UK case law
The Applicants and Appellants in the Post Prudential Closure Notice Applications/Appeals Group Litigation v The Commissioners for HMRC
[2026] UKFTT TC 1435 · First-tier Tribunal (Tax Chamber) · 2026
The verbatim text of this UK judgment. Sourced directly from The National Archives Find Case Law. Not an AI summary, not a paraphrase — every word below is the original ruling, under Crown copyright and the Open Government Licence v3.0.
Full judgment
Introduction
1. By its decision in HMRC v The Applicants in the Post Prudential Closure Notice Applications Group Litigation [2025] 1 WLR 4463 (the “ CA Decision ”), the Court of Appeal (“ CA ”) formally remitted the appeals of the Applicants in the Post Prudential Closure Notice Applications Group Litigation and the Appellants in the Post Prudential Closure Notice Appeals Group Litigation (collectively the “ Taxpayers ”) to the First-tier Tribunal (“ FTT ”) for it to “make the detailed decisions required in relation to the individual appeals and closure notice applications, in accordance with the conclusions” reached by the Court of Appeal (see [239] CA Decision).
2. Paragraph five of the CA’s order states: “The Taxpayers’ individual appeals and closure notice applications previously determined as the eight test cases in these proceedings by the First-tier Tribunal shall be remitted to the First-tier Tribunal for it to make the decisions required in accordance with the conclusions of the Court of Appeal in its judgment handed down on 25 February 2025.”
3. The eight test cases (the “ Test Cases ”) to which the CA referred in its order are as follows: Closure Notice Applications (1) Schroder Asian Income Fund (“ Schroder Asian ”) for the accounting periods ending (“ APEs ”) 31 January 1991 and 15 January 2009; (2) Avon Insurance plc (“ Avon ”) for the APEs 31 December 1997 to 31 December 2003 inclusive; and (3) Baillie Gifford American Fund (“ Baillie Gifford ” ) for the APE 30 April 2005. Appeals (4) SLMM European Equity Fund (“ SLMM ”) for the APEs 31 March 2004, 31 March 2005 and 31 March 2006; (5) Schroder European Fund (“ Schroder European ”) for the APE 15 January 2003; (6) Schroder Institutional Growth Fund (“ Schroder Institutional Growth ”) for the APE 30 June 2004; (7) Fidelity UK Index Fund (“ Fidelity ”) for the APEs 28 February 2007 to 28 February 2010 inclusive; and (8) Henderson Emerging Markets Fund (“ Henderson ”) for the APEs 31 October 2006 and 31 October 2007.
4. The Test Cases had been selected from 129 closure notice applications and 177 appeals (with all others being stayed pending the outcome of this litigation) to resolve a series of issues (referred to as issues 1 – 11 and A – E in the CA Decision at [13] – [14]) in relation to claims concerning tax on dividend income which relate, almost exclusively, to holdings under 10% (“ portfolio holdings ”) by investment funds.
5. As in the hearing before the FTT in June 2021, the Upper Tribunal (“ UT ”) in June 2023 and the CA in January 2025, the Appellants were represented by Jonathan Bremner KC and HMRC by David Ewart KC, Barbara Belgrano and Laura Ruxandu. Their submissions, both written and oral, were very much appreciated and have been taken into account together with all of the materials and authorities to which I was referred, even if not mentioned in this decision. Test Cases
6. Before turning to the individual Test Cases, I need to address an issue that has arisen between the parties in Test Cases 1, 2, 4 and 5 in relation to the necessity and/or utility of recording, in this decision, the key facts and the impact and consequences of the CA Decision.
7. Mr Bremner contends that the effect of the decision of the UT (the “ UT Decision ” [2024] UKUT 23 (TCC) ) and the CA Decision is that the decision of the FTT (the “ FTT Decision ” ( [2021] UKFTT 459 (TC) ) has been set aside. As such, he says, that the facts found and outcome of the proceedings in the Test Cases should be recorded by the FTT in this decision otherwise questions will inevitably remain as to the status of earlier findings in the light of rulings by the UT. He contends that it is important for the parties that there is a set of findings and conclusions that are readily capable of being applied in the other cases (of which there are approximately 900) that are stood behind the lead cases.
