UK case law
V Baker v The Governing Body of St Charles RC School
[2026] EAT 158 · Employment Appeal Tribunal · 2026
The verbatim text of this UK judgment. Sourced directly from The National Archives Find Case Law. Not an AI summary, not a paraphrase — every word below is the original ruling, under Crown copyright and the Open Government Licence v3.0.
Full judgment
Unfair and Wrongful Dismissal – Sufficiency of Reasons The Claimant, the headteacher of a primary school, was summarily dismissed for gross misconduct. The ET dismissed her claims of unfair and wrongful dismissal, finding that the Respondent had conducted a reasonable investigation, genuinely and reasonably believed the allegations, and acted within the range of reasonable responses. The ET further found that the Claimant’s conduct amounted to gross misconduct justifying her summary dismissal. On appeal, the Claimant contended that the ET had failed to provide adequate reasons, in particular by not sufficiently engaging with her case that witnesses were inconsistent and had colluded against her, by failing to address alleged deficiencies in the investigation of each allegation, and by failing to give separate and adequate reasons for dismissing the wrongful dismissal claim. Dismissing the appeal, the EAT held that the ET’s reasons, read fairly and as a whole, adequately explained why it had rejected the Claimant’s case and why it concluded that the Respondent had reasonable grounds for its beliefs following a reasonable investigation. The ET was not required to address every evidential contention advanced by the Claimant, provided that it dealt with the principal issues in dispute. The EAT further held that the ET had properly distinguished between the statutory unfair dismissal test and the contractual test for wrongful dismissal. Although its reasoning on wrongful dismissal was concise, the ET had made clear findings that the misconduct occurred and that, taken as a whole, explained how it amounted to a repudiatory breach of contract justifying summary dismissal. The appeal was dismissed. ANDREW BURNS KC, DEPUTY JUDGE OF THE HIGH COURT : Introduction
1. This is the Claimant’s appeal against the judgment of an Employment Tribunal (“ET”) sitting at Manchester (Employment Judge Dennehy, sitting alone) sent to the parties on 10 March 2023. The ET dismissed the Claimant’s complaints of unfair dismissal and wrongful dismissal. The Claimant had been summarily dismissed as headteacher of St Charles Roman Catholic Primary School on grounds of gross misconduct including allegations relating to smelling of alcohol at work, poor playground safeguarding, unprofessional conduct (including discussing two colleagues’ alleged relationship) and a breach of confidentiality during her suspension.
2. It is not in issue that the ET applied the well-known Burchell test about whether the Respondent had carried out a fair dismissal – in particular following a reasonable investigation and with a reasonable belief in the misconduct. The appeal concerns whether the ET adequately engaged with material aspects of the Claimant’s case and failed to make necessary findings in its judgment. In essence Mr Jupp KC for the Claimant says that the ET failed to provide sufficient reasons to explain why aspects of the Claimant’s evidence and submissions were rejected. In relation to the wrongful dismissal claim, the issue is once again whether the ET gave adequate reasons. The ET’s Findings of Fact
3. The Claimant had been headteacher of the Respondent school from 1 September 2010. The parties were subject to express confidentiality provisions, a whistleblowing policy as well as a disciplinary and dismissal procedure. The whistleblowing policy encouraged staff to raise concerns relating to safeguarding, professional conduct and other serious matters. The disciplinary procedure provided for investigation, suspension, disciplinary hearings and appeals.
4. In late December 2018 the Respondent received an anonymous written concern followed by a “serious staff concern” document supported by fourteen members of staff under the whistleblowing procedure. The allegations concerned the Claimant’s conduct and leadership and included allegations that she regularly attended work smelling of alcohol, had left pupils unsupervised in the playground while a staff photograph was being taken, publicly berated her deputy headteacher, behaved in an irrational, disorganised and unprofessional manner and spread rumours about two members of staff being in a relationship. She was also later alleged to have breached confidentiality during her suspension. Prior to these events, the Claimant had a clean disciplinary record and positive appraisals.
5. In January 2019 the Chair of Governors informed the Claimant that serious allegations had been received and commenced an investigation. The Claimant was signed off sick from work shortly afterwards and remained absent until July 2019. An occupational health assessment concluded that she was fit to participate in investigatory meetings. The Claimant raised a grievance alleging bullying and harassment by the two governors who were conducting the investigation. That grievance and the subsequent appeal were investigated and rejected. The investigation was subsequently continued by another governor after the original investigating governor resigned.
