FOS decisions / Pension Transfer to SIPP
Pension Transfer to SIPP
Financial Ombudsman Service final decisions, reproduced verbatim from the FOS published decisions register.
Decisions
53
Upheld
29
Not upheld
24
Avg redress
£1,585
Upheld complaints (29)
Decision DRN-6288053
A pension transfer recommendation must be suitable having regard to the consumer's objectives, needs, existing benefits, costs, and attitude to risk, with proper explanation of fees and drawdown benefits.
UpheldMar 2026Decision DRN-6287827
Pension transfer advice must be suitable by properly considering the existing pension's benefits, the new arrangement's costs and features, and whether the switch aligns with the consumer's actual needs and attitude to risk.
UpheldMar 2026Decision DRN-6300071
Ongoing advice fees must only be charged where the advisor provides the agreed ongoing service, which must be clearly explained to the consumer.
UpheldMar 2026James Hay Administration Company Limited
DRN-6158440Pension transfer schemes must adhere to the TRIG framework's ten business day timeframe for cash transfers, with each step requiring two full working days plus the day of receipt.
UpheldRedress £2,577Jan 2026True Potential Investments LLP
DRN-6158458A SIPP receiving scheme is liable for delays in processing pension transfers that result in loss to the member through delayed reinvestment.
UpheldJan 2026iPensions Group Limited
DRN-5790055A pension provider must refuse a SIPP transfer if the financial adviser lacks appropriate regulatory authorization to advise the member in their jurisdiction of residence.
UpheldMar 2025Decision DRN-6255429
A regulated pension provider should query contradictory customer instructions and cannot claim tax relief on employer contributions, and must restore a customer to their position had the error not occurred.
UpheldRedress £200AJ Bell Management Limited
DRN-6099034A provider's temporary system error in displaying contribution tax year does not constitute a genuine error claim where the contribution was actually made in the correct year and the consumer had opportunity to correct it during the cooling
UpheldRedress £250Decision DRN-6282212
A financial services provider must handle pension transfers and tax-free cash calculations with reasonable care and must communicate clearly about timescales and the reasons for any differences in quoted versus actual amounts.
UpheldSuccession Wealth Management Limited
DRN-6295181A complaint about a fee charged by a regulated firm for services is within the ombudsman's jurisdiction if the fee relates to or is connected with regulated activities, regardless of whether the firm claims the services were unregulated.
UpheldEBS Pensions Limited
DRN-6262368A pension administrator must process surrender requests within a reasonable timeframe and maintain accurate records to prevent loss of intended dealing dates.
UpheldRedress £500Decision DRN-6299087
A lender may pursue legal action when a mortgage term ends and the borrower fails to repay or arrange refinancing, provided the lender has offered reasonable forbearance options.
UpheldRedress £300HSBC UK Bank
DRN-6272603A bank must reimburse customers who are victims of Authorised Push Payment (APP) scams under the Contingent Reimbursement Model Code, unless specific exceptions apply.
UpheldRedress £16,000Sirius Wealth Management LLP
DRN-6273381Pension transfer advice must include a detailed comparison of charges between the existing and receiving schemes and must be justified by the consumer's specific circumstances, not generic reasons.
UpheldPPA Wealth Ltd
DRN-6160206A firm providing ongoing advisory services must actually deliver those services to justify charging ongoing adviser fees.
UpheldRedress £1,250Decision DRN-6249120
A business must provide clear and consistent information to consumers about the timing of key documents, and should correct misleading verbal advice promptly.
UpheldRedress £100Profile Financial Solutions Limited
DRN-6202606Financial advisers must recommend investments suitable to a consumer's stated attitude to risk and circumstances; unsuitable fund recommendations in a pension transfer can constitute advice failure even if the transfer itself was justified.
UpheldDecision DRN-6250008
A pension adviser must present all reasonable options available to a client, including accessing tax-free cash from existing schemes without transferring, before recommending a pension transfer.
UpheldDecision DRN-6222765
A pension provider must provide fair service, manage customer expectations appropriately, and avoid causing financial detriment through administrative delays and errors.
UpheldPathlines Pensions UK Limited
DRN-6110276A pension provider must process pension transfers promptly and clearly communicate requirements to avoid delays that cause financial loss to the member.
UpheldInteractive Brokers (U.K.) Limited
DRN-5756536A broker must provide clear information about account structure and segment requirements, and must process time-critical fund transfers promptly to avoid losses from forced position closures.
UpheldRedress £400Scottish Widows Limited
DRN-6184638A provider should compensate for losses directly caused by its delays, but only where it is reasonably certain the investment would have been made but for the delay.
UpheldRedress £525Quai Investment Services Limited
DRN-6266564A pension provider must process pension transfer requests promptly and efficiently, without causing unreasonable delays that result in financial loss to the consumer.
UpheldQuai Investment Services Limited
DRN-6266554A pension transfer administrator must process transfer requests within a reasonable timeframe and cannot use increased workload from a business acquisition as justification for substantial delays.
UpheldLondon & Colonial Services Limited
DRN-5593307A SIPP operator must ensure that investments held within the pension are appropriate and that it takes reasonable steps to prevent unsuitable investments.
UpheldAviva Life & Pensions UK Limited
DRN-6230081A pension provider must give accurate information about how pension savings will be valued and invested when a member reaches age 75 and transfers to a SIPP.
UpheldOrigen Financial Services Limited
DRN-5977214On termination of an ongoing advice agreement, a financial adviser is only entitled to charge for the proportionate amount of service already provided, not full monthly charges.