8. However, although I agree with Mr Ewart that it is unnecessary to restate the facts, as these were agreed by the parties (see FTT Decision at [90]) and were not set aside by either the UT Decision or CA Decision, I have nevertheless referred to the paragraphs in the FTT Decision in which the background facts of the Test Cases are stated. The legal decisions and their application to those facts are clear from the CA Decision. Test Case 1: Schroder Asian for the APEs 31 January 1991 and 15 January 2009
9. The background facts are set out in the FTT Decision at [90(17)-(23)]). As agreed by the parties, the application made on 11 April 2019 by Schroder Asian, under paragraph 7 Schedule 1A Taxes Management Act 1970 (“ TMA ”), for a closure notice is refused. Test Case 2: Avon for the APEs 31 December 1997 to 31 December 2003 inclusive
10. The background facts are set out in the FTT Decision at [90(33)-(41)]. As agreed by the parties, the application of 9 April 2019 by Avon, under paragraph 7 Schedule 1A TMA for a closure notice is refused. Test Case 3: Baillie Gifford for APE 30 April 2005
11. The application by Baillie Gifford for a closure notice is refused.
12. In addition to that closure notice application, Mr Bremner contends that the Tribunal should make findings in this decision as to the claim for double taxation relief (“ DTR ”) on withholding tax (“ WHT ”) made by Baillie Gifford in a letter of 26 March 2010 which was not before the FTT in the 2021 hearing. The purpose of doing so, he says, is to provide a guide for subsequent cases and avoid any later suggestion that a letter in similar terms to that of 26 March 2010 does not amount to a valid claim.
13. However, it is accepted that Baillie Gifford had already made a valid claim for WHT in its returns (see FTT Decision at [209]). As Mr Ewart put it, a claim outside the return which asks for DTR (is a duplicate of a claim already included in a return) and is not itself a valid claim. As such, it is not necessary for me to say anything further in regard to the status of the 26 March 2010 letter and whether, if it stood alone, it amounted to a valid claim. Test Case 4: SLMM for the APEs 31 March 2004, 31 March 2005 and 31 March 2006
14. The background facts are set out in the FTT Decision at [90(8)-(16)]. As agreed by the parties, the appeal of SLMM is dismissed and its application for a closure notice refused. Test Case 5: Schroder European for the APE 15 January 2003
15. The background facts are set out in the FTT Decision at [90(24)-(32)]. As agreed by the parties, the appeal by Schroder European is dismissed and its closure notice application refused. Test Case 6: Schroder Institutional Growth for the APE 30 June 2004
16. The background facts are stated in the FTT Decision at [90(42)-(56)]. In the light of the CA Decision, the appeal by Schroder Institutional Growth (“ SIG ”) against the closure notice issued on 27 March 2020 is dismissed.
17. Following HMRC’s issue of a closure notice on 21 April 2026 into the enquiry opened into the “re-made” s 806(2) Claim (see FTT Decision at 90[54]-[56]) in advance of the hearing on 16-17 June 2026 and the protective appeal made against that closure notice referred to the Tribunal on 9 June 2026 (under reference TC/2026/02259), the parties have agreed that the quantum of DTR credit calculated at the FNR arising for SIG for the APE 30 June 2004 is £2,463 (as notified to the Tribunal on 28 August 2026). Test Case 7: Fidelity for the APEs 28 February 2007 to 28 February 2010 inclusive
18. The facts are set out in the FTT Decision at [90(57)-(69)].
19. It is agreed that to determine this case it is necessary to resolve two outstanding issues. The first, concerning the scope of the claims made by Fidelity in the letter from its representatives, Ernst & Young (“ EY ”), dated 31 March 2010, to HMRC; and the second, concerning the carrying forward of DTR.
20. Although it is partially set out in the FTT Decision at [90(61)], it is convenient to set out the terms of the EY letter of 31 March 2010 (the “ Letter ”) again in this decision. It stated: “This letter is in response to a telephone conversation with my colleague, James Marsom [of EY] on 29 March 2010, in relation to claims for credit relief for overseas withholding tax (WHT) and underlying tax suffered on dividends received from EU and EEA companies. As you are aware, the sub-funds of the above OElCs and the Investment Trusts (listed in the appendix), where applicable have filed their tax returns, since 2005, on the basis that EU and EEA company dividends are not taxable. Please accept this letter as a protective claim that, should it be found that these dividends are subject to UK corporation tax, each sub-fund will claim the full amount of credit relief available to it in relation to WHT and, in addition, should it be available, underlying tax suffered on such dividends. The countries of source, amounts of dividend and WHT have been included in the corporation tax computation for each sub-fund and investment trust. I trust that you will find this letter in order and I would appreciate confirmation on behalf of HMRC that the above treatment will apply.”