6. The Claimant was suspended on full pay from July 2019 after alternatives were considered and rejected by the Respondent. At investigatory meetings in November 2019 and March 2020 the Claimant, represented by her union, denied the allegations and maintained that all the staff members were colluding against her because they wanted her removed and preferred the deputy headteacher. During March 2020 an additional allegation was added that the Claimant breached confidentiality by disclosing details about the allegations to staff at another school. An adverse report was prepared and the matter was referred to a disciplinary hearing.
7. The disciplinary hearing took place over seven days between March and May 2021 before a committee of three co-opted governors with witnesses, cross-examination and documentary evidence. The committee found five allegations proved in full and one allegation partially proved. It concluded that the conduct resulted in serious safeguarding concerns about the Claimant, decided that there had been a fundamental breakdown in trust and confidence and found that the Claimant was guilty of gross misconduct.
8. The Claimant was dismissed summarily. She appealed. The appeal was heard in May 2022. The Claimant complained about the composition of the appeal panel and left the hearing, which proceeded in her absence. The panel treated the appeal as a rehearing. It upheld all six allegations, found that the investigation and disciplinary process had been appropriately conducted, rejected allegations of collusion and confirmed the decision to dismiss for gross misconduct. Conclusions of the ET
9. The ET concluded that the reason for dismissal was conduct. It found that the disciplinary and appeal panels genuinely believed that the misconduct had occurred. It found that those beliefs were reasonably held on the basis of the evidence obtained during the investigation and the evidence given by numerous staff witnesses. It did not accept the Claimant’s contentions that the allegations had been fabricated or that there had been collusion amongst staff members.
10. The ET examined each of the six allegations separately and concluded that there were reasonable grounds and a sufficient investigation in respect of each. It also looked at the overall picture and assessed the misconduct cumulatively. The ET found that the Claimant had a fair opportunity to answer the allegations and that the Respondent had reasonably rejected her defence that staff members were colluding against her.
11. The ET found that the Respondent had conducted a reasonable investigation and, although the disciplinary process was lengthy, the delays were adequately explained. Delays were caused by the Claimant’s sickness absence, her grievance and grievance appeal, the need for further investigations, Covid-related disruption, witness availability and arrangements for disciplinary and appeal panels. The ET held that the overall procedure, including the appeal process, fell within the range of reasonable responses open to a reasonable employer.
12. The ET rejected the procedural criticisms advanced by the Claimant, including challenges to the appointment and impartiality of governors, the conduct of the investigation, the absence of formal minutes, and the delay in convening hearings. It found that the Respondent had acted reasonably throughout and that none of the matters relied upon rendered the dismissal unfair.
13. The ET held that dismissal for gross misconduct fell within the band of reasonable responses despite the Claimant’s unblemished service as the misconduct involved serious safeguarding concerns and undermined the trust and confidence required in a headteacher. It therefore concluded that the dismissal was fair within the meaning of section 98(4) of the Employment Rights Act 1996 .
14. In relation to wrongful dismissal, the ET directed itself that it needed to decide whether the Claimant was in fact guilty of gross misconduct which amounted to a fundamental breach of contract. The ET held: 390…The claimant was as the Headteacher, the leader of the school and as such had to conduct herself in a professional manner. Her tendency to blame others and her lack of engagement with the seriousness of the nature of the allegations go to the very root of her contract of employment.
391. I bear in mind [ Laws v London Chronicle (Indicator Newspapers) Ltd [1959] 1 WLR 698 ] equates a fundamental breach with conduct which discloses a deliberate intention to disregard the essential requirements of the employment contract. In considering whether it was credible that so many of the claimant’s colleagues could be persuaded to collude against the claimant by making false allegations of misconduct I find that the claimant was guilty of the misconduct as set out in the allegations and that these allegations raised serious safeguarding concerns regarding the safety of the children and welfare of the staff and this was sufficient for the respondent to justify dismissal without notice. The Appeal
15. The Claimant was permitted by HHJ Beard on 23 May 2025 to substitute Amended Grounds of Appeal abandoning her original grounds. The amended grounds challenge the ET’s reasons in relation to the reasonable belief and investigation. The Claimant contends that the ET did not address her allegations that witnesses had colluded or that the Respondent had failed to investigate matters in her favour. In relation to allegation 1 (attending work smelling of alcohol) the Claimant says the ET failed to address matters affecting the credibility of witnesses or her case that third parties could have provided exculpatory evidence. She says the ET failed to consider her medical evidence or investigate telephone records which she said could have disproved an aspect of the allegation.
