FOS decisions / Open Banking
Open Banking
Financial Ombudsman Service final decisions, reproduced verbatim from the FOS published decisions register.
Decisions
17
Upheld
4
Not upheld
13
Avg redress
£233
Upheld complaints (4)
Intrum Mortgages UK Finance Limited
DRN-6285250A mortgage lender must communicate clearly and promptly with a customer seeking redemption, setting out in sufficient detail what documentation is required to meet regulatory requirements.
UpheldPlata Finance Limited
DRN-6261298Lenders must complete reasonable and proportionate affordability checks to ensure borrowers can repay debt sustainably, with the nature of checks varying based on credit amount, term, costs, and individual circumstances.
UpheldDecision DRN-6164429
A CIFAS fraud marker requires clear, rigorous evidence of identified fraud, not merely suspicion, and the account holder must be given an opportunity to explain their conduct before the marker is lodged.
UpheldNational Westminster Bank PLC
DRN-6285340A bank's gambling block functionality is limited to debit card transactions with regulated UK gambling merchants identified by specific MCC codes, and the bank cannot be held responsible for gambling transactions using alternative payment m
UpheldRedress £200
Not-upheld complaints (13)
HSBC UK Bank
DRN-6185588A civil dispute between a consumer and a payee over non-delivery or defective goods/services is not covered under the Faster Payment Scheme Reimbursement Rules, which only cover APP scams involving fraudulent deception.
Not upheldClydesdale Bank
DRN-6261154A recipient bank is not required to intervene in account transactions unless there is clear indication of suspicious activity, and payment recalls must be processed according to standard banking procedures without assumption of fraud.
Not upheldDecision DRN-6267289
A bank may only register a Cifas fraud marker if it has clear, relevant, and rigorous evidence showing the account holder was complicit in receiving fraudulent funds, not merely that they were unwitting.
Not upheldMonzo Bank Limited
DRN-6190986A bank may fairly load a negative fraud marker on the National Fraud Database only if it has clear, relevant and rigorous evidence that financial crime was committed and the account holder was complicit in receiving the fraudulent funds.
Not upheldDecision DRN-6273338
A bank may vary account terms and introduce fees where the account terms and conditions permit such changes and adequate notice is provided, even if marketing materials previously referenced free banking.
Not upheldRevolut Ltd
DRN-6302032A financial services provider is only liable for scam losses if they failed to intervene where reasonably expected and but for that failure the loss would have been avoided.
Not upheldDecision DRN-6231579
A firm may apply automated fraud prevention systems consistently across its customer base to delay high-value payments to new beneficiaries, even for genuine transactions, provided this is disclosed in its terms and conditions.
Not upheldDecision DRN-6266527
A lender acts responsibly if it conducts reasonable and proportionate affordability checks before lending, considering the borrower's income, existing commitments, and ability to sustain repayment.
Not upheldBarclays Bank UK PLC
DRN-6046396A bank is not required to intervene on sporadic gambling activity where accounts remain in credit and the customer is aware of available gambling blocks, unless activity reaches a level that should reasonably trigger concern.
Not upheldPayPal UK Ltd
DRN-6253207A consumer must provide sufficient evidence to establish they were the victim of a scam before a payment service provider can be held liable for failing to prevent or refund losses from that scam.
Not upheldDecision DRN-6207637
Where evidence is contradictory, decisions are made on balance of probabilities based on contemporaneous system records rather than recollection.
Not upheldBank of Scotland plc
DRN-6239631A bank must take appropriate steps to protect customers from authorised push payment fraud, with the duty to intervene scaling with the risk profile of transactions.
Not upheldStarling Bank Limited
DRN-5643782Banks are not required to provide forbearance beyond the built-in Pay As You Grow options for unregulated Bounce Back Loans, and must only agree to affordable repayment arrangements.
Not upheld