21. Mr Bremner contends that, because it refers to the “underlying tax”, the Letter is sufficient to count as a claim for credit in respect of all overseas dividend income that is received in the relevant accounting period. Alternatively, he contends that the letter must be accepted as a claim that Fidelity must be entitled to credit at the FNR for EU and EEA sourced dividend income.
22. Mr Ewart accepts that the Letter is a claim in relation to the EU and EEA sourced dividends but contends that it does not apply to non-EU and non-EEA dividends. He referred to the evidence before the FTT of Elizabeth Taylor, Head of Product and Operational Tax at FIL Investment Management Limited, on behalf of Fidelity. She is recorded by the FTT, at [96] of the FTT Decision, as saying that Fidelity filed its returns on an EU exemption basis. This, he says, is consistent with Fidelity’s statement of case which, at paragraph 8, referred to the Letter being a claim for credit for both WHT and tax on the underlying profits of EU and EEA dividend income. Similarly, the FTT Decision records, at [90(66)], that the closure notices for APE 2007 and APE 2008 did not give credit for WHT and/or underlying tax upon “EU/EEA income” requested by the Letter.
23. However, as Mr Bremner submits, Fidelity’s primary case is that, as set out in the parties’ ‘Agreed Statement of Facts’ and recorded in the FTT Decision at [90], it claimed credit for both WHT and tax on the underlying profits of that dividend income in the Letter as the term, “that dividend income”, was defined as “dividend income from non-resident investments in holdings below 10%”. This included, “dividends from countries outside the Member States of the European Union or European Economic Area” (see FTT Decision at [90(61)] and [90(59)] respectively).
24. In the circumstances, I accept Mr Bremner’s argument that there is no basis for HMRC to resile from those agreed facts which were accepted in the FTT Decision and the CA Decision.
25. However, even if that were not the case, although paragraph 54 of schedule 18 to the Finance Act 1998 requires a claim under any provision of the Corporation for relief, an allowance or repayment of tax to be for an “amount which is quantified”, it is clear from the judgment of the Chancellor in Claimants in Class 8 of the CFC and Dividend Group Litigation v HMRC [2019] 1 WLR 5097 at [100] – [101] that, in that case the taxpayer could have a valid claim under s 790 Income and Corporation Taxes Act 1988 (“ ICTA ”): “100. … even if it did not know at the time of claiming whether the correct claim was for the foreign tax actually paid on the dividends or the tax that would have been paid at the foreign nominal rate. The lack of knowledge of the precise rate at which the claim should be made may make it harder to make an effective claim, but it does not make it impossible in practice, as is required for the EU law principle of effectiveness to be violated.
101. Accordingly, the relief allowed by section 790 is not, I think, prevented from being an effective remedy because the taxpayers could not have been certain how much to claim under paragraph 54.”
26. In Fidelity’s case, a claim to underlying tax is made in the Letter which is quantified by reference to figures already provided. Therefore, as Mr Bremner submits, the Letter is a valid claim by Fidelity for credit at the FNR for both EU and EEA and non-EU and non-EEA sourced dividend income.
27. The second issue concerns the carry forward of DTR. In essence, the question that arises is whether a second claim is necessary. It is now common ground that a claim for DTR is necessary, however, where DTR has been claimed in Year 1 by a company that also has management expenses, which are set first against income producing a nil tax liability and there is therefore nothing for DTR to apply to, does that claim for DTR carry forward automatically (as Mr Bremner contends) or is a second claim necessary to apply the relief (as Mr Ewart contends)?
28. Mr Ewart accepts that although DTR claimed in Year 1 does carry forward, he contends, relying on the conclusions on issues 10 and 11 in the CA Decision, it does not apply until a (second) claim is made for it to be used in a particular year. In such circumstances, he says, the relief is not lost if a claim is not made in one year as it is carried forward and can be claimed in a subsequent year.