16. In relation to allegation 2 (children being left unsupervised) the Claimant contends that the ET needed to make findings on school practices regarding playground supervision, the role of pupils, and the absence of any adverse incident. In relation to allegation 3 (berating her deputy headteacher in public), the Claimant says that the ET failed to engage with the changing description of where the incident occurred and its significance on the reliability of the witnesses. She says it failed to address alleged deficiencies in the investigation into precisely what was said.
17. In relation to allegation 4 (her irrational, disorganised and unprofessional behaviour), the Claimant says that the ET failed to identify the particular incidents relied upon, failed to explain why it was reasonable to treat the conduct as misconduct rather than capability and failed to engage with contradictory evidence. On allegation 5 (her comments about staff in a relationship) the Claimant says that the ET’s reasoning does not make clear what conduct occurred, who heard the comments, or how changes in the factual basis of the allegation were addressed.
18. Allegation 6 was the breach of confidentiality during suspension and the Claimant says that the ET failed to determine whether the individuals to whom the Claimant broke confidence were ‘stakeholders’ for the purposes of the suspension instruction and the ET failed to address her explanations for discussing the disciplinary with staff at another school.
19. The Claimant also says that the ET failed to provide adequate and separate reasoning for its wrongful dismissal conclusion that she was guilty of gross misconduct. She says the ET failed to determine for itself whether the alleged conduct was proved and whether it amounted to a repudiatory breach of contract justifying summary dismissal.
20. The Respondent served a detailed Answer relying upon the reasoning of the ET. It submits that the ET was not required to make findings on every factual contention advanced by the Claimant and overall gave adequate reasons for its conclusions. The Respondent says that some of the matters relied upon on appeal were either not advanced before the ET or were immaterial to the statutory fairness questions. Legal Principles
21. The ET made a series of proper self-directions of law which are not challenged. Under section 98 of the Employment Rights Act 1996 the Respondent was required to establish a potentially fair reason for dismissal and, if it did so, the ET had to determine whether it acted reasonably in treating that reason as sufficient for dismissal in accordance with section 98(4) . In misconduct cases an employer must have a genuine belief in the employee’s misconduct, based on reasonable grounds and following a reasonable investigation and procedure. Procedural fairness is assessed by considering all the circumstances with regard to the ACAS Code of Practice, the employer’s own disciplinary procedure and the principles of natural justice. Fairness includes the appeal process and that defects at an earlier stage may be cured by an appeal, while deficiencies at appeal may render an otherwise fair dismissal unfair. The overall question is whether dismissal fell within the range of reasonable responses open to a reasonable employer.
22. An ET must take distinct approaches in claims for both unfair and wrongful dismissal. The s.98(4) question for the ET is not whether it would itself have dismissed or imposed a lesser penalty, but whether dismissal fell within the range of reasonable responses. A breakdown of trust and confidence may constitute a substantial reason supporting dismissal in some cases, although such a conclusion should not be reached too readily. The ET must consider whether the conduct was reasonably characterised as gross misconduct and whether dismissal was a reasonable sanction. However, when determining wrongful dismissal, the question is whether, as a matter of fact, the employee committed conduct amounting to a repudiatory breach of contract. Conduct that demonstrates a deliberate disregard of the essential obligations of the contract entitles an employer to terminate employment without notice.
23. When giving full written reasons, an employment tribunal must provide reasons sufficient to enable the parties to understand why they had won or lost. They must contain a summary of the essential findings of fact and an explanation of the reasons which led to its conclusions. The ET should identify the issues that were critical to the outcome and explain how they were resolved: Meek v City of Birmingham District Council [1987] IRLR 250 and English v Emery Reimbold and Strick Ltd [2003] IRLR 710 . The reasons must be sufficiently detailed to explain how the ET applied the law to its findings of fact and reached its conclusions: Greenwood v NWF Retail Ltd [2011] ICR 896 .