UpheldOptions UK Personal Pensions LLP
DRN-6032601A SIPP provider must carry out adequate due diligence on unregulated introducers to ensure compliance with regulatory obligations before accepting pension transfers.
UpheldInvestment Funds Direct Ltd
DRN-4459847A SIPP platform operator must conduct adequate due diligence on securities and DFMs before permitting their use, including scrutinising conflicts of interest where a DFM and bond issuer are part of the same group.
Upheld
Not-upheld complaints (24)
Decision DRN-6179490
Complaints about events occurring more than six years before the complaint is made fall outside the Financial Ombudsman Service's jurisdiction under DISP 2.8.2R, unless exceptional circumstances apply or the respondent consents.
Not upheldFeb 2026Decision DRN-6221142
Pension transfer requests to overseas accounts must comply with UK pension legislation, regulatory requirements, and anti-fraud obligations including verified address verification and QROPS transfer documentation.
Not upheldFeb 2026Decision DRN-6213205
A firm must handle pension transfer and annuity processes with appropriate coordination and without unnecessary delays or administrative errors.
Not upheldOct 2025Quilter Financial Planning Solutions Limited
DRN-6128764Trail commission established before RDR was not intended to cover ongoing advice services and continued to be payable to the servicing agent regardless of whether ongoing service was provided.
Not upheldDecision DRN-6242110
A pension provider must give accurate information about pension benefit options available to members claiming serious ill health retirement, and compensation should reflect the inconvenience caused by errors in that information.
Not upheldGrove Pension Solutions Ltd
DRN-6275425A financial adviser must conduct a proper fact-find and assess vulnerability when advising on pension transfers, particularly for clients with health conditions affecting their capacity to make informed decisions.
Not upheldAviva Life & Pensions UK Limited
DRN-6271914A business must take reasonable steps to remedy its administrative errors, but is not responsible for failures to communicate if it has attempted contact through proper channels and received no response.
Not upheldLegal and General Assurance Society Limited
DRN-6255376A provider is not responsible for delays in pension fund transfers beyond its control, and must clearly communicate to consumers the distinction between the date funds are requested and the date annuity payments commence.
Not upheldPhoenix Life CA Limited
DRN-6255403A pension provider is not responsible for market value fluctuations between quotation and transfer completion when the transfer is processed within reasonable service standards and on the date instructed by the receiving provider.
Not upheldDecision DRN-6243496
A creditor is entitled to pursue a valid, non-statute-barred debt even where the debtor is elderly and vulnerable, though fairness considerations may apply to the enforcement approach.
Not upheldAviva Life & Pensions UK Limited
DRN-6155903A pension provider must accurately record and communicate fund holdings and unit prices to the customer, but is not required to provide online access to pricing information if the product terms permit alternative access methods.
Not upheldJ.P. Morgan Personal Investing Limited
DRN-6257289An ISA must receive at least one subscription in a tax year to remain active; if no contribution is made, it becomes inactive and cannot accept further subscriptions without reactivation, regardless of whether contributions are below the an
Not upheldDecision DRN-6158076
A transferring pension scheme must carry out due diligence and provide clear warnings about pension liberation risks, but cannot ultimately prevent a transfer if the member insists after a cooling-off period.
Not upheldEQ Investors Limited
DRN-6159232A firm is not responsible for losses resulting from market timing decisions when it has provided accurate information about settlement procedures and the consumer proceeded with their instructions despite understanding the implications.
Not upheldDecision DRN-6298234
A pension transfer service provider is not responsible for delays caused by the receiving pension scheme's external systems and processes, provided the provider takes all reasonable steps to expedite the transfer.
Not upheldDecision DRN-6174898
A transferring pension scheme's obligation to provide warnings about transfer risks is satisfied where comprehensive written warnings about specific dangers are provided and acknowledged by the customer.
Not upheldDecision DRN-6140747
A pension provider may reasonably suspend withdrawals from illiquid assets where the fund terms permit such suspension, even if it extends beyond initial timeframes communicated to investors.
Not upheldDecision DRN-6169308
Suitability of investment advice and transfer recommendations must be assessed against the client's objectives and risk appetite, with charges properly disclosed.
Not upheldGrove Pension Solutions Limited
DRN-5814673An adviser cannot be expected to disclose at the abridged advice stage information about specific pension providers' insistent client policies when the adviser's recommendation is not to transfer.
Not upheldSkipton Building Society
DRN-6292845An adviser's error in misinterpreting internal guidelines about pension contribution eligibility does not result in permanent financial loss if the consumer can make the contribution in a subsequent tax year and receive equivalent tax relie
Not upheldDecision DRN-5696218
An adviser is not responsible for suitability of arrangements inherited from a previous adviser, but must ensure any new recommendations are suitable within the constraints of existing arrangements.
Not upheldDecision DRN-6127185
Pension transfer advice must be suitable based on the consumer's attitude to risk and capacity for loss, considering the overall portfolio composition and available alternatives.
Not upheldPrudential Assurance Company Limited
DRN-6174893A pension provider must conduct appropriate due diligence under the Occupational and Personal Pension Schemes (Conditions for Transfers) Regulations 2021 to protect consumers from pension scams, but must do so reasonably and not request inf
Not upheldInvestAcc Pension Administration Limited
DRN-6033634Receiving pension schemes may impose higher safeguards than the minimum legal requirement and can require financial advice for DB transfers below the £30,000 statutory threshold.
Not upheld