29. However, the issue before me is not the same as that considered by the CA in issues 10 and 11. Those concerned the position where there had not been an in-time Year 1 claim rather than the issue in the present case; namely whether a further claim for DTR is necessary if there has been an in-time claim in Year 1.
30. In the CA Decision at [201] Falk LJ said, in relation to DTR: “… It is common ground that DTR credits must be claimed. In that respect they are different to reliefs which are available (and indeed are carried forward) automatically, such as management expenses or indeed the ACT credits referred to in Prudential SC at [103]. Without a claim, DTR is not available as a credit. As a matter of principle, therefore, a credit cannot be said to arise and be unused, or be available for carry forward, unless it has been claimed in respect of Year 1. If it is claimed in respect of Year 1 but it cannot be used, then FII SC3 tells us that it must be carried forward and set off against future tax liabilities. There being no further domestic machinery, it will offset those tax liabilities as and when they arise. ” (emphasis added)
31. In my judgment it follows from that observation of Falk LJ that, as Mr Bremner submits, DTR must be carried forward in circumstances where a claim has been made in Year 1 (those carried forward DTR credits being automatically applied for set off against any tax liabilities arising in subsequent accounting periods) and, in the absence of the “machinery” for doing so, no further claim is required. Further Submissions
32. During the hearing it was suggested and agreed by the parties that, following the provision of a draft decision which included the Tribunal’s above conclusions in relation to the two outstanding issues in Test Case 7, the parties would liaise and agree the effect of this on the issues arising in this Test Case.
33. However, having given the matter some further thought, I considered that it would be a more efficient use of both the parties’, and the Tribunal’s, time and resources if my conclusions in relation to the issues in Test Case 7 were provided to the parties sooner as this would enable their agreed position to be incorporated into the final decision. Accordingly, directions were issued on 29 June 2026 (the “ Directions ”) under which the parties were required by, not later than 27 July 2026 to: “…provide the Tribunal with an agreed joint statement (or in the absence of agreement their respective submissions) in relation to the impact and consequences of the Draft Decision in relation to Test Case 7.”
34. Unfortunately, the parties were unable to reach agreement and, on 27 July 2026, provided their separate submissions to the Tribunal together with Excel spreadsheets supporting their respective calculations.
35. The parties differed in their approach to the calculations. HMRC calculated the Schedule D Case V income (and the corresponding FNR) on the net dividend treating Fidelity’s entitlement to WHT as a deduction under s 811 ICTA. Fidelity’s computations, for the reasons set out below (at paragraph 36(3)), treat the irrecoverable WHT as a EUFT credit (rather than a s 811 ICTA deduction). As a result the Schedule D Case V amount and FNR are calculated on the gross dividend amounts. It is submitted on behalf of Fidelity that this difference in approach does not make any material difference to the overall quantum.
36. However, Fidelity contends that there is a “significant” error regarding the figures for management expenses carried forward in relation to APE 28 February 2009 where HMRC incorrectly stated, originally in a letter of 23 July 2026 to Fidelity that the “less originally used” figure for management expenses was £5, 546 ,413 but should have been £5, 463 ,413, a difference of £83,000 less management expenses which has been carried forward to later accounting periods. Also, in its submissions responding to the Directions, Fidelity further contends that HMRC, in their letters of 21 July 2026 and 23 July 2026, omitted an income tax deduction of £36,000 which was recorded as a deduction in its return for APE 28 February 2009, in their calculations for this period.