24. An ET must give its conclusions on any conflict of evidence on a significant issue of fact ( Levy v Marrable & Co Ltd [1984] ICR 583 ). It cannot simply repeat verbatim the submissions of one party or merely say that it preferred the evidence of one witness over another without more ( Kibirango v Barclays Bank plc UKEAT/0234/15 ). It does not need to address every evidential point or detail but just give such explanation so that the losing party can understand why their case failed. Those reasons must be read by the EAT fairly and as a whole. It is not legitimate to infer merely from the absence of a reference to particular evidence that the ET failed to consider it: DPP Law Ltd v Greenberg [2021] IRLR 1016 . Discussion and Conclusions
25. Mr Jupp for the Claimant says that ET failed to explain how it resolved critical disputes which were central to the lawfulness of the Respondent’s investigation and its belief in her misconduct. I will address each allegation in turn (as in the Amended Grounds) and then consider the reasons as a whole. However, my starting point is that this was a straightforward claim for unfair and wrongful dismissal. Written reasons in such cases can, and often should, be concise. The ET was required to identify the principal reason for dismissal, apply the correct legal test and explain in broad terms why it reached its conclusions. The reasons should show the application of the band of reasonable responses test and give reasons on any material procedural issue or challenge. In a misconduct case, the ET need only show that it applied the facts to the Burchell test and explain its reasons for each of the Burchell factors, as they are material to the particular claim. Where serious findings are made against a party the ET should be careful to explain the basis for those findings giving some detail so that the parties understand why they have won or lost. However it is not normally necessary for an ET to go through all the evidence considered by the employer during a disciplinary process or record reasons for every point of challenge raised by an employee. Although an ET must consider all the relevant points put before it, the reasons need only deal with the principal or important points which are disputed between the parties. It is not necessary to address every point. The EAT has pointed out that the reasons are directed at the parties who know in detail the arguments and issues in the case and so the reasons do not need to be spelt out in detail. Reasons should also be proportionate to the length and complexity of the claim. An unfair and wrongful dismissal claim heard within a few days does not require long or extensive reasons to explain to the parties the result and the main reasons for that result. It is not in accordance with the overriding objective to expect an ET to produce unnecessarily extensive reasons, particularly given the limited resources and the tremendous demands on judicial time caused by the growing backlog of claims. Allegation 1
26. The Claimant’s case was that the disciplinary allegations about her smelling of alcohol arose from collusion by members of staff. She says that the ET failed to engage with her challenges to the reliability of key witnesses, including alleged changes in the deputy headteacher’s account, the failure to obtain evidence from police officers, social workers and other professionals who had regular contact with her, medical evidence about her skin condition and telephone records.
27. Mr Tinkler for the Respondent (who also appeared below) points out that the ET addressed collusion and the Respondent’s reasonable assessment of the witness evidence. The ET said:
160. NMG in her oral evidence confirmed that she did consider the motivation of staff and she questioned them on this point and came to the conclusion that there was “no feasible explanation” in respect of collusion.
161. TM in his witness statement confirms that the panel found no evidence of collusion and the panel did not accept that the signatories to the SSC who were witnesses at the hearing were lying. TM went further to state that the panel had found inconsistencies in the claimant’s evidence and that she sought to blame others.
162. LHR in her witness statement says that the appeal panel did not find any evidence of collusion. LHR went on to state that all the witnesses in the appeal hearing stood by their original statements. …
170. The signatories to the allegations would have faced disciplinary action themselves had they been found to be making false allegations. I do not accept on the submissions made that there was evidence of collusion between the signatories to the allegations.
28. The ET engaged with these issues and in paragraphs 178-185 and 241-248 gave thorough reasons for rejecting the Claimant’s arguments. The ET noted that the Respondent interviewed all 14 complainants and found that 12 of them had direct experience of the Claimant smelling of alcohol. The other two gave indirect evidence. The ET found the Respondent, faced with numerous witnesses who made the same allegation, had reasonable grounds for its belief the Claimant committed the misconduct alleged in allegation 1.
