the reference request, indicating that no conclusions had been reached regarding that issue and that the principal concern remained the allegations which are the subject of the criminal proceedings.
15. Mrs Simcock explained that the most extended timetable would arise if the Respondent were acquitted. In that event, Social Care Wales would be required first to obtain disclosure following the conclusion of the criminal proceedings, a process which she estimated could take approximately two months. Thereafter, Social Care Wales would need to undertake its own investigation, including obtaining witness evidence and preparing the evidential bundle. The bundle would then be provided to the Respondent, who would be entitled to 28 days in which to provide representations. Following consideration of any representations, a decision would be required as to whether the matter should be referred to a Fitness to Practise Panel. If referred, charges would need to be drafted, a pre-hearing review arranged, and the Respondent given the requisite notice of any substantive hearing. Mrs Simcock's evidence was that, even on an efficient timetable with little slippage, those steps would likely take the matter through to the autumn of 2027. The Tribunal’s analysis, conclusions and findings. Public Protection and Public Interest
16. We are satisfied that continuation of the Interim Suspension Order remains necessary for the protection of the public and is otherwise in the public interest. We have given appropriate weight to the conclusions previously reached by the Interim Orders Panels, whilst undertaking our own independent assessment of the application before us. The allegations remain serious, the criminal proceedings remain unresolved, and there is no evidence before us that the level of risk identified by the original Interim Orders Panel has diminished since the order was imposed. We accept Mrs Simcock's evidence that no information has emerged which would justify a different assessment of risk and that the position remains materially unchanged from that considered by the previous review panels. In those circumstances, we are satisfied that unrestricted practice would give rise to an unacceptable risk and that public confidence in the social care profession and its regulatory framework would be undermined were the order not continued pending final resolution of the allegations. The Carmarthenshire Safeguarding Investigation and Reference Request
17. We have considered the safeguarding investigation undertaken by Carmarthenshire Council, including the safeguarding outcome which recorded a unanimous safeguarding decision that the allegations were substantiated. We accept the evidence of Mrs Simcock that the safeguarding process is separate from the regulatory process and that Social Care Wales is not bound by the conclusions reached by the safeguarding authorities. Whilst we have considered those materials as part of the factual background, we do not regard them as determinative of this application, and they have not played a material part in our decision-making. Similarly, we considered the evidence concerning the request for a reference associated with the Respondent. We accept the evidence that no findings have been made in relation to that matter and that it may ultimately prove to be entirely innocent. We therefore place little weight upon it. To be clear, our conclusion that the Interim Suspension Order should continue would have been the same regardless of both the safeguarding outcome and the reference issue. The determinative factors remain the seriousness of the allegations, the unresolved criminal proceedings, and the absence of any evidence that the previously identified risk has reduced. Duration of the Extension
18. We gave particularly careful consideration to the duration of any extension. We remind ourselves that, consistent with the principles in GMC v Hiew, the Tribunal is not a rubber stamp and must be satisfied that the period sought is justified on the evidence before it. Initially, we were concerned that the written application identified the procedural steps remaining to be completed but did not fully explain why the full twelve-month extension sought was necessary. We therefore explored that issue in detail with Mrs Simcock. Having done so, we accepted her evidence that, particularly in the event of an acquittal, Social Care Wales would require time to obtain disclosure, undertake its own investigation, obtain witness evidence, prepare and disclose an evidential bundle, receive and consider any representations from the Respondent, determine whether referral to a Fitness to Practise Panel was appropriate and, if so, comply with the procedural requirements for arranging a hearing. We found that anticipated timetable to be realistic and reasonable and accepted that, particularly in the event of an acquittal, those steps could not realistically be completed before autumn 2027. In those circumstances, and notwithstanding that the statutory review provisions will continue to apply during the extended period, we concluded that an extension until 3 October 2027 is proportionate and necessary. Overall conclusion
19. Accordingly, we are satisfied that continuation of the Interim Suspension Order remains necessary for the protection of the public and otherwise in the public interest. Decision
1. The Tribunal grants the application made by Social Care Wales.
2. Pursuant to section 148 of the Regulation and Inspection of Social Care (Wales) Act 2016, the Interim Suspension Order imposed upon Anthony Balogun on 4 April 2025 is extended until 3 October 2027. District Tribunal Judge D Hyland First-tier Tribunals (Care Standards & Primary Health Lists) 22 September 2026