37. In view of those errors and omissions, and in the absence of any further correction or explanation, having carefully considered the respective calculations provided by the parties, I have, on balance, preferred those submitted on behalf of Fidelity which, in contrast to those submitted by HMRC, are based on the following (which I have taken from Appendix 2 to Fidelity’s letter of 27 July 2026 to the Tribunal in response to the Directions): (1) The computations apply an entitlement DTR calculated at the FNR to all overseas dividends, including both EU/EEA and non-EU sources. This is consistent with its primary position (see paragraph 22, above), with which I agreed (see paragraph 23, above), ensuring that the maximum available DTR credit is recognised. (2) Fidelity have incorporated the automatic carry-forward of DTR credits that were blocked in earlier periods due to excess management expenses ensuring Fidelity receives the full benefit of its DTR credit entitlements over time. (3) The calculation of the amount of FNR credit and the corresponding gross dividend has been made consistent with the previous treatment of WHT in each of the submitted corporation tax self-assessment computations and is applied consistently between accounting periods and between all dividends: (a) The Fidelity MoneyBuilder UK Index Fund tax computation for APE 28 February 2007. This approach is consistent with each of the APEs 28 February 2005, 2006, and 2008. (b) The claim made for credit relief means that s 811 ICTA does not apply to treat WHT as a deduction. On the basis that the 31 March 2010 letter represents a claim for WHT, the calculations have been prepared on the same basis as for those dividends included in the original filed returns. On the basis that a valid claim for credit relief has been made, s 811 ICTA is precluded from applying a deduction. These circumstances appear to distinguish Fidelity’s position from the example provided in the CA Decision at [214]. (c) HMRC’s supporting calculations for the amount of FNR and corresponding gross dividend for APEs 28 February 2007 and 2008 have been made based on the assumption that no claim for DTR credit in respect of the EU source dividends has been made (and therefore s 811 ICTA operates to apply a deduction against the Schedule D Case V amount and the FNR credit and corresponding credit has been calculated on that net dividend amount). (d) The overall effect of this difference in approach is very small as the majority of dividends are attracting FNR in excess of 20%, ie. the impact on the tax liability in APE 28 February 2009 when the increase in the Schedule D Case V amount and the corresponding DTR credit is nil (except for the very small amount of Ireland dividends with a sub-20% FNR). (4) Fidelity are consuming more management expenses across the relevant accounting periods than in HMRC’s calculations albeit Fidelity are also incorporating an increased corresponding DTR credit at the FNR arising on the non-EU dividend income.
38. For the reasons above, I therefore accept the methodology and calculations submitted by Fidelity and confirm that corporation tax is repayable in accordance with the sums set out in the Appendix below. Test Case 8: Henderson for the APEs 31 October 2006 and 31 October 2007
39. The background facts are stated in the FTT Decision at [90(70)-(96)]. In the light of the CA Decision, the appeals against the closure notices issued by HMRC on 15 April 2020 are allowed in part: (1) in respect of the APE 31 October 2006, the conclusion in the closure notice is amended to allow Henderson WHT credit for portfolio dividends in the sum of £28,694; (2) in respect of the APE 2007 the appeal is dismissed; and (3) the closure notice issued by HMRC in respect of APE 2007 stands.
40. Following HMRC’s issue of a closure notice on 21 April 2026 into the enquiry opened into the “re-made” s 806(2) Claims for APEs 31 October 2006 and 2007 (see FTT Decision at 90[96]) in advance of the hearing on 16-17 June 2026 and the protective appeal made against that closure notice referred to the Tribunal on 9 June 2026 (under references TC/2026/02262), the parties have agreed that the quantum of DTR credit calculated at the FNR arising for Henderson for the APE 31 October 2006 is £36,233.84 and the APE 31 October 2007 £20,195.14 (as notified to the Tribunal on 28 August 2026). Baillee Gifford China Growth Trust PLC
41. Although not part of the Test Case litigation, I heard the appeal of Baillee Gifford China Growth Trust PLC (formerly Witan Pacific Investment Trust PLC) (“ BGCG ”) at the same time as, and together with, the Test Cases. This was in an attempt to resolve all outstanding issues between the parties and in accordance with directions that the appeal be heard and determined at the same time as the remitter of the Test Cases. With the agreement of the parties, the decision in BGCG has been released separately from, but at the same time, as this decision. Right to apply for permission to appeal
42. This document contains full findings of fact and reasons for the decision. Any party dissatisfied with this decision has a right to apply for permission to appeal against it pursuant to Rule 39 of the Tribunal Procedure (First-tier Tribunal) (Tax Chamber) Rules 2009. The application must be received by this Tribunal not later than 56 days after this decision is sent to that party. The parties are referred to “Guidance to accompany a Decision from the First-tier Tribunal (Tax Chamber)” which accompanies and forms part of this decision notice. Release date: 29 th SEPTEMBER 2026