29. The ET addressed the Claimant’s submissions that a rumour was allowed to fester and grow and why the Claimant’s medical history of rosacea (a skin condition) was not necessary for the Respondent’s Adverse Report. The medical evidence was irrelevant as multiple witnesses confirmed that it was not how she looked, but that she smelled of alcohol at school that was the cause for concern. The ET addressed the issue of whether a reasonable employer would have taken the relatively unusual step of interviewing witnesses outside its organisation about a sensitive matter and whether it should ask third parties whether the Claimant smelled of alcohol. It accepted the Respondent’s evidence was that the Claimant did not want the Respondent to contact anyone else. It was reasonable for an employer to investigate internally and not discuss sensitive allegations with third parties such as the police or social services. The ET addressed the Claimant’s argument that the complaints were malicious. The ET did not need to discuss why telephone records were not necessary for a reasonable investigation as the complaint of drunken phone calls late at night was not pursued. In any event it did make findings about this in paragraph 247. Whether or not the deputy headteacher was wrong about the Claimant ‘not looking right’ at an interview was not a significant factor in the case as it was not relevant to whether or not the employer could reasonably rely on multiple reports that the Claimant regularly smelled of alcohol. The ET noted at paragraph 361 that the Claimant admitted in cross examination that if the allegation of smelling of alcohol were true then it would be a serious issue. The ET’s judgment is thorough and the Claimant knows why the ET accepted that the Respondent had a reasonable belief after a reasonable investigation. Allegation 2
30. The Claimant submits that the ET failed to engage properly with the context of children being left unsupervised in the playground including the precautions she took, school practices concerning supervision, the absence of any adverse incident, and evidence said to undermine the characterisation of the incident as a serious safeguarding concern. The ET addressed these issues thoroughly. I agree with Mr Tinkler that this was a straightforward matter which did not require extensive analysis. In paragraph 251 the ET noted the Claimant’s arguments as to why this was not a serious matter “e.g. there was no formal procedure requiring the playground to be supervised at all times, it only took two minutes, that fact that a door was open and two trusted pupils were put on alert to come and fetch the claimant if anything had gone wrong.” The ET noted the evidence was that the Claimant left children unsupervised for 10 minutes. It also recorded that the Claimant accepted in her evidence that “this was not the correct course of action to take and that she would do things differently now”. The ET concluded that (whatever the context) the Claimant accepted that leaving a playground unsupervised was not correct and together with its other findings this clearly told the Claimant why she lost on this issue. Allegation 3
31. In relation to the allegation that she publicly berated the deputy headteacher, the Claimant contends that the ET failed adequately to address significant inconsistencies as to where the incident occurred and the implications of those inconsistencies for the reliability of the allegation. She further argues that neither the Respondent nor the ET identified with sufficient clarity what was actually said or why the conduct amounted to misconduct. The ET addressed the inconsistency directly in paragraph 255 recording that “The claimant would not accept that this was an error in the drafting of the allegation although it was accepted by the disciplinary panel.” It has already noted that:
192. When giving evidence TM said that the panel did consider there was an inaccuracy re location in that the event did not take place in the playground but had in fact happened in the classroom. He says that both witnesses found the situation distressing and found no reason for them to fabricate the allegation. It was accepted by the respondent that an error had been made regarding the location.
