UK case law

Zara Arif v Registrar of Approved Driving Instructors

[2026] UKFTT GRC 1396 · First-tier Tribunal (General Regulatory Chamber) – Transport · 2026

Get your free legal insight →Email to a colleague
Get your free legal insight on this case →

The verbatim text of this UK judgment. Sourced directly from The National Archives Find Case Law. Not an AI summary, not a paraphrase — every word below is the original ruling, under Crown copyright and the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Full judgment

1. This appeal was listed for determination on the papers only with the agreement of the parties.

2. The Appellant appealed against a decision of the Respondent dated 24 February 2026, to refuse the Appellant’s application for a second trainee driving instructor licence made on 31 December 2025. The decision of the Respondent was made, taking account of representations made by the Appellant on 23 January 2026, namely, that she had experienced episodes of ill-health, together with suffering a tragic miscarriage on 2 December 2025, resulting in her having to take time away from training, on the grounds that she, the Appellant, had not complied with the conditions of her first trainee licence by providing a training record in Form AD1 21AT within three months of the said trainee licence; that supporting evidence furnished by her showed that she was only unable to use her trainee licence for the purpose for which trainee licences are issued, at the end of the 6 month period; that Part 5(15)(3)(a) of the Motor Cars (Driving Instruction) Regulations 2005 require a minimum of 20 hours training to be completed within the first three months of the trainee licence period, whereas, in fact, the Appellant had not completed any hours of training within that period; that the sole purpose of a trainee licence is to afford the trainee an opportunity of giving driving instruction to members of the public while endeavouring to achieve registration; that the trainee licence system must not be allowed to become an alternative to achieving registration; that it was not the intention of Parliament that a trainee licence be issued for however long it might take a trainee to pass her Part 3 test; that 6 months experience of instruction provided a very reasonable period in which to reach the qualifying standard and, in particular, to obtain any necessary practical experience in tuition.

3. The Appellant submitted an appeal dated 27 April 2026 against the Respondent’s said decision on grounds that greatly elaborated upon her written representations to the Respondent on being advised that the Respondent was considering refusing her application, namely, details of her ill-health and tragic pregnancy outcome, which, taken together, she maintained, significantly reduced the hours when she could teach, eventually to zero. However, it was clear that this position only pertained towards the end of her trainee licence period and did not address her failure to complete any hours of training within the first three months of that period.

4. The Respondent, in his Response dated 27 July 2026, reiterated the above-mentioned reasons for refusing the Appellant’s application for a second trainee licence. In addition, he confirmed that the Appellant had failed her first attempt to pass her Part 3 test on 9 April 2026, while he, the Respondent, had cancelled another booked date on 12 March 2026, and that a second attempt by the Appellant to pass her Part 3 test was booked, but was on hold. The Response also submitted that the Appellant, if she wished to obtain further training, could attend a training course, or study or practice with an ADI or provide unpaid tuition and pointed out that many ADI applicants obtained registration as a fully qualified ADIs without ever holding a trainee licence, using such alternatives.

5. If the Appellant had been unable to meet the training conditions set out in his existing trainee licence due to the reasons advanced by the Appellant in her written representations, repeated in his Notice of Appeal, she could have surrendered his existing trainee licence back to the Respondent who then might well, in those circumstances, have looked more favourably on an application for a second trainee licence, as might the Tribunal have done in determining this appeal.

6. This appeal concerns a decision of the Respondent to refuse the Appellant’s application for a second trainee licence. The powers of the Tribunal in determining this appeal are set out in s.131 of the Road Traffic Act 1988 (‘ the Act ’). In determining the appeal, the Tribunal may make such order as it thinks fit, standing in the shoes of the Respondent, considering the decision afresh on the evidence available to it, giving appropriate weight to the Respondent’s reasons for their decision. The burden of proof in satisfying the Tribunal that the Respondent’s decision was wrong rests with the Appellant.

7. The essential basis of the Respondent’s decision was that the Appellant had been provided under his first trainee licence, more than adequate time to gain sufficient experience to pass her Part 3 test and that she had not complied with the conditions of that licence.

8. An appeal to this Tribunal against the Respondent’s decision proceeds as an appeal by way of re-hearing, that is, the Tribunal makes a fresh decision on the evidence before it. The Tribunal must give such weight as it considers appropriate to the Respondent’s reasons for its decision as the Respondent is the regulatory authority tasked by Parliament with making such decisions. The Tribunal does not conduct a procedural review of the Respondent’s decision-making process.

9. In reaching my decision I have taken into account all of the written evidence and submissions received by the Tribunal and considered all of the relevant circumstances of this appeal. To refuse this appeal is, on balance, the proportionate response in all the circumstances.

10. There was little or no dispute as to the material facts of this case.

11. Accordingly, the appeal is dismissed.

Zara Arif v Registrar of Approved Driving Instructors [2026] UKFTT GRC 1396 — UK case law · My AI Judge