32. The ET addressed the inconsistency and noted that the Respondent had found the deputy headteacher and another witness ‘compelling’ and that they did not fabricate this ‘distressing situation’. The ET identified the misconduct – “the claimant publicly berated the Deputy Headteacher when he challenged her about the decision to leave the playground unsupervised”. The Claimant denied that any of this had happened. The ET concluded in paragraph 194 that “I find that based on the evidence that the respondent read and heard the respondent had reasonable grounds for believing the claimant was guilty of the misconduct raised in allegation 3”. This was a permissible conclusion and clearly tells the Claimant why she lost on this point. Allegation 4
33. The Claimant submits that the ET failed to explain which incidents were relied upon in Allegation 4 and does not explain its finding that the Respondent’s belief and investigation were reasonable (saying that allegation 4 should properly be characterised as capability). The ET does not set out any of the 45 aspects of this composite allegation, but found that examples of Allegation 4 were cited by the signatories to the complaint and that the Respondent found the Claimant’s position contradictory. One of the Claimant’s own witnesses said the Claimant “did not accept challenge and that she micromanaged staff”. The ET recorded that the Respondent did not make any finding that the Claimant was late for work. Mr Jupp KC criticised the ET for not addressing some of the 45 examples of irrational and erratic behaviour. At paragraph 264 the ET commented that the Respondent is a small junior school and although supported by the local authority had not conducted a thorough investigation of every example but the report included “only the more serious aspects of the whole whistleblowing complaint”. This was a reasonable approach taking into account the size and administrative resources of the employer. It was not important for reasonableness whether aspects of this allegation were conduct or capability, particularly as the Claimant denied it. The ET was entitled to look at the composite allegation to which there was a blanket denial and stepping back in paragraphs 195-199 and 259-266 gave adequate reasons for its decision. Allegation 5
34. The ET addressed Allegation 5 about mentioning a rumour of an affair between a teacher and her teaching assistant. There was a dispute about what the Claimant had said and the ET had to decide whether the Respondent had reasonable grounds to believe the teachers over the Claimant. The Respondent found that the witnesses to this incident were clear as to what was said and what was implied, even though the actual words used differed. The ET dealt with the Claimant’s point about a change in the witnesses’ evidence by explaining that first drafts of investigation statements had been sent to the Claimant by mistake. The ET addressed the point that the teaching assistant was not interviewed as he was not present. The Claimant had asked the Respondent not to discuss the allegations with anyone outside the complainants. The ET adequately explained its findings that the Respondent had a reasonable belief based on a reasonable investigation in respect of these allegations in paragraphs 200-205 and 267-271. Allegation 6
35. In relation to the Allegation 6 concerning impermissible contact during her suspension, the Claimant submits that the ET did not address whether the contacts were with ‘stakeholders’ within the suspension restrictions. The Claimant asked the investigator to contact the ex-teacher but did not approach her union representative about talking to her. Instead she directly approached a headteacher at another school and disclosed the matters in order to get permission to meet the ex-staff member. The ET records that the dismissing officer (‘TM’ - who was found by the ET to be a credible witness) decided that the Claimant was “wholly inappropriate, unprofessional and unjustified and the real reason for going to the other school was to intimidate that teacher”.
36. The ET addressed the stakeholder point directly (raising significant criticism of the Claimant) saying:
210. The claimant says this term stakeholder is not defined so the other teacher was not a stakeholder. The claimant did not accept that as a former member of staff, such a person would have been a stakeholder. The Adverse Report stated that an ex teacher clearly fell within the criteria of being a stakeholder. I find this is another example of the claimant’s tendency to focus and find fault with one fact rather than considering the potential harm of her actions.
37. The Claimant says the ET did not address her explanation that she was attempting to obtain evidence relevant to her defence. This is simply incorrect. The ET found that the substance of the allegation was not denied by the Claimant who said that she had tried to contact the other teacher “because she was frustrated at the delay of the appeal hearing” and “because the HR manager had refused to investigate allegations made against that teacher”. The ET explained that telling another headteacher about the allegations and details of the complainants was found to be “a clear breach of confidentiality” and noted the Claimant’s unsustainable contention that it was not misconduct as the individuals had not complained about a breach of confidence. Coupled with the evidence that this was believed to be an attempt to intimidate the teacher, the ET thoroughly explained its findings about reasonable belief and reasonable investigation in respect of this allegation. Wrongful Dismissal
38. Finally, in relation to wrongful dismissal, the Claimant submits that the ET’s reasoning was inadequate. She argues that the ET failed to explain why the conduct relied upon, whether individually or collectively, amounted to a repudiatory breach of contract justifying summary dismissal. It is said that the ET merely repeated its conclusions on misconduct without undertaking the distinct contractual analysis required for the wrongful dismissal claim.
39. It is an error of law for an ET to fail to make a clear distinction in its reasoning between the question whether an employee in fact committed misconduct and the question whether the employer reasonably believed that. Co-Operative Group Ltd v Baddeley [2014] EWCA Civ 658 states that where a claim is for both unfair and wrongful dismissal “it is very important that in such a case the tribunal clearly and carefully separates out its consideration of the two issues”.
40. Mr Jupp points out that the ET does not go through each of the 6 allegations and make findings of fact about whether the conduct occurred or not and whether it was so serious as to be gross misconduct. It did so in relation to both the issues of reasonable belief and reasonable investigation for the purposes of unfair dismissal. Having discussed the evidence of misconduct in the context of whether it supported a reasonable belief, I do not believe it was not necessary to go through each of the allegations individually to tell the parties why they won or lost. This is particularly because, as Mr Tinkler points out, some of the conduct was not in dispute. The Claimant admitted leaving 120 children unsupervised in a playground and admitted sharing details about the allegations with another headteacher.
41. The ET correctly directed itself in paragraphs 151-152 that “when it comes to wrongful dismissal the Tribunal is not concerned with the reasonableness of the employer’s decision to dismiss, but the factual question, was the employee guilty of conduct so serious as to amount to a repudiatory breach of the contract entitling the employer to summarily terminate the contract”. The ET said: “The Tribunal must therefore decide whether the claimant was guilty of repudiatory breach.” Having made extensive findings on unfair dismissal, the ET dealt with wrongful dismissal in concise terms.
42. The ET explained why the conduct amounted to a repudiatory breach of contract justifying summary dismissal. It first noted that the Claimant as headteacher was the leader of the school and was obliged to conduct herself in a professional manner. The ET found that her tendency to blame others and her lack of engagement with what the ET found was “the seriousness of the nature of the allegations” went to the “very root” of her contract of employment. That expression is taken from classic contract case law as describing a breach which is fundamental and repudiatory. The ET had found at paragraph 361 that the Claimant admitted that if the allegation of smelling of alcohol were true then it would be a “serious issue”. That was plainly correct and a serious matter of safeguarding on any view. The ET found at paragraph 368 that the Claimant was a long serving employee who ought to have been fully aware that her conduct fell short of the behaviour expected, particularly as “wilful neglect of health and safety in leaving the pupils unattended in the playground is an express example of gross misconduct within the respondent’s disciplinary and online safety policy”. This hardly needed explanation as it was obvious that a headteacher deliberately leaving 120 primary school children unsupervised in a playground for no good reason amounted to gross misconduct.
43. The ET had to find whether she committed the misconduct of which she was accused by her colleagues at the school. The ET considered “whether it was credible that so many of the claimant’s colleagues could be persuaded to collude against the claimant by making false allegations of misconduct”. The ET plainly took the view that it was not credible as it found that the Claimant was guilty of the misconduct “as set out in the allegations”. The ET then went on to decide for itself whether the misconduct it had found did in fact occur was so serious to amount to a fundamental breach of contract. The ET took into account that the allegations “raised serious safeguarding concerns regarding the safety of the children and welfare of the staff” and for this reason held it was sufficient for the Respondent to justify dismissal without notice.
44. The ET did not merely repeat its conclusions on unfair dismissal. The ET was not required to make findings on each individual allegation – it had to look at the Claimant’s conduct as a whole and decide whether the misconduct took place and whether it justified summary dismissal. It did draw (as it is permitted to do) on its findings about the credibility of the evidence. It found at paragraph 170 that it did not accept that there was “evidence of collusion between the signatories to the allegations”. The ET said at paragraph 189 that it found “the claimant’s evidence on the time it took to take the photograph not credible”. At paragraph 386 it commented that there were inconsistencies in her evidence and her evidence on the collusion issue was not credible saying, “By way of example the claimant’s stance of a blanket denials has not helped her case by way of example she refused to accept allegation 2 completely, based on incorrect location which the panel had already accepted was incorrect”. The ET in paragraph 245 preferred the “consistent and truthful” evidence of the Vice Chair, later Chair, of Governors to the Claimant’s “blanket denials, focus on minor factual inconsistencies and failure to engage with the substance of the allegation”. Conclusion
45. I have stood back and looked at the judgment as a whole. The ET’s reasons on unfair dismissal are clear, thorough and well-explained. Some of the matters now emphasised on appeal were not central issues before the ET. The reasons address the issues of reasonable belief and reasonable investigation in relation to each individual allegation and cumulatively. They take into account that the majority of the allegations were supported by a substantial body of staff evidence and were not dependent upon the credibility of any single witness. They are plainly Meek compliant. The ET’s reasons on wrongful dismissal are admirably brief. Those reasons tell the parties the essential reasons why they won and lost, adopting the distinct contractual analysis required for a wrongful dismissal claim.
46. For those reasons the appeal is dismissed.